Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Becky Gamester

GET UPDATES FROM Becky Gamester
 

Back Home: How the Media Got Ukraine Wrong

Posted: 22/06/2012 01:00

Racism and hooligan violence were supposed to greet England fans travelling to Ukraine for Euro 2012, if certain sections of the British media were to be believed. They couldn't have been more wrong.

In the run-up to the tournament, whispers about what horrifying scenes England fans might find in the country culminated in a surprisingly one-sided documentary from Panorama that has had no relevance to the experience fans have had out here so far. Apart from new songs dedicated to Sol Campbell, that is.

Certain publications seemed to decide there would be 'trouble' at England's final group game against Ukraine in particular. The Daily Mail told fans at home that ultras over here were 'promising violent clashes' on 'hundreds of stickers in Donetsk' - stickers which nobody seems to have seen - and England fans would be 'shocked by the welcome some Ukrainians are planning for them'. Unless locals giving English fans free chocolates and writing folk songs for us is some sort of hooligan rally call, this report could not have been more wrong (the ludicrous suggestion that 10,000 England fans would be at the game, when it was obvious the numbers would be more like half that, is perhaps a marker on how much research was done for this story).

While working on the Football Supporters' Federation's Fans' Embassy I have heard nothing but praise for the locals in both Donetsk and Kiev. I have listened to several stories about residents putting up stranded England fans (thanks to the 'phantom' accommodation issues, which I will mention later), some even without charge. You only have to walk down the street for someone to stop and ask you if you need any help with anything, to ask for your thoughts on the tournament so far, or even just to use the opportunity to practise their English.

Even after Ukraine's 1-0 defeat to England at the fabulous Donbass Arena, while the home supporters were obviously disappointed with the result they were also keen to shake opposition fans' hands and say it was a good game. It is also the only match I have been to where there has been no segregation of fans whatsoever - something that, ironically, simply does not happen in our own domestic leagues for fear of violence. And you know what? It worked. There were a few Ukraine fans in the England section and vice versa yet was absolutely no tension. The fact that the England contingent not only stayed quiet for, but actually enthusiastically applauded, the Ukraine national anthem at the beginning of the match speaks volumes.

As for racism, as far as I'm aware there simply hasn't been any. The non-white England fans have had as much praise for the people here as everybody else. Speaking at a Q&A at the Golden Lion, the England fans' pub in Donetsk, ex-footballer Stan Collymore said when he recently asked Ghanaian students in the country for their experiences, they thought the suggestion of racism was so ludicrous that they were surprised he even brought the subject up in the first place.

The icing on the media's fictional cake was when England fans 'arranged' for a shoddily-made coffin to be delivered to the Golden Lion in a reference to Campbell's ill-informed advice to not travel to the tournament. It was also accompanied by a poster saying "you're wrong Sol Campbell". I suspect those watching at home will have heard chants referencing this, but that doesn't necessarily mean fans would go out of their way to arrange what in my opinion was a publicity stunt. Not long afterwards, the Mirror, followed by The Sun - and the Daily Mail who incorrectly said the coffin would be taken to the stadium - published an article on the 'story' complete with pictures.

The one negative aspect of the trip, which is perhaps a more newsworthy topic that hasn't been covered so much by the press back home, is that fans have booked and paid for hostels or campsites, then turned up in Donetsk or Kiev only to find the accommodation doesn't exist - and worryingly, these places are still being advertised on the internet. Booking.com, one of the websites used by fans, have disabled reservations for 'phantom' venues in both Ukraine and Poland. A spokesman for booking.com said: "Booking.com is a reservation service, not a travel agent. We are not recommending any particular hotel, but we are aware some of these properties did not exist which is fraudulent activity locally and have been dealt with by local authorities.

"Fans affected should contact booking.com if you have not yet been contacted by us. We would recommend customers look at our reviews, which are genuine and have been made by guests."

Let's hope the issue is sorted before thousands of 'Roy Hodgson's Barmy Army' arrive in Kyiv, and then possibly travel to Warsaw, in what has already been a much better tournament than expected both on and off the pitch.

 

Follow Becky Gamester on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BeckyGamester

FOLLOW UK SPORT
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:49 AM on 07/23/2012
Good story Becky!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
02:45 PM on 06/25/2012
Lets not blame the BBC for their reporting on the subject matter...I give fully credit where it deserves to Poland and the Ukraine for cleaning up their problems regarding racism and Hooliganism...however lets not pretend that just because they put a good face on for the world, those problems ddon't exist nor will they not pop right back up when Sky packs up the cameras and goes home. Anyone who has seen images of the Polish and Ukranian domestic leagues will testify that the odious chanting and hooligan violence will still occurr on a regular basis next seaon.
04:23 PM on 06/23/2012
Unfortunately, this negative media attention from the English is only a small variant of the rather uneducated view of Eastern Europe by Britain in general. As a Ukrainian who has lived and studied in the UK for years, its very sad to see that there are many negative stereotypes that are still around. No one really understands the politics of Ukraine or the politics of Eastern Europe. Hell, I'll go as far to say that many English people don't actually understand the difference between a Ukrainian or a Russian. In a society that has praised itself for being 'multi-cultural' and so afraid of racism and discrimination - Eastern Europeans are sometimes seen as the irritants of Europe.
01:26 PM on 06/23/2012
What about the 250,000 dogs who have been rounded up and either cremated while they are still alive or buried in mass graves in order to 'clean up' the streets for football fans?
This comment has been removed.
12:43 AM on 07/23/2012
In the first place, this story shows that media twists things around. And I wouldn't be suprised if they did the same for the dog situation. I am for animal rights, but those groups also give false infos. I have seen some of the many strays in Ukrainian towns. They appeared remarkably well-fed and happy. One lay down in the middle of a busy sidewalk, with laughing eyes watched people step over it. How are stray dogs dealt with in England? Or here in Canada? Behind closed doors, right? And ours are countries that can more easily afford the humain facilities.

Anyway, it was not for the fans this was done. And improvements were made before the matches.
Also, I must say, left-wingers in the media seem to smear Ukraine and other eastern countries; probably for their past opposition to communist dictatorships.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fozwords
Abandon hope when you post on here
11:57 AM on 06/23/2012
Well its no surprise really, Panorama has seldom reported the facts as they are, rather the facts as they believe the public want to see them, what was once a valued programme of guaranteed evidence is no no more than a telivised version of somthing between the Sun and the Daily mail. Like other organisations, especially BBC organisations and Parliament itself, Panorama now believe what we want to see and hear, one of the reasons I no longer wtch all their programmes or any programme right through. Once you can smell the plot, time to switch over.
The real problem is that these people self perpetuate and will continue in these I am greater than thou roles forever, unfortunately.
11:33 AM on 06/23/2012
The only thing that would surprise me about the UK media would be if it ever got anything right.
07:38 AM on 06/23/2012
Modern day British Brainwashing Corporation = (BBC).
Thank you David icke.
This comment has been removed.
06:33 PM on 06/22/2012
I am sorry Between Russia and other eastern Europe there have been advisories for black people not to travel out there. It crazy how they feel about black people.
And please dont act like the fans werent making monkey noises at black players. Most black players couldnt even invite their families to come to the Euros because of the rascism.
Of course its hard for you to see. Walk around with people of colour in these countries and then come back and report about it. You obviously havent spoken to the black players and what they have been enduring
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fozwords
Abandon hope when you post on here
12:06 PM on 06/23/2012
Dont apologise Liyah, it is the system that is wrong, but in not defense of The Ukraine etc, they have all lived a harsher lifestyle than we in the west have and have not endured the cultural changes we had put in place and continue to put in place.
We still have many ignorant outdated people in this country and will have for generations, the best we can all do is promote acceptance and identify and highlight prejudice. Best wishes
04:16 PM on 06/23/2012
Actually, the problem seems to be worse in Poland than Ukraine: that is where the monkey chants took place and where the majority of problems between fans have occurred. During the soviet times Ukraine was host a very large non-white population because of the educational exchanges so in bigger cities like Kyiv and Lviv, the locals are more used to seeing non-whites. Yes, there are places (and many of them) that have never seen a black person in real life. However, the level of violence towards minorites is nowhere near as bad as let's say Russia. It is rather unfortunate that the British media has portrayed Ukraine in such a negative light and it was because of this rather than factual reports that many of the English player's families didn't show up (although, not having the WAG's around helped people actually enjoy the game rather than their fashion statements) - my brother was in Donetsk, and while he had issues with the city infrastructure, he had a great time and said the people were terrific.
05:19 PM on 06/22/2012
Someone in the BBC clearly had their own agenda. There was the racist program, some of which looked clearly staged (it is a problem but BBC exaggerated it), there was another about a village's lost Jewish roots and another about lost children and continual sniping about violence and racism and dodgy politics (it is!). Why at this time? Presumably because someone high up in the Beeb wanted to take a dig at the Ukraine for political reasons at the most embarrassing time for Ukraine and Poland. Shame on them!
firstwizard
Never trust anyone that says "Trust me.."
09:11 PM on 06/21/2012
My girlfriend lives right outside of Donetsk. The times I have been there the people while not being as friendly as say the people in Scotland, they are far from rude.
05:20 PM on 06/22/2012
That's what I call being damned by faint praise!
firstwizard
Never trust anyone that says "Trust me.."
06:01 PM on 06/22/2012
Lol. Well it IS still Eastern Europe. You have to take it for what it is.