Abortion 'Does Not Increase Woman's Risk Of Developing Mental Health Problems'

Abortion

First Posted: 09/12/11 06:51 GMT Updated: 09/12/11 07:03 GMT   PA

Having an abortion does not increase a woman's risk of suffering mental health problems, according to the world's biggest review of the issue.

It makes no difference to a woman's mental health whether she chooses to have an abortion or continue with the pregnancy, researchers found.

Women with unwanted pregnancy do have a higher incidence of mental health issues than those in the general population, but the rates of problems are the same whether a woman opts for a termination or goes on to give birth, according to the report commissioned and published by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges.

The report, which included data on hundreds of thousands of women in 44 previous studies, was carried out by the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health at the Royal College of Psychiatrists.

Professor Tim Kendall, director of the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health, said 11% to 12% of the general population suffer depression and anxiety but this rises to about a third of women who have an unwanted pregnancy.

Prof Kendall said that having an unwanted pregnancy may cause mental health problems, a woman may already have problems before becoming pregnant, or it could be a combination of the two.

The experts found that women who had a history of mental health problems before having an abortion were more likely to suffer problems after the procedure.

Factors that may potentially increase the risk of mental health issues after an abortion included women being pressurised by a partner to have an abortion, stressful events, or the woman herself having a negative attitude towards abortions.

Prof Kendall said: "There is a separate debate, which is about the ethics and about legal abortion, illegal abortion, the physical consequences, which are not part of our report.

"We are simply saying that with regard to the mental health outcomes, we should now shift our attention to the problems associated with unwanted pregnancy, not abortion."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

Having an abortion does not increase a woman's risk of suffering mental health problems, according to the world's biggest review of the issue. It makes no difference to a woman's mental health whet...
Having an abortion does not increase a woman's risk of suffering mental health problems, according to the world's biggest review of the issue. It makes no difference to a woman's mental health whet...
Filed by Stephen Hull  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 39
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:11 PM on 01/07/2012
I do not like abortion, I consider it to be murder, sorry but that is me, the child did nothing wrong.
What I would encourage is the free access to contraception for all.
There are too many people on our small planet.
Much better to spend our aid money on condoms and pills than any other aid.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fenrir Lokison
I luv the sci fi of Evolution and the Big Bang
05:56 AM on 01/07/2012
Of course it does in some people. It is no different than someone who miscarries or have a still birth. The child is attached to them. Their is a human being in the womb. Someone with a spirit, a mind, and a body. And to make a willing decision to kill that baby can have a profound effect.
09:36 PM on 01/06/2012
What about the mental problems of the abortionists? You would think taking that much life would cause mental problems. We accept that someone who tortures animals is likely psychotic why not someone that dismembers fetuses?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
02:54 PM on 01/07/2012
Abortionists aren't torturing anything, nor are they 'dismembering fetuses' as you so hysterically and inaccurately put it.

The collection of cells removed in a typical abortion would fit into an eggcup.

Abortion is often used to save life.
photo
George From NYC
Warren in 2016
12:24 AM on 12/20/2011
No, abortions do not lead to mental health problems, but I bet if you did a study, you might find that being a rabid evangalist will lead to mental health problems.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
02:48 PM on 01/07/2012
That's a good point - does being a fundamentalist make you unhinged or does it attract crackpots in the first place?
This comment has been removed.
11:13 AM on 12/10/2011
I think the intelligence of those with unwanted pregnancies should be a good area for research.
It is so easy to get contraception, even easier to say NO, unless of course you are drunk or drugged up.
photo
George From NYC
Warren in 2016
12:25 AM on 12/20/2011
or raped
09:02 PM on 12/20/2011
Fair comment.
Like most, I try to push that thought way to the rear, I am a parent, and such thoughts are distressing.
Sorry for forgetting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fenrir Lokison
I luv the sci fi of Evolution and the Big Bang
06:00 AM on 01/07/2012
Far less occurrence than those who do it because they don't want to loose their lifestyle just yet.

And even still, there are several who also feel the same loss after they have the abortion. As if they were sentencing an innocent to death for what someone else did.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
03:00 PM on 01/07/2012
Welcome to the real world where not one form of contraception is 100% effective.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Yorksgal
'Conservative Christian' is a complete oxymoron.
03:45 AM on 12/10/2011
Well duh! Was the headline supposed to spread fear and angst?
01:32 AM on 12/10/2011
That was a misleading headline. It should have read "Abortion does not link to mental health issues"
08:38 PM on 12/09/2011
I have just been having a discussion on another site about how there are many different factors that shape personality, character or beliefs. I was very lucky that when I found myself pregnant at a young age (despite taking precautions) that I had a sensible, straightforward Doctor who gave me the information I needed without pushing his opinion of what I should do. The person I was was able to go through with a termination and has never suffered any negative affects because of this. Looking back it would have been an awful mistake to go through with the pregnancy. Yet another woman in exactly the same circumstances may have ended up feeling the opposite of this. It's sad that often instead of getting the proper support she needs a woman is used by either the anti or pro abortion lobby for their own ends.
07:33 AM on 12/12/2011
There is no such thing as a "pro-abortion" lobby.
photo
George From NYC
Warren in 2016
12:31 AM on 12/20/2011
Tell that to the republicans who try to impose their religious views in the world of science.

I'm happy that you made your own decision. If republicans get their way, there will be no decisions made by anyone other than the religious yahoos that get their kicks by telling others how to live their lives.

What is the new law they are trying to pass? Oh yes, to make a woman seeking an abortion have a sonogram. Is that a medical necessity? How would that law have made you felt?
There is no “pro-abortion” lobby, it’s called liberty, freedom and the right to privacy.
09:39 PM on 01/06/2012
"There is no “pro-abort­ion” lobby, it’s called liberty, freedom and the right to privacy."

Except for the fetus's liberty and freedom.
10:24 AM on 12/09/2011
Many GPs use leaflets from pro-life groups in their surgeries to provide information about abortion (and its supposed risks) to pregnant women. Not because GPs are necessarilly pro-life, but because the leaflets are free. The leaflets state that post-abortion depression is a serious and common side-effect of termination. As research has shown that post-abortion depression is a myth manufactured by pro-lifers, can we hope that (a) these leaflets are withdrawn and (b) the pro-life psychiatrists who've been making a very good living as specialists offering "treatments" for this "condition" will now get proper jobs?
12:22 PM on 12/09/2011
What surgery do you go to. I find it far easier to get hold of abortion leaflets.
03:28 PM on 12/09/2011
SPUC (Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child) distributes free "information" leaflets to GP surgeries throughout the UK. As these are often the only easily available leaflets on abortion, GPs often give them to women considering termination of pregnancy despite the SPUC leaflet's heavy-handed pro-life agenda.
10:11 AM on 12/10/2011
I think research in this area is tainted and is corrupted by a huge number of variables. Lots of women have baby blues and lots of women on the long term sick with depression will have had children, so you could argue that having children causes mental health problems. So you're damned if yo do and you're (not now) damned if you don't so to speak. I always think it would be easy to prove that drinking iced drinks causes skin cancer.
03:32 PM on 12/09/2011
Dr Davenport's review of the meta-analysis in American Thinker so distorts the evidence from the research that it is unrecognisable. Her discussion may sit well with pro-life readers who simply want their prejudices reinforced, but anybody looking at the actual meta-analysis (rather than relying on Dr Davenport's highly individual interpretation) will immediately see that the evidence does not support her position.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
nikanj
free the fnords
06:00 PM on 12/09/2011
An abortion can be a great relief, a great trauma, or both.
It all depends on the circumstances.
Regardless, the decision and the outcome are private matters
for the woman, her partner, and her health care provider.
07:43 AM on 12/12/2011
No, one person with questionable methodology and a declared political agenda says the opposite, and then she published her study on a site that has a political bias, and is known for as a propaganda site for the anti-choice ideology.

http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/199/3/180.abstract/reply#bjrcpsych_el_34304

These are the responses from people in the field who had some issue with the author's (please note the singular here, you're only pointing to ONE study done by ONE author) methodology, and application of epidemiology.
This comment has been removed.