Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
B.J. Epstein

GET UPDATES FROM B.J. Epstein
 

Sweden: If a Racist Tweets in a Forest, Does Anyone Care?

Posted: 18/06/2012 00:00

Ah, Sweden. That liberal bastion of neutrality and openness. Not to mention Ingmar Bergman films, long summer days, beautiful blondes, gravlax, IKEA. (Let's skip ABBA - that's a bit more embarrassing.)

Or maybe that should be Sweden, home of seething, barely contained anti-semitism, racism, and distrust of all the "foreigners" who move there and simultaneously take the jobs of real Swedes while not working and simply accepting government money.

Comedian (and I use that term loosely) Sonja Abrahamsson raised a few eyebrows, but apparently little more than that, while tweeting on @sweden's Twitter account this past week. A number of her tweets were bizarre comments or questions about Jews (I won't bother to give any examples here, as there's no point in promoting Abrahamsson, who, incidentally, needs to work on her English skills). How this was supposed to either market Sweden as a wonderful tourist destination or amuse the 52,000+ followers of @sweden is unclear to me.

However, it does bring up important issues about how Sweden, and many other European countries with high percentages of immigrants, sees itself and its future.

Is Sweden a country that truly wants to welcome all people? Or does it just want the reputation of being like that? Or does it regret that it got that reputation and now wants to cleanse itself of those unwanted others?

During my years living in Sweden, I heard numerous xenophobic and anti-semitic comments. I was told directly by potential employers that they'd rather not hire foreigners. I guess they'd rather have foreigners go on welfare, as it gave them something to complain about. I was also warned against living in or even going into certain neighbourhoods, as "blacks" or "Arabs" or "Chinese" lived there, as though it made more sense to create a segregated society. I was regularly told "jokes" about foreigners of all types, Jews, and Muslims. So funny.

A surprising number of Scandinavians have in recent years voted for far-right political parties and have started to demand stricter immigration laws. This isn't the place to discuss their desire to purify their countries or to protect their culture and identity, but I do often wonder what a "pure Swede" might be or what "Swedish culture" is supposed to consist of.

Abrahamsson's tweets, while stupid and not really worth reading in and of themselves, speak to several larger issues in Sweden, and elsewhere. One is the already mentioned topic of who belongs in which culture, and which culture belongs where. What would a Sweden full of foreigners look like? Would it still be Sweden? What would that mean?

Another issue is regarding what is acceptable to say in various contexts. One of @sweden's rules for its microbloggers was that they were not to incite racial hatred. I can't claim that Abrahamsson was doing that, but she was somewhere on that continuum, and she was at the very least making derogatory, ridiculous comments about Jews. I can't help wondering if there wouldn't have been more of an outcry had she been referring to just about any other group of people; somehow, even in this politically correct era, it's still acceptable to make snide remarks or tell jokes about Jews.

Even though there has been a minor commotion about Abrahamsson's Jewish comments, she hasn't stopped. Even as I write this, she is posting about there being so many Jews in advertising - way to go with the stereotyping, Sonja. Meanwhile, she claims that not all Swedes are the same, so why would she think any group is monolithic, as some of her earlier remarks have implied? Oh, and incidentally, a certain number of Swedes are Jews, but I'm guessing she hasn't thought about that. She acts as though Swede and Jew are exclusive categories.

Why @sweden lets Abrahamsson continue her inane tweeting is something I can't quite comprehend. She is promoting the idea of an insular, racist country that doesn't welcome or accept those who are different. That doesn't exactly make people want to get on the next plane to Stockholm.

I suspect they'll just go to their local IKEA instead. You can pretend you're in Sweden there, and the people are friendlier and more open, too, at least if Sonja Abrahamsson is anything to go by.

 

Follow B.J. Epstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bjepstein

FOLLOW UK TECH
Ah, Sweden. That liberal bastion of neutrality and openness. Not to mention Ingmar Bergman films, long summer days, beautiful blondes, gravlax, IKEA. (Let's skip ABBA - that's a bit more embarrassing.
Ah, Sweden. That liberal bastion of neutrality and openness. Not to mention Ingmar Bergman films, long summer days, beautiful blondes, gravlax, IKEA. (Let's skip ABBA - that's a bit more embarrassing.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
3Nox
Turns into a hedgehog when messed with
10:19 PM on 06/21/2012
I think it's really unfair of you to say she needs to work on her English when she's from a foreign country. It sounded good enough.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:05 PM on 06/19/2012
What's wrong with ABBA?!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
What's the story mourning Tories?
11:40 AM on 06/19/2012
It seems to me britain and Sweeden are seperated twins. Our cultures while different are very complementary, and thats no surprise considering they are amoung our closest cultural relatives. Ou languages for a start have so much in common, even if it doesn't seem so. With all this in mind, and knowing a fair few Swedes, it seems to me their attitudes mirror the UKs. All this negative stuff can be found in th British public in about the same concentration. In fact every nation has a problem with anti semitism and every nation has plenty of people who moan about immigration. We can sometimes think of these as white european issues. Far from it.
Sweden can look worse than it is. They've got a right wing government for the first time in decades, and like everywhere else, times are bad, and when recession hits, prejudice always spikes, compunded by the fact immigration rises. I personally think therefor immigration should be controlled better, however this will pass. And let it be said most Swedes are sane decent people, these prejudiced people are the minority.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gods own child
Weapons legitimise a regime
09:01 AM on 06/19/2012
If people didn't misidentify themselves as jews, muslims, christians etc, they wouldn't be upset when criticism of these groups was expressed, in the same way as football fans of a particular club. We are all brothers and sisters regardless, not enemies.
03:23 AM on 06/19/2012
I assume you are aware of the black irony in your essay..perhaps not,are you American. ( Gosh! I'm at it too! ) Poor little Sweden who wouldnt harm a fly! Immigrants come. Are mal-treated. Integrate. Flourish. New immigrants come..its the story of every nation that depends on immigrant labour. Sweden is no differant. C.I.
01:56 AM on 06/19/2012
In the UK we have opened our doors and it sort of worked for us. It has delivered good economic growth and all the skilled workers we want. The problems are self evident but then again I think it was worth the price. Sweden is entitled to do things their own way after all they have a massive welfare state and people are always protective of how their taxes are spent so i can understand how any "outsiders" might be considered a threat.
03:11 AM on 06/19/2012
In Sweden immigration is a huge burden and although the problems are self evident anyone who dares to speak up about them risk being branded as racists. It has not produced much in the way of skilled workers instead adding to the jobless rates. It takes the average immigrant seven years to find a job in Sweden. The average, that means there are many who take considerably longer tiem. If only they were taking "our" jobs! If only! Now they just take our welfare checks.
09:47 PM on 06/18/2012
"Abrahamsson, who, incidentally, needs to work on her English skills"

Being racist in an article that criticises others for being racist is probably not the best way to make your argument
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parthiban Yahambaram
10:54 PM on 06/18/2012
Running someone down for speaking lousy English is not racist. Arrogant and conceited, perhaps, but definitely not racist.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gods own child
Weapons legitimise a regime
06:44 PM on 06/18/2012
When allowed freedom of speech, people are often only too pleased to make fools ot themselves, whether archbishops on homosexuality, or tweeters on immigration or religion, or us huffers on The Huff.
Probably best that we carry on that way and take the applause or the flak, however clever or stupid we may be, some of the stupid might be won over in the process.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:45 AM on 06/19/2012
Well said, the alternatives to freedom of speech are all worse than freedom of speech in my view. Just because I don't agree with someone, or find their views offensive even, doesn't mean they don't have the right to express those views.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
11:51 AM on 06/18/2012
Sorry to hear of your experiences of Sweden BJ, I hope things have improved since, let's hear from some Swedes on their opinions...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oferdesade
08:13 AM on 06/18/2012
kingbird is absolutely right. there is absolutely NO reason to confuse antisemitism with racism. nazism and antisemitism in sweden are so acceptable that "antisemitism in sweden" actually has its own wikipedia entry. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Sweden one could not for quite some time walk into an ikea in israel coz the nazi founding father refused to open shop there. now that they're open - their po;pularity is mere testament to the self abasing stupidity of israelis in general. as for volvos, its a shame they're such good cars. why they're not boycotted by jews the world over while some german cars still are is a mystery.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:59 PM on 06/18/2012
Can you provide more information please oferdesade? What is the problem with Volvo's? Several Jewish friends of mine won't buy German cars, but buy Swedish ones instead, typically Saabs I have to say, but this is something of which I was not aware.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oferdesade
08:30 AM on 06/19/2012
oops - i let my sarcasm get away with me not too clearly. nothing wrong with volvos or saabs - excellent cars. just the fact they're swedish. i would call for a boycott on them just as the boycott people in the uk would like to boycott internet chat, celphones, most computer processors, drip irrigation, medical stents ...
but that would be self defeating.
personally i would prefer a german car - at least the (pre-WW-2) germans were HONEST in their intents, and didnt try to cover it over with pseudo humanitarianism.
03:28 PM on 06/18/2012
Doesn't seem like you actually read my comment...

Furthermore, "antisemitism in the United States" actually has its own Wikipedia entry too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_United_States

I don't think that's any proof that nazism or antisemitism is acceptable, not in Sweden nor the US.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oferdesade
08:31 AM on 06/19/2012
the difference is that when you read AS in US your ealize its one more trend in a very pluralistic society. when u look at the swedish article you are shocked to learn of the establishment complicity.
07:40 AM on 06/18/2012
Let's add some missing facts:

Sweden scored an amazing 9.2 on migration in the Commitment to Development Index (CDI). UK? 3.5. USA? 4.9. France? 3.4. Here's what it measures from Wikipedia: "The CDI rewards migration of both skilled and unskilled people, though unskilled more so. It uses data on the gross inflow of migrants from developing countries in a recent year and the net increase in the number of unskilled migrant residents from developing countries during the 1990s. The CDI also uses indicators of openness to students from poor countries and aid for refugees and asylum seekers."

In 2010 14.3% of the population were foreign-born. Few countries can compare with that level of openness. 

It may not be wise to let people speak their minds on behalf of Sweden on the official twitter account as some stupid and controversial comments are bound to be posted at some point. Personally, I think it's an interesting idea to let the citizens have the voice of their government and for it to be interesting it must be their own voice.

Abrahamsson's brand of comedy might not be worthy of being the official voice of Sweden. I believe I would agree with that, but that's not the point. If you give the opportunity to someone to express themselves you don't censor it unless they clearly break the rules (kudos to those responsible for the account for not backing down on the idea in face of international criticism).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deluk
disgusted.
02:36 PM on 06/18/2012
I lived in Sweden, the folks on the street generally do not reflect the liberalism espoused by their governments, Stockholm, not surprisingly is the most segregated city in Europe, and never have I met a nation more obsessed by it's image.
This comment has been removed.