Child Refugees 'Still Detained As Adults', Says Report

PA  |  Posted: Updated: 20/05/2012 14:52   PA

Uk Borders

Child refugees are still being locked up by the immigration service which wrongly classifies them as adults, a new report claims.

Young people can be left seriously damaged by their detention with some suffering mental health difficulties as a consequence, it warns.

Some highly vulnerable children who arrive in the country unaccompanied are held for weeks before officials accept they are not adults, it found.

The report, published this week by the Refugee Council, raises concerns about the number of age dispute cases more than two years after the Government vowed to end the detention of children for immigration purposes.

The charity believes officials are failing to exercise sufficient caution on the issue, meaning the controversial practice has continued.

It has called on the government to implement a number of safeguards to reflect the serious nature of a decision to treat someone as adult based purely on their appearance.

Donna Covey, chief executive at the Refugee Council, said: "It is a scandal that two years after the Government agreed to end the detention of children because of its harmful effects, they still believe it is acceptable to lock up children who have come here on their own.

"These are children who have fled horrifying situations in their own countries and have made traumatic journeys to reach safety here.

"They are then met with disbelief by the people who are supposed to help them and locked up with other adults in detention centres.

"The UK would never treat a British child in this way. We have an obligation to protect these children, so it is imperative that they are not held in detention and that they are given the benefit of the doubt."

According to the report, many refugees arrive in Britain on false documents - something which is accepted under international law. These are likely to be marked with an adult's date of birth.

While some children are advised to state they are older than their years to protect themselves from exploitation on their journeys, others would not be allowed to travel alone if their true age was known.

This means immigration staff are not immediately equipped with the necessary information and young people may be incorrectly judged to be an adult based simply on their physical appearance.

"One of the biggest issues young people seeking asylum face on arrival in the UK is that they are usually unable to verify their date of birth with official documents," the report states.

In the first three months of this year, six children were released from detention after officials realised they were under the age of 18, it found. Another four cases remain outstanding.

Last year, 22 children were released from detention for the same reason. This figure stood at 26 in 2010.

The charity's report, Not a Minor Offence, focuses on the cases of a number of children it claims were wrongly locked up.

Kabir, who fled Iran after his father was killed and his brother imprisoned for opposing the political regime, arrived in the UK aged 15.

Assessed to be an adult, he was kept in a police cell for four days before being transferred to an Immigration Removal Centre.

He was held for a month-and-a-half - unable to communicate - before his release was secured.

He still suffers from mental health difficulties because of his detention, according to the charity.

"The psychiatrist who assessed him stated that the six weeks he was locked up, when he felt abandoned and terrified about his future, were the cause of his current disorder, particularly because he was not able to mix with anyone of his own age," the report found.

Another child, Faisal, was 15 when he arrived in the UK from Afghanistan, having hidden inside a lorry. He was detained for more than three weeks following a journey which lasted several months.

The Refugee Council has outlined a series of measures to address the "pernicious situation of these forgotten children".

This includes asking the UK Border Agency to refer all asylum applicants claiming to be children for a local authority assessment and ensuring staff only decide someone is an adult if there is no possible chance the person in question could be a child.

If there is any doubt, the decision should be made not to detain, even if someone is treated as adult, the report suggests.

The Refugee Council works to secure the release of children from immigration detention when they are treated as adults.

FOLLOW UK

Child refugees are still being locked up by the immigration service which wrongly classifies them as adults, a new report claims. Young people can be left seriously damaged by their detention with ...
Child refugees are still being locked up by the immigration service which wrongly classifies them as adults, a new report claims. Young people can be left seriously damaged by their detention with ...
Filed by Michael Rundle  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 44
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:59 on 21/05/2012
Who wrote this article?-Kabir, who fled Iran after his father was killed and his brother imprisoned for opposing the political regime, arrived in the UK aged 15.-I feel very sorry for this poor unfortunate boy but to say detention caused his mental health problems,well,that probably started when his father was killed and his brother imprisoned.I'm prettyv sure if I lived in one of these hiddious countries,I too would want to come to the UK,but how can we support the massive influx of immigration when we can't even support owr selves.I thought asylum seekers were supposed to clain asylum in the first country they get to? Why do they all end up here?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NOSHER
15:48 on 21/05/2012
i agree mate getting plenty of replies of thet spelling detective ,he must be one of these do gooders, cant stand them thats how the country is like it is, with there onesided human rights take care mr bb
majdf18148
I have nothing to declare but my curiosity
11:44 on 21/05/2012
Well, in my opinion, most of this is nonsense. Firstly, in 99.99% of the time the tretament of those young people in the detention centres will be far better than what they had hither to experienced in their own country. Secondly, from my extensive time spent in many different parts of the world and in many different cultures I know many of these young refugees live amongst adults as part of their normal life in their own countries and are expected, from an early age, to become adult in their work and lifestyle. Thirdly, I find it hard to believe 6 weeks in an adult detention centre is the sole cause of severe psychiatric problems, unless these kids are abused by ther own people whilst there. I am not hard hearted but we have to keep this in perspective. We are the last bolt hole for the world's unwanted, the crooks, thieves, benefit cheats, child abusers and general criminals. Amongst all that there are genuine refugees with a genuine need for help and sanctuary, we desperately need to eject the first group and help the second group.
10:26 on 21/05/2012
They need to spend all the money an removing them then recapturing the ones who are illegal. They then need to start investigating one by one the legal immigrants. Going right back to the fifties to uncover fraud.
10:25 on 21/05/2012
not all but most are beggers and pickpockets in time for the olympics. NAIVE comes to mind.
12:12 on 21/05/2012
It'll be interesting to see how many of the tourists that come over for the Games actually go home again after they finish.
09:54 on 21/05/2012
Why don't the Refugee Council investigate the "pernicious situation" whereby these illegal and certainly unwanted immigrants are detained in the first place instead of being immediately deported - wasting millions of tax payers money on feeding and housing them and no doubt providing free medical care as well.
10:23 on 21/05/2012
Well said, could'nt have put it better myself.
08:14 on 21/05/2012
when all the money has gone to pay for all their new homes,health care,education,benefits et al and there is no money left to pay for your operation,send your kids to school,cannot drive the car as it's too expensive etc etc . will you immigrant huggers be so welcoming to these people? i sympathise with the immigrants plight but we are better helping them to be productive in their own country first with training and tools and not food & money handouts which go to send the dictators kids to EATON
08:02 on 21/05/2012
i notice they don`t post your comment on here when you tell the truth
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NOSHER
07:36 on 21/05/2012
this is to severus , thanks for your comment,mine has been took of because its the truth. but apart from that didnt know u were a professor, and dont be daft about my spelling , u still could read it or u wouldnt have complained , u want to find something better to do than sit all day checking peoples spelling and get a life , why dont u go to www.whoopee i can spell.com how sad
This comment has been removed.
07:14 on 21/05/2012
So Donna Covey says " it's a scandal ". Yes it is,a scandal they are allowed into this country in the first place. She also speaks about their " traumatic journeys ", can't be that bad travelling through half of Western Europe and having a few weeks holiday in France waiting to jump on a truck to the U.K. so us mugs, the tax payers, pay to have them looked after.Oh, and by the way, who pays her wages, hope it's not us mugs as well.
04:12 on 21/05/2012
So much ill-feeling.

Imagine being in a situation so horrific that you give up everything to escape... you get to a 'safe' place, you take whatever job you can (let's face it, there is a lot of work, some people just don't want to do the jobs that are available) and through it all you feel completely unwelcome and are victimized as though you're the same as the people you were fleeing from... and we think we have it tough.
05:51 on 21/05/2012
I think the word naive comes to mind.........you're worried....you look after them.
17:33 on 21/05/2012
They get to a place that feeds them, houses them,give them everything, they thank us by abusing our system,and our children.they have more rights than you or I. ALso I am fed up with my taxes being so high to pay for all this.most can not speak English so the children go to our schools , and our children loose out because the immigrants children can not speak English. YES i think we have it tough Alex you need to get real.
20:38 on 20/05/2012
This has been going on for years, children? coming here alone.What gets me are the miles they travel and getting through several countries and ending up here.No wonder our immigration service is overloaded. It can only point to these other countries turning a blind eye. Italy is one such country who just waves them through.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ZeoGetty
A soul with a conscience
21:09 on 20/05/2012
For the love of all that's good and decent, enough with the ignorance. You don't know exactly how they got here and whether or not it was a direct flight. And just because these other countries are "turning a blind eye" doesn't mean it's acceptable for the worlds former policing country that invaded nations and inflicted their own morals to now say we will become heartless. Children can be sculpted, locking them up and treating them like criminals will turn them into criminals. I am shocked how heartless some of you anti-immigration Brits are. Unless you are actually observing these cases and working hand in hand with them, you have no right to deny them the right to live a safe life. Stop listening to the lies the rightest media and Theresa Mary are spreading. The UK is becoming a dark place for Human Rights... Btw, there are a lot of refugees, in Germany, France and Belgium so before you go on, read about their refugees. It is the lying politicians of this nation who want to make it sound as if the UK is the only "humane" nation that opened its doors. True some took advantage of the system but that's not to say they're all like this. You all are just too blinded by hate and ignorance, I pray to god that not all Brits are that way.
21:52 on 20/05/2012
The problem we Brits have with "refugees" Zeo, is that all too often, they cross country after country, and end up in France. The law of asylum is that if you are in danger in your own country, you must ask for asylum at the FIRST SAFE BORDER.
The French do nothing to stop them gathering at Calais, where they devote their lives to coming to England. Our Border Agency people arrest the same people many times over, but the French shrug, and allow them to remain at Calais until they do smuggle themselves over here.
Very few asylum seekers are real, they come here to live off the benefits system, taking all and donating nothing. Many join criminal gangs already established here, and if caught, play the race card.
The UK allowed many thousands of genuine Jewish refugees from Nazi Europe to come and live here, far more than America did, so we are not an unfeeling nation, just a nation that is fed up with having to accept the worlds dregs in the name of asylum.
23:27 on 20/05/2012
'' Enough with my ignorance'', You need to tale a long look in the mirror it's you are ignorant I know all about the refugees in other countries, but my loyalties are to my country.Pray all you like but it's the majority of British people who feel the same as me.
20:22 on 20/05/2012
Just when is this scam going to come to an end? Just how many of those so called child refugees need a shave?
This comment has been removed.
08:31 on 21/05/2012
You are so right Blindstu. totally agree.
10:33 on 21/05/2012
Thank you for your support. I spent my whole life travelling around the world, mixing and working with many different cultures and am fully aware that lies just slip off the tongues of some peoples in an effort to get what they want and once word gets out on how to fool the British Border Force, they all try it on. Nobody likes to see kids suffer but where do we draw the line.............we cannot possibly support the entire world but unfortunately, the bleeding hearts amongst us seem to think that we can and their efforts could very well lead to our own destruction.
19:56 on 20/05/2012
why are unaccompanied children being allowed to fly from their parent country to here anyway ?
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
18:26 on 20/05/2012
It is often difficult to ascertain the true age of these 'children'. Their appearance is nothing to go by. In their own countries they were undernourished from birth so not grown to their full growth for age.
However, I do believe the 'children' know this and use it to their advantage when seeking care here. X-ray them for bone age plus a full medical necessary for diseases too.
Then if they are lying return them to whence they came. No more free lunches here.