Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Amy Lamé

GET UPDATES FROM Amy Lamé
 

Bullying is Making the Obesity Epidemic Worse

Posted: 11/11/2011 22:00

One recent Sunday morning I was sitting in the breakfast room of the Jurys Inn in Belfast, enjoying a plate of scrambled eggs and bacon when a wiry, boisterous man asked if he could join me. Usually I'd say no. Hotel breakfast rooms are usually full of mad, half-asleep people.

Anyway, this chap had a familiar face, especially to those who may have been interested in Trotskyist diatribes in Merseyside in the 1980s (okay, he was Derek 'Degsy' Hatton). So I said, sit down, please join me.

We were both due to appear on a popular BBC 1 programme called Sunday Morning Live, a topical debate show focusing on moral, ethical and religious issues.

We were discussing the issue of fat on the show - no, not the kind that skirts a ribeye steak, or the type you rub into flour and sugar to make a crumble topping. The kind of fat we were debating just so happened to reside in my midriff, chin, upper arms, thighs, back and arse. Let's just say it was personal.

We were on opposing sides of the argument, and narrowly managed to avoid a confrontation over toast. Later, on the programme, it would become clear that Degsy found my fat repulsive, immoral and a drain on the National Health Service. But for the moment, I was busy fixating on his breakfast plate.

As I tucked in, Degsy flagged down the waitress and placed a special order. "I want four poached eggs, but no yolks - ONLY the whites. Got that?" (to be read in a Scouse accent).

He then proceeded to unwrap what could only be described as a drugs parcel - a foil-wrapped package containing at least two dozen different pills, capsules and potions that Degsy informed me he takes daily to keep him in good health.

To call my appearance on this television show a milestone in the world of fat politics would be an exaggeration, but it did make something pop in my mind.

The topic up for discussion was: "Is it irresponsible to be fat?"

I was subjected to a 15 minute personal attack on my physique by Degsy and some psychobabbly doctor (whose name I can't remember) on live television. When I attempted to make a case against their blatant, rabid body facism, I was shouted down.

Dr Whatsername kept staring at my rotund belly with wonderment and intrigue. Degsy was grabbing my chunky arm, stroking it every time he wanted to make a point. I was getting VERY mixed messages; they were trashing me on live television, yet fascinated with my flesh. My conclusion? CLOSET CHUBBY CHASERS, THE PAIR OF 'EM.

One good thing came out of this misguided TV appearance (by the way, thanks, BBC, for ensuring "fair and balanced coverage"). I received hundreds of messages of support from people all over the UK, not just saying how horribly Degsy and the doctor acted, but sharing their own stories of bullying, exclusion and difficulties of being a fat person in a thin world.

Every news source - papers, TV, magazines - seem to be reporting that we are in the grips of an obesity epidemic. No one has the definitive answer on how to tackle it. In the meantime, reality docu-soaps like Fat Families track the tears, tantrums and takeaways of the nations lardy lasses.

The degrading tone - "hey, let's poke fun at the porkies!" - is hardly groundbreaking or responsible television. But people like to laugh at those less fortunate than themselves.

Schadenfreude, anyone?

Victimisation TV is hugely popular - and it gets in the advertisers, too. Crisps, chocolate, dehydrated gravy granules, fast food joints and diet products all love to appear in the advertising slots of programmes that make fun of fat people.

Mixed messages? Hardly. The shows - and adverts - are playing subtle psychological games with us to make us feel superior, dissatisfied and guilty in quick succession. If we manage to feel depressed - or manipulated - enough to keep tuning in and purchase their products, they've won.

You may think, "oh, come on, it's only a bit of fun" or "they deserve to be laughed at; they're fat, lazy and ugly". Or perhaps you think these programmes actually do the participants some sort of good - it's the kick up the fat ass they need to help them shed their obese excess and find everlasting happiness as a thin person.

What these programmes really do is allow and advocate a carte blanche to abuse anyone not fitting into a narrowly-defined body norm.

Have you ever followed the hashtag Twitter comments during an episode of Embarrassing Fat Bodies? The abuse is phenomenal - Dr Christian has A LOT to answer for.

So what is the real impact of all this? Quite simply, it makes fat people feel angry, depressed and worthless. Which, for some, means they may eat more in order to comfort their pain. Which makes them fatter. And so the cycle continues.

Why must the onus be on fat people to break the cycle; i.e stop eating, rather than the abusers halt their hurtful words? In a society so concerned with 'anti-bullying', this fat-phobia is a despicable tragedy. One recent anti-bullying campaign - against homophobia - had the catchphrase 'It Gets Better'.

Well, quite frankly, it doesn't. For fat people, it gets worse...a lot worse. If you were bullied on the playground for being porky, and expect once you grow up for your fellow adults to treat you with respect, you're in for a shock.

TV shows are sanctioning adult bullies to revel in their hideous playground tactics. All this bullying is making the 'obesity epidemic' worse.

And just in case you thought that TV shows were the only ones to blame, you're wrong. The government is one of the worst culprits, with its threat of a "fat tax", selling off school playing fields, reducing funds available for after-school sports, abolishing the free fruit programme for school children, and being entirely beholden to the food manufacturing industry giants who have a vested interest in us eating cheap, nasty nosh, to keep their profit margins healthy, not us.

The government insists fat people are a drain on the NHS. Well, guess what: I'm fat and pay my taxes, and have every right to access the NHS as any other Joe or Jane Schmo. I don't have children, and never will. Do I decry pregnant women as a drain on the NHS? Or those that can't have children accessing NHS funded IVF treatment? No, I don't. We're all in it together.

And in case you were wondering, that is not some 'Big Society' proclamation. Cameron is a blatant liar - he's dismantling the NHS, but put up billboards across the nation during his election campaign promising he'd do nothing of the sort. In order to cover up his deceit, he's flinging his shit onto fat people. After all, they are slow moving, easy targets.

It seems morning after morning on Radio 4's Today programme, John Humphries and Evan Davis try to uncover the 'magic bullet' answer to the obesity epidemic. Eat less, exercise more, join a weight loss club, get a gastric band, try hypnosis, drink diet shakes, get liposuction, cut out carbs, cut out sweets, cut out fat, cut out anything remotely tasty. Allow doctors to prod, poke, prescribe. Or just stay at home and repent for your sins.

There are many, many reasons why people are fat; the multitude of reasons does not have one easy solution. But not bullying fat people is a very good place to start.

 

Follow Amy Lamé on Twitter: www.twitter.com/amylame

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:40 PM on 11/14/2011
Wow, what a lazy article. 'stop making fun of me being fat as that will make me fatter.' Except Amy - you are never going to lose weight as your whole 'media' persona is now based on being fat - so to lose any weight would basically end your career. Your biography at the top of this piece doesnt describe you as "Fat flowery feminist floosie" for nothing. And if I called anyone what you call yourself then that would probably be abusive in your mind - so it therefore isnt just others who throw insults - by your own argument you are throwing them at yourself.
04:10 AM on 11/14/2011
Amy, have a look at the new film "Forks Over Knives". I believe the full version is on Youtube. Science (real science, not mainstream commercial science slanted by financial interests) is coming to the conclusion that obesity is on the rise as the result of two things -- foods processed, adulterated and sold by mega-industry, which is designed to not satiate or nourish (hence your breakfast companions need for so many supplements), and a program of emotional and mental conditioning, which you touch on here, but which is covered more in the film. I think you will find it VERY informative, and outrageous. We've basically been their guinea pigs, and the government has colluded. The agencies that make dietary recommendations are *populated* by a majority of people with financial interests in the industries that starve us of real nutrients. I'm older than you, and am finally slimming down simply because my digestive system has "broken" now after so many years taking the "way we eat" for granted. I now get sick eating many things that are actually nutritious. So I may end up looking better on the outside, but not without expense to my health. The thing is, even people who are average-sized and think they eat well are at risk, they just don't know it. I think you'll find the film fascinating, and definitely pass it on!
09:17 AM on 11/15/2011
thanks for this, mayalibre, will def look up that film, sounds really interesting...stay happy & well! x x
11:23 PM on 11/13/2011
One only has to read the comments to this excellent piece to see just how much hatred is flung at fat people.

Go on, read the comments, and imagine that instead of fat, they're talking about gay people, black people, people with disabilities... anything. Put yourself in the place of anyone who is fat reading the comments. How do you feel?

Fat people are just that... PEOPLE. Human beings with lives, loves, emotions, families, jobs, hobbies, passions... Who all deserve, just like anyone else, to go through their lives without being bullied, discriminated against or vilified by the media.
11:50 PM on 11/13/2011
I think it more appropriate to replace fat with "alcoholic or drug addicted". Unfortunate conditions, difficult to beat but certainly not in the same league as sexuality or race. It is incredibly offensive for you to equate the "discrimination" you face to the real and frequently treatment I receive regularly because of the colour of my skin. You can go on a diet; I cannot wave a magical wand and suddenly be white. I'm sick of people like you painting your gluttony and laziness as a social justice rather than a health issue. It's as though some fat people want to be victims.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:59 PM on 12/14/2011
It's a form of dehumanization in all cases. And here we go with the stereotypical "glutton and lazy" argument that is hashed back to anyone that is overweight. While analyzing stereotypes and the pain that different people suffer - it's important to understand that it is a form of hate. Class, race, sexuality, body size, hair color, eye color - if you take that and spin it around at someone based on their outwards appearance then you are just as guilty of dehumanization as Nazis, White Supremacists, and hatemongers. Man! How I wish it was so easy to just STOP EATING and be THIN suddenly with that magic wand!

Because it's not like I haven't been trying for the past 30 years. It must be so easy, right? I mean, obviously, you can do it. So why can't I? Well, again, it comes down to people having different internal struggles with their body. Fast metabolism, low metabolism, caloric intake, diabetes, mental health ... there's no "magic wand" LaraJ 78.

Oh, and even when people discriminate against you because of the color of your skin, do you suddenly wish that you were a different color? No? Good, because I don't want to be super skinny just because someone else can't get it out of their craw. I pay taxes. I don't have children. At 200 lbs, I'm in better condition healthwise than my thin friends.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:03 PM on 12/14/2011
But yet I get turned down for job interviews, I get teased, I get snickered at, I get jokes flung my way... but I'm supposed to take it because it is so easy to lose the weight, right? Please. Grow up and step outside of yourself to see the struggles that everyone faces and not just one person.
11:13 PM on 11/13/2011
I deplore the way you were treated on live television, I find it completely reprehensible. Bullying is the solution to nothing.

Indeed, until about 4 months ago, I might have also completely agreed with you, that being fat is not a choice we make. But about 4 months ago, I decided, that, after being moderately overweight since my teens, and with the scales creeping ever higher, I needed to do something about it. Because of all the people in this country who are significantly overweight, I assumed it must logically be really hard to loose it! If not, surely everyone would have done it by now?

So I found a calorie counting website (myfitnesspal.com), set a target of a pound a week, and started tracking ALL my food AND drink. And it was... easy. I'm down nearly 2 stone since I started. Once you start to count the calories, it is SOO easy to see where the extra comes from (for me: beer/wine and the '2nd dinner' when you get in after the pub)!

So suddenly, I have lost almost all sympathy for the 'I've tried everything nothing works!' crowd. Sure, culture plays a role, genetics probably too. Sure we live in a world where its easy to overeat and underexercise. That's why I got this way. But it wasn't impossible to change it! In fact it was way way easier than I ever thought...!
02:31 PM on 11/12/2011
"by the way, thanks, BBC, for ensuring "fair and balanced coverage" "- you didn't really think it would be fair and balanced, come on it's the BBC!
01:56 PM on 11/12/2011
So people in third world countries get fat because they are under stress, etc. etc.? Give me a break! Obesity is a condition unique ONLY TO US in the the 'developed world' where a conbination of formative diet (that which we eat as children) and adult ignorance/indiscipline leads people to become obese. END OF STORY.

In my teens, 20's and 30's I weighed a muscular + athletic 13 stone (at 6'2") because I was disciplined about THE TYPE OF FOOD I consumed and did plenty of sport. Since then I have become indisciplined and don't exercise anywhere close to what I should be doing so I have lost muscle mass and gained fat. The fact that I now weigh 16 stone is 100% MY FAULT.

It would seem that the amount of excuses people make up increases in direct proportion to how huge they are.. The first step to losing the excess pounds is to wake up and be honest with yourself. We are the masters of our own destiny and should not be looking to others for either blame or help.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheMysteriousStranger
05:36 PM on 11/12/2011
Quit calling explanations "excuses." The bigotries towards the LGBTQ community were justified because the perpetrators called all new evidence that contradicted their beliefs "excuses," too. As someone who is bi-sexual and fat, It literally makes me sick to see people following that same line of logic here.

The title is not "causing the obesity epidemic," it's "making the obesity epidemic worse." I.e. perpetuating it. Your militant insistence on weight loss, devoid of compassion or consideration, is what causes people to hide in comfort food. It's not encouraging, it's insulting and shameful. It's meant to be, and you know it, because part of you is thinking, "yeah, take that, fatties!"

Know how I know?

Because I went through the same thing you are.

But then I was made to see the damage I was doing to people. I stepped back, and I realized that people like Amy are right. People who are struggling with depression and use food as a catalyst don't require scorn or mockery, or derision. They require self-acceptance before they can be convinced to improve themselves. And that's not the only reason people GET fat, not by a long shot. It doesn't always have to do with food.

You identify all fatness as the result of an action without factoring in things like psychological health, self-image, economic status, biological factors and so-on because it's inconvenient to imagine that this topic may be more complex than you want to admit.
12:02 PM on 11/13/2011
I have 4 kids ( grow up ) 1 has always been '' thin ''....2 '' average '' and 1 ''bigger ''....they were all brought up the same...same diet, same exercise etc......they were born with those genes.....so yes they could gain weight or lose it, by tryig extra hard and changing their lifestyle......which may make my bigger child thinner, the 2 average kids thin and my thin child very underweight.....
However....the question is WHY ???....WHY would they want to or need to ; they are all happy ( other than my bigger kid who has been on the brunt of some prejeduce ).....they are all healthy, working, paying taxes and dare I say it...LIVING their lives...not harming ayone else.....
Its not always over indulgece or greed or whatever some of you wish to label it.....we are all different...some born brunette, some blonde.....some dye our hair cos we dont like it....but some of us are quite happy the way WE ARE and the way OTHERS ARE....
Live and let live....treat others the way we would like to be treated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
redsquad
Shootin' from the lip
01:50 PM on 11/12/2011
Well said missus!
Who'll be the next target of the finger-pointing? Pasty faced people getting skin cancer? New mothers get all sorts of money-draining help thrown at them, yet they CHOOSE to get pregnant (often over and over), then we have IVF being tossed around as if it's an "illness" not to be able to have children these days when the population is balooning.
12:22 PM on 11/12/2011
I agree that there are some very nasty people out there. Being overweight automatically makes people think that it is there fault, people look at overweight people and think of them as lazy and then thinks well they could lose weight if they could be bothered to lose weight but this is not always the case. A person is overweight for many different reasons so we should never judge.

Claire Hegarty a leading Gastric Band Hypnotherapy expert said in the media recently that people think that being overweight is an option when it is not. She explained that people can become overweight through stress, through a bad relationship and many other reasons and that we she never judge someone on their weight.

I agree. I was one overweight and for over five years i struggled to lose weight and done everything i could to lose weight. I spent thousands and thousands of pounds on diets, my doctor was not interested and i only managed to finally lose weight after having hypnotherapy to help me.

We should never judge, we should never bully and bullying should be illegal. It is what is inside that matters and people should remember that and for people who look at someone and thinks cruel things then they should be ashamed of themselves.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
werba
12:00 PM on 11/12/2011
Well said, Amy! There is so much more to being overweight than 'eating too much!' I will never forget a colleague telling me that if my overweight husband only had a bit more willpower, he could be as thin as her husband. Yeah,right - her 6 ft 5 in, ten stone wiry spouse came from a long thin line of people all over 6 ft and all weighing under 11 stone, and he had the most unstressful job ever, with nice little salad lunches and dainty snacks served to him. His working day was 10 am - 5pm (with no commute at all )& he was able to go to the gym three evenings a week.

My husband came from a long line of overweight people & has the most stressful job imaginable, with no nice little light lunches on a lunch hour - he gets none but is expected to chew on a pizza where he works. His working day is 9 am to 7.30 pm with a 3 hour commute, and when he gets home at 9 pm he is far too tired to go anywhere. Will power? She can stuff it up her you know what.
11:19 AM on 11/12/2011
Hear hear ! Tubbies of the world unite ! You have nothing to lose .....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
redsquad
Shootin' from the lip
01:53 PM on 11/12/2011
You don't have to be 'fat' to agree that the government targeting certain parts of the population for 'blame' in order to cover up their own inadequecies is sickening.
11:15 AM on 11/12/2011
Overweight people do not usualy choose to be that way, but footballers, pot holers, mountaineers etc all cost the health service huge amounts and its through their own choice. many conditions needing treatment are caused or made worse by our life choices, skin cancer, diabetes, even housemaids bloody knee. To pick on fat people is pure discrimination. Who will be next?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
11:09 AM on 11/12/2011
you are right. i know how it feels. thanks for speaking/writing about it.
08:21 AM on 11/12/2011
well said Amy, smokers usually get it, well I wonder where all the tax smokers pay on cigarettes goes!!