Andrew Tyrie Attacks Government's 'Incoherent' Growth Strategy

George Osborne Andrew Tyrie

First Posted: 01/10/11 08:22 Updated: 01/10/11 12:40

A senior Conservative MP has attacked the government's plans for growth as inconsistent and incoherent on the eve of the Conservative Party conference.

Andrew Tyrie, the chairman of the Commons Treasury committee, told the Times that despite talk of the need to tighten its belt, the government had not come to terms with the true state of the economy.

He said the current policy agenda mistakenly reflected the "priorities of the middle of the past decade, when David Cameron expected to inherit at least acceptable economic conditions".

"The Big Society; localism; the green strategy - whether right or wrong; these and other initiatives have seemed at best irrelevant to the task in hand, if not downright contradictory to it; likewise the huge spending hike on overseas aid and the cost of the Libyan expedition," he said.

"But the age of abundance has been replaced by the age of austerity. Current policy does not recognise that face."

"There is much to do, and it is not just a question of gaps in policy," he said. "A coherent and credible plan for the long-term economic growth rate of the UK economy is needed."

He said that while he supported the government's immediate plan to tackle the debt crisis it had a "long way to arrive at a coherent strategy" and that "in places it is inconsistent, even incoherent".

Shadow Treasury minister Chris Leslie said George Osborne should heed Tyrie's warning.

“With unemployment rising again and the recovery choked off last autumn, the Conservative chair of the Treasury select committee is right to say that the government does not have a credible and coherent plan for economic growth," he said.

“It’s time the Chancellor started listening to people like Andrew Tyrie, as well as the CBI and Federation of Small Businesses who have also warned in the last few days that the government needs to do more."

Tyrie's criticism comes on the eve of the Conservative Party conference in Manchester where the economy is likely to dominate proceedings.

In an interview with the Daily Telegraph Osborne said the coalition was doing "everything it could to stimulate growth in the economy but appeared to rule out tax cuts in the near future.

"My first priority is to deal with the deficit. I don't want to be a Chancellor who cuts taxes one year and has to put them up the next," he said.

"A country with an almost double-digit deficit cannot add to its deficit in the middle of a sovereign debt storm to cut tax, presumably on a temporary basis, because you would have to then put it back up again to deal with the deficit. Tax cuts should be for life, not just for Christmas."

He added: "We have plenty of economic issues to discuss -- we've got the situation in the eurozone, the situation in the world economy. We are doing everything we can to get the British economy moving. That is where my energy is spent."

Osborne will use the conference to announce plans to change employment law so workers can only sue companies for unfair dismissal after two years rather than 12 months.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

A senior Conservative MP has attacked the government's plans for growth as inconsistent and incoherent on the eve of the Conservative Party conference. Andrew Tyrie, the chairman of the Commons Tre...
A senior Conservative MP has attacked the government's plans for growth as inconsistent and incoherent on the eve of the Conservative Party conference. Andrew Tyrie, the chairman of the Commons Tre...
Filed by Ned Simons  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:35 on 02/10/2011
Sound like a Republican to me
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Lantin
Writer.
01:33 on 02/10/2011
Sir

Andrew Tyrie does know what he is talking about.

He had excellent academic qualifications as well as being a Fellow of Nuffield College, Oxford.

He worked in the UK Treasury as an advisor to Nigel Lawson and to John Major (when each of them was working as Chancellor of the Exchequer).

Andrew Tyrie is also an expert on European economic affairs and worked as senior economist at the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development.

I hope that the Cameroons listen to him. They should.

Sincerely, Derek Lantin. http://dereklantin.booksabuzz.com
23:27 on 01/10/2011
Well at least we now know of 4 things they will talk about over the next few days.

Rise in motorway speed limit.

Return of weekly bin collections.

111 NHS in place of Real A&E Depts...

Maximum of 1 year 11months and 29 days work for the unemployed.......

Don't you all have the feel good factor now?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Blockem1
When will our politicians start putting policies
22:39 on 01/10/2011
"Osborne said the coalition was doing "everything it could to stimulate growth in the economy",

What if any thing are they doing ............. sorry lets not forget there is the extra money for the bin collections ! understandable really when you consider the utter rubbish he is coming up with.
22:38 on 01/10/2011
All three parties are incoherent.

What the UK has right now are Blue Tories, Yellow Tories and Red Tories.


Crying out for a proper social democrat party
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Lantin
Writer.
01:38 on 02/10/2011
When Deng Xioau Peng was running China, he said

"I don't care what colour a cat is, as long as it catches mice"

I do not care what colour this government is, as long as it can sort out the lamentable state of this country's finances and as long as they can provide some real leadership.

So far, I have been badly disappointed.

Regards, Derek
21:54 on 01/10/2011
idiot osbourne still cant see the wood for the trees, tunnel vision won't solve a crisis and though I like to drive around the 80 mark The only way I see this helping the economy is increased revenue from inefficient use of fuel, any more brill ideas from the Tory think tank, ha ha ha ha ha
20:33 on 01/10/2011
Don't panic - at least you might get your bin collected every week. Whether you can afford to put anything in it is another matter ! Can bin lorries do 80mph on the High Street ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Lantin
Writer.
01:41 on 02/10/2011
Their collections are so slow that I think they move at 5mph and a man with a red flag walks in front of them.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Haselden
An Enemy of Rupert Murdoch, since 1984.
18:34 on 01/10/2011
What happened to "You were only supposed to rip the bloody poor off?"
17:26 on 01/10/2011
The Government have a growth strategy?...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Haselden
An Enemy of Rupert Murdoch, since 1984.
18:36 on 01/10/2011
I know , It came as a shock to me, too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
obeliskpress
Muddy water, let stand, becomes clear.
13:36 on 01/10/2011
Diminish workers' rights to 'boost the (slave) economy.'
Sweet Tory medicine.
photo
BeeJayCeee
I still loathe Thatcher
12:36 on 01/10/2011
Wait, what?! Tory boy and Tory boy 2 don't know what they're doing?! Political dogma instead of a credible economic recovery plan?! Who'da thunk it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Haselden
An Enemy of Rupert Murdoch, since 1984.
18:37 on 01/10/2011
Shhhhhhh, these Eton types don't take criticism too well. There could be tears, tantrums or massive redundancies.
photo
BeeJayCeee
I still loathe Thatcher
22:05 on 01/10/2011
I always find it incredibly difficult to understand what it is they're going on about. Whenever they open their mouths, all I can hear is a silver spoon rattling around.
10:47 on 01/10/2011
The thing that worries me is how devoid of ideas Cameron, Clegg & Osborne seem to be now it's clear 'Plan A' isn't working.

The day before yesterday the government were claiming that raising the speed limit on the motorways to 80mph would boost the economy. If that isn't grasping at straws I don't know what is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
09:53 on 01/10/2011
They do not have any strategy, that is the trouble, they must form policies to stimulate growth
09:35 on 01/10/2011
You don't need to have a masters in Keynesian economics to realise that the Tories are getting this all wrong. No change there then.