Japan 'Astonishingly Unprepared' For Fukushima, Report Concludes

Fukushima

First Posted: 2/03/2012 06:42 Updated: 2/03/2012 06:51   PA

Officials in Japan were "astonishingly unprepared" for the events that led to the Fukushima nuclear disaster, a damning report has concluded.

Investigators highlighted a catalogue of human errors before and after the earthquake and tsunami which killed thousands of people, devastated the Japanese economy and threatened the future of the nuclear industry.

In particular, they attacked the myth of "absolute safety" promoted by supporters of nuclear power.

The independent report, published in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, criticised the building of multiple nuclear reactor units so close together, and the failure to take the risk of a deadly tsunami seriously.

The nine-magnitude earthquake on March 11 last year triggered a 14-metre tsunami which wiped out coastal towns, shut roads, severed communications and claimed thousands of lives.

It also cut off all electricity to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power station, setting the stage for a major nuclear accident.

A cascade of events followed, including meltdowns of reactor cores, explosions and the release of radioactive material.

After the disaster the Rebuild Japan Initiative Foundation set up an independent panel to review the actions and responses of the Japanese government, nuclear plant owners the Tokyo Electric Power Company (Tepco) and regulatory agencies.

Almost 300 people involved in the accident were interviewed, including Japan's prime minister at the time, Naoto Kan.

The report, written by foundation chairman Yoichi Funabashi and investigation panel director Kay Kitazawa, said the tsunami could and should have been anticipated.

Earlier research on a tsunami that occurred in 869 AD demonstrated the risk of high waves after an earthquake. But even though Tepco's own nuclear energy division understood the danger, the company dismissed it as "academic".

Regulatory authorities encouraged the company to incorporate new findings about tsunami risk into its safety plans but did not make the measures mandatory.

The folly of building a collection of nuclear reactor units in one place was also highlighted.

It meant the nuclear power station's director, Masao Yoshida, had to cope simultaneously with core meltdowns at three reactors and exposed fuel pools at four units.

Major systemic failure was built on a raft of small individual problems, said the report.

For instance, when on-site workers referred to the severe accident manual, the answers they were looking for were not there. A lack of training had also led to the condition of the emergency cooling system being misjudged.

Tepco was said to bear the primary responsibility for incompetent handling of the disaster's aftermath. The organisation failed to make rapid decisions and lost the government's trust, it was claimed.

Confusion about the roles of public and private institutions also contributed to the poor response.

Questioning why preparations were so inadequate, the report said: "One factor was a twisted myth - a belief in the 'absolute safety' of nuclear power.

"This myth has been propagated by interest groups seeking to gain broad acceptance for nuclear power."

The safety myth had been nurtured for decades, partly to overcome strong anti-nuclear feelings linked to the dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki at the end of the Second World War, said the report.

Japanese government regulators including the Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency (Nisa) and the Nuclear Safety Commission (NSC) were criticised for their lack of leadership.

In particular, a system designed to help governments decide when to evacuate in the event of a radioactive leak was not used.

The report told how secret plans were drawn up for what to do under six increasingly drastic scenarios.

In the most extreme case, some 30 million residents could have been evacuated from the Tokyo metropolitan area.

The authors concluded: "It's clear from our investigation of the Fukushima Daiichi accident that even in the technologically advanced country of Japan, the government and the plant operator, Tokyo Electric Power Company, were astonishingly unprepared, at almost all levels, for the complex nuclear disaster that started with an earthquake and a tsunami. And this grave oversight will affect the Japanese people for decades.

"Ultimately, the final outcome of studies of Fukushima Daiichi should be an intense effort to build up the resilience of the country, its organisations and its people, so future disaster can be averted or responded to effectively."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK WORLD

Officials in Japan were "astonishingly unprepared" for the events that led to the Fukushima nuclear disaster, a damning report has concluded. Investigators highlighted a catalogue of human errors b...
Officials in Japan were "astonishingly unprepared" for the events that led to the Fukushima nuclear disaster, a damning report has concluded. Investigators highlighted a catalogue of human errors b...
Filed by Lucy Sherriff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 155
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
08:45 PM on 03/06/2012
For the technically inclined

http://images3.freshpatents.com/pdf/US20120051485A1.pdf

Corium Cooling Promoting Aparatus and Containment
professor
Correkt the Spelling and Pick on the Moniker
08:29 PM on 03/03/2012
They admit that what we say is true and then say "so what"? Can't even refute it. The evidence mounts.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
08:25 AM on 03/05/2012
you have no evidence, just scare tactics and bad science.

keep trying, You wont catch up to the knowledge required to fully understand the situation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
04:06 PM on 03/03/2012
Radionuclides from the Fukushima accident in the air over Lithuania: measurement and modelling approaches http://www.happysmile.se/dokument/science_plutonium_litauen.pdf
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
05:40 PM on 03/03/2012
so what?

wont kill anyone. Too dilute
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Harley 2
06:16 AM on 03/05/2012
2600% over baseline, thats the uranium, the plutonium is really rare in nature, that is like 12000% over baseline, and we were inhaling it. As measure by EPA RADNET.

There is no other possible conclusion, it is very simple. 3 vaporized at least its full reactor load and maybe some spent fuel too.

http://nukeproffesional.blogspot.com/p/uranium-aerosolized-into-atmosphere.html
WonderingNThinking
Think Before We Sink
WonderingNThinking
Think Before We Sink
07:45 AM on 03/03/2012
The Frying Dutchman singing about Fukushima. Very powerful statement:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5p283KZGa8&feature=youtube_gdata_player
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Harley 2
07:37 AM on 03/05/2012
That Dutchman nailed it.
permament storage at this site.

http://nukeproffesional.blogspot.com/2012/02/human-error.html
WonderingNThinking
Think Before We Sink
07:34 AM on 03/03/2012
A great blog giving an overall look at the truth about nuclear power and the lies the nuclear shills tell:
http://nukepimp.blogspot.com/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
02:56 PM on 03/03/2012
Faved, already fanned!

Worth a daily read!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
04:30 PM on 03/04/2012
So why arent colleges and universities adopting this in their curicula? Easy. Its wrong.
WonderingNThinking
Think Before We Sink
07:28 AM on 03/03/2012
Still Cesium in the milk on the U.S. West Coast (see 4th quarter report)
http://cdph.ca.gov/programs/Pages/RHB-RadReport.aspx
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
05:42 PM on 03/03/2012
so what? Wont amount to any health hazard.

There was cesium in the milk during the Cold War.
12:47 AM on 03/05/2012
And Polonium in the cigarettes, and something in the bananas. And cyanide in apples and uranium in the dirt. The stuff is everywhere I know. I always try and stress that radiation does not cause cancer, it just increases your chances. It's why I wear long sleeves during yard work, and don't sun bathe.

hah, I just remembered a tour of Sharon Harris plant in N.C. They had a display with a geiger counter on a slide to show different things. Turns out "fiestaware" brand plates were the highest because the clay came from a uranium vein.
I bet the food stayed fresh on it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
05:07 AM on 03/03/2012
Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology

Volume 49, Issue 1, 2012

Insights from review and analysis of the Fukushima Dai-ichi accident

http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/18811248.2011.636538
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
02:56 PM on 03/03/2012
Warning: Nuclear Baloney (NB) is bad for your health!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
05:42 PM on 03/03/2012
Technical literature isnt baloney. Koolaid is baloney.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
04:32 PM on 03/04/2012
Hmmm. Next time you need a CT scan, tell that to your physician.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
01:04 AM on 03/03/2012
Did anyone serious expect any review Board in Japan to come out and say that ALL land based nuclear reactors are just as vulnerable as the Fukushima Reactors?

No way that the Japanese Nuclear Industry would approve anything that even "HINTS" at that; so this to me is yet just more Nuclear Baloney (NB) designed to try and calm folks down just before the anniversity of 3/11...

I think it will have the opposite effect and further convince the Japanese people that their regulators and their utilities are "in bed" with each other and that Utilities Corp. profits are much more important than public health...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
03:06 AM on 03/03/2012
There is no trillion dollar eco disaster.

You think what you want to think, doesnt make it true.

Check aluminum hat. Disenfranchised always plays conspiracy card.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
03:07 PM on 03/03/2012
Got a link for that "lowball" claim
or are you just in nuclear denial?
WonderingNThinking
Think Before We Sink
07:48 AM on 03/03/2012
Hi CaptD. Hope you are well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
07:03 PM on 03/03/2012
You and he have been scarce since 1) the Frontline piece, the news that the radiation effects are in the noise 3) the US is building new plants

Seems that even a year later, Fukushima hasnt changed nuclear's resolve except for a few bohemian and green pockets in Europe.

Hey the ladies dont shave their armpits. Gotta keep warm and reduce energy I guess.

Yet sleeping with somone each night gives them 20 microSv.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
12:37 AM on 03/03/2012
This article underscores one fact:

Antinukes lost their perspective,

"The nine-magnitude earthquake on March 11 last year triggered a 14-metre tsunami which wiped out coastal towns, shut roads, severed communications and claimed thousands of lives."

That says it all.

If roads are wiped, communication is severed, and many people are killed, including responders, then how are they going to notify people? Who is going to respond.

Its as if an ELE asteroid can hit smack dab at a nuclear plant as well, and they wouldnt care about the devestation, They would rather complain about the nuclear plant, and not the tremendous loss off life the natural event caused.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
12:41 AM on 03/03/2012
Ha Ha Ha
Sure the Rebuild Japan Initiative Foundation set up an independent panel to review the actions and responses of the Japanese government, nuclear plant owners the Tokyo Electric Power Company (Tepco) and regulatory agencies, were going to find that the Tusunami was the true cause and make everyone in Japan afraid to accept nuclear...

You have been consuming too much Nuclear Baloney (NB)!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
02:56 AM on 03/03/2012
without the tsunami there is no Fukushima.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
03:44 AM on 03/03/2012
who is watching the watchers? Everyone is a critic who isnt a player.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
10:04 PM on 03/02/2012
TEPCO and the Nuclear Mafiahttp:
//is.­gd/b8kXDL
snip
"TEPCO's involvemen­t with anti-socia­l forces and their inability to filter them out of the work-place is a national security issue. It is one reason that increasing­ly in the Diet we are talking de facto nationaliz­ation of the company. Nuclear energy shouldn't be in the hands of the yakuza. They're gamblers and an intelligen­t person doesn't want them to have atomic dice to play with."

BTW: How can the Japanese GOVERNMENT allow the yakuza access to nuclear materials when the rest of the World threatens other ROGUE groups that seek nuclear materials!  Who is keeping tract of every GRAM of nuclear materials in Japan, how much is being stolen and or sold to other groups or Countries?

This is a VERY IMPORTANT issue that has not been addressed in MSM:
Where have ALL THE HIGHLY RADIOACTIV­E MATERIALS GONE?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
12:37 AM on 03/03/2012
Its still in the reactors.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
12:42 AM on 03/03/2012
MORE Nuclear Baloney (NB)...

Got a link that proves that?

Even TEPCO has no idea where all the Corium(s) are, how do you know?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Harley 2
07:39 AM on 03/05/2012
Video Analysis of Unit 3 Explosion here

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Q3ljfLvHww&feature=youtu.be
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
04:24 PM on 03/04/2012
You think nuclear material is something you can get at Walmart? There has to be special precautions and procedures taken or those handling the material will have a bad day.

It seems you are caught in a non sequiter. You say the most untrained are in custody of material that requires the utmost training and care. Thats illogical.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
10:02 PM on 03/02/2012
I suggested months ago the they remove as many SFR's as possible to yet another site, but I don't know why they have not done so YET; my guess it that TEPCO wants to restart #5 and #6... aka Tepco's Folly!

The Japanese love to GAMBLE and they are betting yet another Trillion Dollar Eco-Disast­er will not happen, which is N☢T a safe bet; Ask The Japanese people!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
12:38 AM on 03/03/2012
Chernobyl 1-3 is operating
TMI 1 is operating

Fukushima 5 and 6 are perfectly good reactors. Plus they are more modern.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
12:43 AM on 03/03/2012
Plus they are in the HOT ZONE of the rest of Fukushima...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
03:46 AM on 03/03/2012
The SFRs for 5 and 6 are best kept where they are.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
03:11 PM on 03/03/2012
Until the next major EQ, you mean?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
09:59 PM on 03/02/2012
Almost 12 Months and counting!
The Japanese people and many of those of the rest of the World,
... wait in fear because of what TEPCO and the Japanese Gov't
.... are trying to make money instead of stopping this Eco-Disaster...

That is the bottom line and no amount of Nuclear Baloney (NB) type
... "reports or reviews or Nuclear theory" makes that any better.

Do any of US actually know what the situation is on the ground?

I sure don't, but I know that because TEPCO has lied, concealed data
... and played the Japanese People's SAFETY down, while trying to save
... TEPCO profits instead, we all have much to fear from THEM!
 
If someone told me 11 MONTHS ago that I would be sitting on the edge
... of my chair, and blogging to save the Japanese people from their Utility
... TEPCO & their Gov't. overseers I would have  thought they were crazy!

This is a nuclear nightmare... And N☢T just for the Japanese, but the Planet!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
04:40 PM on 03/04/2012
See this is where we differ - because my education and training tells me that its not the information coming from Japan that is the problem - the problem lies with antinukes perception of the information.

Every day, I take pockets of information, data mine, and correlate. There are a couple fundamental truths you need to understand.

1. PicoCuries of radiation will not kill anyone.
2. Knowledgable people do know what is going on.

"I sure dont" tells it all.

You arent blogging to save the Japanese people. Your blogs actually cause fear and panic IF anyone even takes you seriously.

Now I have talked with the Japanese who are technical and they and I agree that your approach hurts people in the long run.

This is not a nuclear nightmare. The sky isnt falling

THe reactors will go back on, else Japan falls behind.

THey dont want that.

So blog all you want, 1) it wont help and 2) it causes more grief to those that are unknowing and sheeple.

You know the 1 year anniversary is coming up and what have you accomplished? What is your metric?

I sure have mine. And it has nothing to do with blogging.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
09:56 PM on 03/02/2012
People in the Western World, need to reexamine the "way" they view Japan and that includes not only how that Country is governed but what actual "say" the Japanese people have in their Governments process! It has taken almost a year to realize that Japan is actually being "run" by its Powerful Utility Companies and this "business" relationship extends in a "Control Continuum" that extends at one end, from actual Utility direct financial support of the highest Government Leaders in the Country, to the widely known use of organized gangs to keep citizens in line at the other! The idea that individual Japanese people actually have a say in how they are governed, much less the way their Energy is generated, is just a well publicized fantasy that the Utilities uses to put a nuclear "smily face" on the grim reality that ever facet of Japanese life is less important than what is good for these Utilities! These Powerful Utilities ARE Japan, and the Japanese people are only "forced" customers of these Utilities since they have no other choice of providers when it come to basic needs like electricity, at lest until now! Solar panels have allowed many to get the electricity they need and this is a huge threat to these Utilities, that must be "crushed" ASAP if they are to maintain their complete control over the Japanese people! Ever since 3/11, the rest of the World's attention has been focused on the Trillion Dollar Eco-Disaster at Fukushima and Japan's response to their triple melt down. What we have learned is that the Government has allowed TEPCO to not only remain in Control of this debacle but they have actually enabled the Utility to place huge numbers of Japanese citizens at risk rather than demand that the Utility think first of human health instead of Corp. shareholder profits. The fact that radioactive pollution has now spread Globally and is affecting the rest of the Planet is hardly mentioned in MSM which points to an even greater problem for the rest of mankind; we are helpless and as yet unable to demand any "better" treatment from Japan because our own Leaders are for the most part are in full support of the those Utility backed Leaders in Japan. Kudos to Germany and many other Countries for pointing the finger at Nuclear Power and the Trillion Dollar Eco-Disaster RISK every nuclear complex now represents! People globally now are becoming informed and starting to demand answers to basic questions and once people start asking questions perhaps change will occur, even if not for the Japanese themselves... one thing is for certain, the Japanese people will be affected by their Trillion Dollar Eco-Disaster for much longer than the estimated 40 to 100 years that it will take to "tidy up" after Fukushima...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
12:39 AM on 03/03/2012
There is no Trillion Dollar Eco Disaster.

You are well beyond your 250 word limit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
03:07 AM on 03/03/2012
Check WebMd, you might find some chemistry that can help.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
photo
rabidrightwatch
Green lefty & active environmentalist
03:10 PM on 03/02/2012
Astonishingly unprepared - this describing a nation, renowned for its eye for detail and security, has shown how very easily even well-prepared nations can lapse into a false sense of security - or do I mean insecurity?

Something not mentioned in the report, and highlighted on Channel 4 (UK) a couple of days ago, was the estimate of 40 years to decommission the remaining intact reactor and to remove and dispose of the highly radio-active remnants of the remaining three reactors.

The cost will be phenomenal, and large areas of Japan will remain off limits for many years to come, and if the restriction zone around Chernobyl can be taken as a measure, this could be many hundreds, perhaps thousands of years.
A vast area of an incredibly crowded island nation is affected.

Japan has more than 50 nuclear reactors, many positioned along the same faultline system...

The cost, leaving aside for one moment the environmental and human catastrophe, makes nuclear a very expensive option for power generation.

Perhaps now is the time for a grown-up debate (rather than knee-jerk prejudiced reaction) concerning how we generate power for the future.

For my part, I would advocate the development of a whole raft of renewables as part of this debate.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atoms4Peace1
Applying the atom peacefully since 1978
12:46 AM on 03/03/2012
Unprepaired? There was no one left.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
12:49 AM on 03/03/2012
Every reactor is "unprepared" for a major EQ; that is their weak spot!

Too much ground motion and then,
... even big metal structures start to warp, bend and FAIL like Fukushima!