Meryl Streep Shines As Margaret Thatcher - But How Accurate Is 'The Iron Lady'?

The Iron Lady

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 15/12/2011 07:58 Updated: 13/02/2012 10:12

The Iron Lady is among us, with Meryl Streep's uncanny portrayal of Margaret Thatcher, both in her dotage and - through flashback - seen in her prime, earning accolades and inevitable Oscar-talk. But alongside the praise for the acting of Streep and co-star Jim Broadbent are mutterings that the film casts a Hollywood glow over one of the most dividing eras of recent political history. So just how accurate is this film? HuffPostUK Political Editor Chris Wimpress casts his eye over five pieces of dramatic licence:

Earlier this week at a private screening for Tory politicians, a producer made a statement to the audience beforehand, saying the film isn't designed to be a factual depiction of her life. It is a loosely-based piece of fiction, they claimed.

They were heading off the inevitable howls from political types. First of all there's the hat. Tories who were around in the seventies - and there's enough of them - insist Thatcher never, ever wore one in the Commons.

The opening of the film - in which a demented elderly Thatcher stumbles through the streets of London - could never happen. All former PMs have extensive security and the arrangements for Thatcher in particular mean the idea of her being jostled by randoms in the way the film suggests is the height of artifice.

The much-trailed imagery of protesters slamming their fists on the window of Thatcher's car as PM during unrest over the much-reviled poll tax never happened. Politicians rarely get so close to such hot zones, and never did. This was one of several scenes which tried to paint a "little England" picture to appeal to an American audience.

The Airey Neave scene is entirely fabricated. Neave, Thatcher's Northern Ireland spokesman during her time in opposition, was killed by a bomb planted by the Irish National Liberation Army. The film shows Thatcher saying goodbye to Neave, one of her favourite political colleagues, only minutes before. In fact, she was not remotely near the car-bombing and found out about it hours later.

Even in her dotage, Thatcher doesn't live her days in isolation. She has a busy agenda and, though there's no denying she has dementia, sources close to Lady T insist she remains lucid, frequently pointedly so.

FILM REVIEW: So there's five pieces of dramatic licence for you - click here for five reasons it's a stonking good piece of big screen drama

The Iron Lady is an ultimately sympathetic gloss on Thatcher, painting her opponents as either idiotic or self-serving. As a piece of Tory propaganda, it's something money can't buy, and the issues around striking and Europe have resurfaced at a weirdly opportune moment to chime in with the film's release.

Tories will take the glaring inaccuracies with a pinch of salt, because as a reminder of working class Tory principles, they're getting a massive freebie in this film.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK ENTERTAINMENT

The Iron Lady is among us, with Meryl Streep's uncanny portrayal of Margaret Thatcher, both in her dotage and - through flashback - seen in her prime, earning accolades and inevitable Oscar-talk. But ...
The Iron Lady is among us, with Meryl Streep's uncanny portrayal of Margaret Thatcher, both in her dotage and - through flashback - seen in her prime, earning accolades and inevitable Oscar-talk. But ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
PC Contrarian
Political Correctnes­s is the opiate of the left.
03:45 PM on 12/15/2011
One of my favorite Thatcher speeches, a graceful tribute:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9eQIWKBR-s&feature=related
photo
PC Contrarian
Political Correctnes­s is the opiate of the left.
03:31 PM on 12/15/2011
I'm quite grateful for the movie, regardless of it's predictable inaccuracies; for it has prompted me to know more about Thatcher, including this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-0WyAkZmxk&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYrLiiUbxkM&feature=related
photo
PC Contrarian
Political Correctnes­s is the opiate of the left.
03:14 PM on 12/15/2011
I'm no expert on Thatcher, so I'll defer to reasonable Brits who are.
But I do like this example of The Iron Lady:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Tetk_ayO1x4

Her stand on the Euro and the IMF seems prescient now.
photo
My Mate Pat
Nobody's Nationalist
12:43 PM on 12/15/2011
I once shook Mrs T's hand at a rally in 1979. I was 15, and hope I can be forgiven for letting her feel that she had my support. As I grew up, and she grew monstrous, our ways parted dramatically. I will not be able to bring myself to watch this film. I bitterly resent the way she and her like made us feel how it did to be British in the 1980s.

Furthermore, in '79 her complexion was already nothing like dear Meryl's. There was more putty in her face than a National Trust window frame.
11:29 AM on 12/15/2011
oh no. did i have one of those terrible nightmares that linger in the darkest parts of your subconscious for hours after you wake up?
I can't look - I don't want to even believe that this is real. Why didn't the lovely Meryl just strap on a big one and chase Angelina Jolie around a deserted asbestos factory for 2 hours. It would be far more palatable and less horrific than this abomination.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vippy
Carpe Diem!
10:24 AM on 12/15/2011
Wow, she looks a lot like Thatcher there only prettier!
10:18 AM on 12/15/2011
If there was a prize for decimating British Industry Thatcher would win all the Oscars. If there was a prize for stealing what we already owned, then selling it to other people she'd get all the Emmys too. If there was an award for the originator of the Great Property Manipulation Contrick, she'd get the Fooker Prize for that too.