Michael Gove: Universities Should Be Given The Power To Set A-Levels

PA/The Huffington Post UK  |  By   |  Posted: 3/04/2012 07:03 Updated: 3/04/2012 11:26

Michael Gove A Levels
Michael Gove has called for universities to have a "far greater" role in designing A-levels in the future, amid concerns that the qualifications are failing to prepare teenagers for university.

Education Secretary Michael Gove has called for universities to have a "far greater" role in designing A-levels in the future, amid concerns that the qualifications are failing to prepare teenagers for university.

In a letter to the exams regulator Ofqual, Gove said that he did not envisage the Department for Education playing a part in developing A-levels in the future, adding he would like to see the new university-led A-levels available for first teaching in September 2014.

The Conservatives first said they planned to put universities, exam boards and professional societies in charge of creating A-levels before the last general election, and Gove has repeated the policy since taking office two years ago.

In his letter to Glenys Stacey, chair of Ofqual, Gove said that exam boards should be able to work with universities to develop qualifications. In return for greater freedom to design exams, boards will have to provide evidence of which universities have been involved in decision such as subject matter, and style of questions.

"I will expect the bar to be a high one: university ownership of the exams must be real and committed, not a tick-box exercise", he writes.

A Labour Party spokesperson said it was important to have a "trusted" system: "Our exams must have the confidence
of parents, teachers, employers and higher education."

The news comes amid claims universities are being forced to lay on remedial classes for new undergraduates because many are struggling to write essays, use grammar and punctuation and build arguments.

According to a study by Cambridge Assessment too much "teaching to the test" in schools - drilling pupils to pass exams - is a "major factor" in pupils being unprepared for studying at degree level.

Cambridge Assessment's study, based on an 18-month research programme that included a survey of 633 higher education lecturers and roadshows, found that more than half of lecturers think that undergraduates are unprepared for degree-level study.

Three fifths (60%) said that their universities are providing extra "support" classes for under-prepared first-year students, usually focusing on writing and independent learning. Nearly three quarters (72%) of those questioned said that they have changed their teaching styles for students who are not ready for university study.

Students can have trouble structuring essays, with spelling, punctuation and grammar, referencing and citing sources, building arguments, conducting research, and evaluating information, the study found. But they are most prepared in terms on the ICT skills, ability to work in teams and in presentation and communication skills.

The findings, due to be presented at a conference on Tuesday, say that academics want A-levels to include more advanced content for bright students, cover subjects in more depth and encourage critical thinking, independent study, experimentation and more extensive reading.

Mark Dawe, chief executive of the OCR exam board, which is part of Cambridge Assessment, said: "Recognising the need to strengthen links with universities and other HE institutions, the research programme is one of the ways we are increasing HE's role in the design, development and evaluation of A-levels and other qualifications."

But union leaders have hit out at the plans saying they are a "quick fix gimmick".

Dr Mary Bousted, general secretary of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), said: "This sounds like a quick fix gimmick from Michael Gove.

"Of course universities have a useful role to play in deciding what should be tested at A-level, but A-levels need to test more than just the ability to go to university. A-levels need to test students' skills and help prepare them for the world of work and daily life as well as to study further."

FOLLOW UK EDUCATION

Education Secretary Michael Gove has called for universities to have a "far greater" role in designing A-levels in the future, amid concerns that the qualifications are failing to prepare teenagers fo...
Education Secretary Michael Gove has called for universities to have a "far greater" role in designing A-levels in the future, amid concerns that the qualifications are failing to prepare teenagers fo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Francesca1953
A mind is like a parachute-only works when open
10:40 PM on 04/03/2012
I had to check if I was still on the UK page, as we are going through the same kind of thing (students ill-prepared for college) in the USA.

BTW, as a parent of an American student attending uni in London, I'm just beginning to understand the UK system!
05:17 PM on 04/03/2012
Am I the only one who sat the Oxford O and A Levels in the fifties. Other schools saat exams set by Cambridge so why not now? The exams covered the whole of the years we were at senior school and not broken up in to parts as today so that people who you went to work for or the University you applied for knew that you had studied. Not read a computer or used a calculator but used your brain and retention skills that every one has.
01:32 PM on 04/03/2012
i think this is perhaps a good idea in theory, but i don't think it would work so well in practise. mostly because each university has a different style of teaching for each subject, and subjects at a-level could relate to different subjects across the board of university, requiring different ideas within the subject. having been to university myself, i found that what i learned at a-level wasn't really much use at university, and i struggled to have to catch up on work that others had done. however, i think this just helped me get into the university mindset for studying. gcses and alevels are so much based around being in lessons all day every day, whereas university requires you to go out and study for yourself.

my university, in some modules of my course, held tests at the beginning of the course to find out what level you were up to and adapted the course from the results. i think this would be a more useful approach as then it is purely based on what you will learn within the module for the subject you're wanting to study, not teaching you in advance far too much to examine on a subject you probably won't even need in the future.
03:41 PM on 04/04/2012
So let me get this straight - university degree courses are now split up into bite-sized, easily digestible, multiply re-sat modules just like A levels and GCSEasies?

What has this once proud nation come to?
12:00 PM on 04/03/2012
The third class degree, once about a third of all graduates, is become a rare beast, while firsts have multiplied severalfold - and you have to be a trifle older than me to remember even the existence of a fourth. So I doubt the universities to be trusted to maintain standards either. Quis custodiet?
katertaif
My wife thinks I have one fault. Everything I do!
10:06 AM on 04/03/2012
Some years ago, while allegedly teaching in Saudi Arabia, the students, at the end of the week, were given sometimes only one, never more than three questions, multi choice box tick style. On the last page of their work books, just in case they couldn't read English or Arabic (one of mine could not read English at all) was the box they had to tick. It worked so well that one student attended on Saturday mornings (to get his workbook) and then disappeared until Wednesday afternoon (to sit the exam) He still managed to achieve 100% in his test results. I mention all this, only to highlight that for some years we have been going the same way. Our children come out of there educational system with a very ofen meaningless degree at the same time barely literate or numerate. Then we wonder why foreign workers with a better work ethic, a far higher standard of education, and who can read and write English more fluently than some of us, come here and take what few jobs are going.
09:34 AM on 04/03/2012
People always highlight the importance of the critical thinking in the learning, which is the most difficult part to develop through exam base assessment. Also, I believe critical thinking skill need to base on a good knowledge base, as the information providing the foundation of think in different aspect. However,students always forget to challenge the ideas when they trying hard in grasping the knowledge.
Finding a balance to merit student who have different thinking. They will be able to make good progress during their university study.
09:30 AM on 04/03/2012
Without doubt. It is the only way to ensure that the schools raise their current lamentable standards. I have worked in manufacturing for 25+ years and the current standards of basic reading , writing, and maths is deplorable. Applicants cannot fill out application forms, and even worse cannot calculate how much they have earned in wages, and do not know how much theey have to pay in income tax etc. Yet all we hear from teachers is how badly they are done by, they should come and work with the results of their pitiful efforts.
09:18 AM on 04/03/2012
Good. The old examining boards were all university based. O&C, JMB, London etc. There were some differences. O&C were reckoned to be the most testing It was taken account of. Also, in my discipline, the A levels in Vhemistry, Physics and Biology were monitored by the Medical schools as they exempted you from the Ist MB examination. Similarly Additional Mathematics as the gateway to Maths degrees.

A long overdue reversion. For once a politician has gotit right.
09:13 AM on 04/03/2012
As A levels have become so discredited and the Examination Boards have not covered themselves in glory then it would seem a good idea that those who inherit the problems, the universities, should be the ones to deal with repairing tyhe situation.
However the Universities themselves have some question marks against them with degrees being given in some non academic and questionable subjects so the choice of who deals wth these problems should perhaps be restricted to the older, best established universities and not those ctrreated from Technical Colleges.
KenInd
We too shall get through this.....
08:47 AM on 04/03/2012
Dear Michael.......no experience in education; just as a political and journalist hack. The closest experience he has had in education was playing the rather effete school chaplain in the 1995 family comedy 'A Feast at Midnight'. He is the sort of chap who would have been laughed at by the 2nd fifteen rugby team at a rural prep school while spending a gap year cleaning boots. He has no experience in education. He is a fraud.

Pure and simple. Anyone in education, whatever their views, regards anything he says about education with disbelief. New schools? Teach the Lord's Prayer? This man is echoing a conservative voice that speals in his mind but not that of the electorate. He is, simply put, a joke that has backfired.

I suggest a move to 'Minister in Charge of Silly Walks'.
majdf18148
I have nothing to declare but my curiosity
10:08 AM on 04/03/2012
Methinks thou doth protest too much! Your post is a vain glorious attempt at sniping at a personality rather than addressing the matter to hand which you choose to determinedly ignore. Your choice of words display a leaning towards you being anti gay and your remark apropos "anyone in education....et al" is an opinion and absolutely not fact based. I am no fan of Michael Gove, I don't know him but many accounts I have read of him describe him as being highly intellectual despite a troubled childhood. His plan for universities to have a far greater role in setting A Level exams is sound. Don't dismiss a sensible plan because you harbour some irrational dislike of the person proposing it, that's what Luddites did! I accept of course your right to say what you please ergo this response along similar lines!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
12:02 PM on 04/03/2012
Loving this retort! Have read it thrice now and it impresses me more each time. F&F
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
05:23 PM on 04/03/2012
F&F - great post. The man IS a joke as he has no idea whatsoever about how children learn, but unfortunately he's an evangelical, right wing joke. And he's stuck a chord with know-it-all armchair experts. No-one I know in the world of education has any respect for him at all.

Unfortunately he couldn't cope with the Ministry of Silly Walks:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HAqyf7a4xFM
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
08:41 AM on 04/03/2012
Wow! A piece of common sense from a Tory!!!