The average UK family now spends more than a quarter of net income (27%) on childcare suggests a report by Conservative MP Elizabeth Truss for the CentreForum think tank.

Yet measures suggested by Truss to overhaul childcare provision in the UK have met with little enthusiasm from experts.

In her report, Truss, MP for South West Norfolk, claims that while the number of nursery places has increased since 1996, the number of childminder places has dropped drastically in the same period to 245,000 in 2010.

The report argues this has led to price inflation, while at the same time, becoming a childminder is now fraught with red tape.

She calls for childminders to be allowed to take on more children (so one minder could look after five children aged five or younger, rather than three), a single funding system, and for childminders to be able to register with a local agency, nursery or network that would take responsibility for inspection and training and be regulated by Ofsted.

See Also

However, according to national childcare charity Daycare Trust, the 'deregulation' of childminders would not solve the UK’s childcare crisis.

In her report, Truss suggests Britain adopt a framework used in the Netherlands for childminders.

In the Netherlands childminder or ‘host parent’ agencies operate locally, training and monitoring registered childminders, while parents pay a monthly fee for childminding.

An equivalent system in the UK could be based on existing networks, agencies and local authorities, Truss proposes.

However, Anand Shukla, chief executive of Daycare Trust, argues the model implemented in the Netherlands since 2005 has not worked - and many of the changes have since been reversed.

“The Dutch reforms led to lower quality childcare, did not increase the number of high quality childminders in the profession, as the increase in numbers was largely due to grandparents registering as childminders; did not have a noticeable impact on maternal employment; and saw bureaucracy increase, due to the introduction of a layer of agencies,” he says.

Further criticism of the report's proposals comes from the NCMA, the membership organisation for registered childminders.

Stuart Turner, director of policy, says: “NCMA does not see the suggestions as a step in the right direction. The system in the Netherlands is now in the process of being abandoned because it wasn’t successful; costs increased and quality was driven down."

"In the UK, parents receive money and/or tax breaks to spend on private services, whereas in many EU countries where parents pay less, government funds services directly, thereby cutting out a level of bureaucracy," he adds.

The NCMA's Individual Inspection Matters campaign calls for government to retain the current system and increase state funding for childcare.

“EC data shows that in countries where childcare is cheaper for parents there are high levels of government funding channelled directly to services, so local authorities finance around 80% of the cost of an early years’ place, and parents pay the rest. In the UK, around 13% of childcare costs are subsidised by Government," says Turner.

In a statement, Ms Truss said: "The coalition Government has a great opportunity to simplify the provision of childcare and get better value for money for parents.

"Reform could lead to an increase in availability of flexible childcare and an end to spiralling costs."

Loading Slideshow...
  • Sri Lankan army snipers march during the annual victory day parade in Colombo, Sri Lanka, Saturday, May 19, 2012. The Sri Lankan government marked the third anniversary of defeating Tamil Tiger rebels with a military parade in the capital Colombo with participation of thousands of soldiers. (AP Photo/Eranga Jayawardena)

  • Athletes compete in the women's 3000m steeplechase the Diamond League Athletics meeting held in Shanghai, China, Saturday, May 19, 2012. (AP Photo/Alexander F. Yuan)

  • Chelsea's Frank Lampard, right, is flanked by Jose Bosingwa, left, as they hold up the trophy at the end of the Champions League final soccer match between Bayern Munich and Chelsea in Munich, Germany Saturday May 19, 2012. Didier Drogba scored the decisive penalty in the shootout as Chelsea beat Bayern Munich to win the Champions League final after a dramatic 1-1 draw on Saturday. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner)

  • A plane takes off from Chicago O'Hare International Airport in between the arrival of world leaders attending the NATO Summit, on Saturday, May 19, 2012, in Chicago. Security has been high throughout the city in preparation for the NATO summit, where delegations from about 60 countries will discuss the war in Afghanistan and European missile defense. (AP Photo/Seth Perlman)

  • A performer participates in a two-day fire festival in Minsk, Belarus, on Saturday evening, May 19, 2012. (AP Photo/Sergei Grits)

  • Models perform on the catwalk during the opening ceremony of the 20th Life Ball in front of the city hall in Vienna, Austria, on Saturday, May 19, 2012. The Life Ball is a charity gala to raise money for people living with HIV and AIDS. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)

  • Actress Charlize Theron, center, Japanese actors Koyuki, left, and Kippei Shiina arrive for a promotion of "Snow White And The Huntsman" in Tokyo, Sunday, May 20, 2012. Koyuki, and Shiina play dubbed-in voice for the film in Japanese. (AP Photo/Shizuo Kambayashi)

  • The moon slides across the sun, showing a blazing halo of light, during an annular eclipse at a waterfront park in Yokohama, near Tokyo, Monday, May 21, 2012. Millions of Asians watched as a rare "ring of fire" eclipse crossed their skies early Monday. The annular eclipse, in which the moon passes in front of the sun leaving only a golden ring around its edges, was visible to wide areas across the continent. (AP Photo/Shuji Kajiyama)

  • Switzerland's Jean-Baptiste Febo swims a Men's 400 meter heat at the European Swimming Championships in Debrecen, Hungary, Monday, May 21, 2012. (AP Photo/ Michael Sohn)