TECH

'Moto X' Smartphone Review: The Cost Of Purity

21/01/2014 15:34 | Updated 25 January 2014

The Moto X is Motorola's mid-range 'pure' Google handset, available in the UK from February for £380 SIM-free.

Key Features:

  • Android 4.4 Kitkat
  • 4.7-inch 720p Screen
  • 2200 mAh battery
  • 10-megapixel camera
  • 1080p HD video recording
  • Qualcomm Snapdragon S4 Pro
  • 2GB Ram, 16/32 GB storage

The Pitch:

"Talk to Moto X and it learns your voice. With Google Now, it tells you what you need to know – even when you’re not touching it. With two flicks of your wrist, Moto X becomes your camera and captures the shots you used to miss. All of this coupled with its all-day battery means that Moto X is ready when you are."

moto x

The Verdict:

It's a bit of an oddity that the first big smartphone to be released in the UK in 2014 has already been out in the US for about six months. But whatever the reason for the delay - whether it's dealing with UK accents for its voice control tech, or just marketing focus - Motorola has now decided to bring its sort-of-flagship, sort-of-midrange smartphone to the UK. So how does it stack up compared to its Android competitors, especially the similarly specced, priced and vanilla Android Nexus 5?

Visually the phone makes a decent first impression, and while this is clearly not hardware from the top-tier of design and build quality, it's still pleasant to look at and nice to hold. The back of the phone is plastic, and notably curved with a subtle rounded logo impression which helps it sit nicely in the hand. It's fairly light, solid and well-built, though it's not going to dazzle anyone either. In both white and black, it's a straightforwardly dull, neat phone.

In terms of specs, the most obvious downside is the screen. The Moto X is smaller and lower resolution than the Nexus 5, displaying just 720P at 312 pixels per inch. The dip in quality is not tremendously bothersome unless the Moto X is side-by-side with a better display. Indeed, the Amoled panel is quite strong in general, with good contrast levels. But once it is put alongside a better screen, there's no comparison. Similarly its processor is lower spec compared to the Nexus 5, which boasts a quad-core Snapdragon 800 versus the X's Snapdragon S4 dual-core, plus a natural language co-processor. In practice though both perform well, and we didn't experience much difference between the phones on a day-to-day basis.

Battery life was similar, in our unscientific tests, but the Moto X edged it managing a whole day of use without issuing a low-power alert, unlike the Nexus.

moto x

The final big feature battle is in the camera, and here it's a marginal win for Motorola. The Moto X has a 10-megapixels camera, which is a boost versus the the Nexus 5's 8-megapixel sensor, and also boasts an impressively quick 'twist to open' gesture which brings up the camera by just rotating the phone like a motorbike accelerator. Quality was similar to the Nexus in general, though. We noticed sharper images with the Moto X, but both run similar software and it's hard to be too enthusiastic for one over the other.

In software terms, the Moto X does have some pretty neat ideas that the Nexus 5, and many other top-tier Android phones lack. The best is its addition of 'touchless controls', by which you can operate many important functions of the phone without pressing a single button. Just say 'Ok Google Now' and using its language co-processor the phone will start listening for commands, whether it's to navigate to a new area, tell you the weather or make a call. This is partly made possible by hardware, and not even the Nexus 5 has it. It's a nice addition, and while you might not use it much in practice, it's an alluring step towards a truly useful digital assistant.

The Moto X also has intelligent notifications, which use its 'Active Display' to quietly highlight information you need, without waking the whole screen. It's discreet and well designed, and lets you choose when to respond and when to ignore a pulsing notification, depending on where you are. Using the Motorola Connect app you can see and respond to all your notifications using a desktop version of Google Chrome, while the Migrate app lets you port over your SMS messages, contacts and pictures to the new device very easily.

All that combines to a phone with a likeable combination of decent looks, good components and some unique software features. Unfortunately it's also a little hard to recommend when compared on price to its competition. You can get a Nexus 5 for £80 less than the Moto X - and you can get a Samsung Galaxy S4 for not that much more. Without any truly inspiring design options as seen in the US, it's quite hard to recommend in a crowded marketplace. On the other hand, it's also unlikely to disappoint if you do want a basic, pure Android phone with a slightly better camera than the Nexus.

4starstechdarkblue

  • 1 Apple iPhone 6s
  • The iPhone 6s on the surface at least looks like your bog standard update. Visually it's very much the same animal but look a little deeper and this is an entirely different phone. There's now a pressure-sensitive display utilising a feature called 'Force Touch' while a blistering new processor means it's one of the most capable gaming devices outside of your living room.
  • 2 Google Nexus 5X
  • The Nexus 5X strikes the ultimate balance between power and affordability. Taking over the responsibility from the frankly excellent Nexus 5, Google's new smartphone boast an ultra-light body but still crams in a fingerprint sensor, the latest version of Android marshmallow and a Full-HD display.
  • 3 HTC One A9
  • The HTC One A9 is the iPhone for people who love Android. There's simply no denying the design similarities between the two phones. Thankfully HTC's packed this with more flagship features than you can shake a indecently sized stick at. There's a fingerprint reader, 5-inch Full-HD display, 13MP camera and the A9 can play high-resolution audio.
  • 4 Sony Xperia Z5 Premium
  • Sony has created the world's first truly 4K smartphone. While you might be wondering why, the fact is they've gone ahead and done it anyway. Utilising Sony's amazing screen expertise it should come as no surprise to learn the display is an absolute stunner. There's a fingerprint reader and the ability to play high-res audio.
  • 5 Google Nexus 6P
  • The Google Nexus 6P is Google's answer to the big-screen phone. Sporting a 5.7-inch Full-HD panel, the 6P has a beautifully thin unibody enclosure while the subtle fingerprint scanner on the back can be used for security and for paying. You'll also get the added advantage of owning a phone that'll always get Google's Android software before anyone else keeping it safer than ever.
  • 6 LG G4
  • The LG G4 is LG's most advanced smartphone yet. Combining a massive 5.5-inch 2K display with a powerful F1.8 lens camera this is a phone that means business. If you can get past the size of it then you'll be richly rewarded. Thanks to that F1.8 lens LG claims that the G4 is the closest you'll get to a professional SLR on a smartphone without spending thousands on a camera.
  • The Galaxy S6 Edge is probably the most advanced phone available right now. With it's stunningly curved 2K display and powerful octa-core processor this is a return to form for Samsung that was much needed. If you're after the absolute cutting-edge then this is for you, just don't expect the battery to last any longer than a day.
  • The Moto X 2 is significant for two reasons; the first of which is that you can almost entirely design it yourself. On top of that you get a stunning 5.2-inch display that's matched with a phone that measures in at just 3.8mm at its thinnest point. Thanks to Motorola's agreement with Google it's pure Android and will get updates from Google as soon as they're announced. For now, this is your Nexus replacement.
  • This is the Samsung Galaxy Note 4 and it shows the biggest departure from Samsung's design thinking yet. Gone is the cheap plasticky body, replaced with a thin metal frame and smooth leather back. The screen is still 5.7-inches but Samsung's upped the resolution to a massive 2K.
  • The Nokia Lumia 930 is the flagship phone for Microsoft. Running the increasingly impressive Windows Phone operating system the 930 is a serious contender against the iPhone 6 and S6. It also happens to be a seriously powerful smartphone as well with a 5-inch Full-HD display, 20MP camera and professional levels of film recording thanks to four mics for full stereo pickup.
Suggest a correction
Comments

CONVERSATIONS