Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dame Helena Shovelton

GET UPDATES FROM Dame Helena Shovelton
 

Calls for a Ban on Smoking in Cars Are Welcome, but Action on Children Is Needed Now

Posted: 17/11/11 00:00 GMT

The call yesterday by the British Medical Association (BMA) for a total ban on smoking in private vehicles is a welcome recognition by the country's doctors that this issue should be at the top of the government's health agenda, and at the British Lung Foundation we support any action that would improve lung health. We realise that a blanket ban however, is a vast and contentious issue that is likely to stretch long into future public discourse. Getting government to take action to protect children from passive smoke in cars is a more realisable and urgent objective. It is clear that momentum is gathering on this worrying health issue in the widest sense, but the immediate priority should be children.

Adults choose to smoke, but children are trapped in the confines of a car with no choice over the fumes they inhale. While we legislate to protect adults both at work and at leisure, we fail to protect children in one of the situations in which they are exposed to unacceptably dense concentrations of second-hand smoke. Over half of children aged 8 - 15 say they have been exposed to cigarette smoke in the car. Research by the University of Aberdeen University has shown that smoking in a car exposes children to the same levels of smoke in a busy smoke-filled pub.

Every year over 300,000 children in the UK go to their GP with illnesses such as bronchitis and pneumonia as a result of exposure to passive smoking, an astonishing statistic that highlights need for immediate Government action. In straitened times, the financial incentive for government to take action on the issue is also convincing. According to a 2010 report by the Royal College of Physicians, this cost the Government over £22 million per annum in UK primary care visits and hospital admissions in England.

Alex Cunningham, MP for Stockton North has been a leading political voice on this issue, tabling a Ten Minute Rule Bill which passed first reading in the House of Commons last June. But Parliament needs to take the lead in addressing this. The Welsh Assembly has already committed to considering legislative action if a behaviour change campaign is found to have not worked, and just this week Edwin Poots, the Health Minister in Northern Ireland Assembly agreed to consider action on this issue.

Action has been firmer abroad, with eight out of 10 Canadian provinces having introduced legislation to protect children are involved. Five American states including Arkansas and Louisiana have also judged that individual liberty does not trump child health, and all but one state in Australia agrees.

One of the more reasonable doubts that has been expressed over the legislative option is the question of enforcement, citing the example of the oft-abused mobile phone legislation. There was an insufficient amount of public education on the mobile phones issue before it became a law, in contrast to compulsory seatbelt wearing, which had a comprehensive public education programme. The government therefore needs to thoroughly evaluate the findings from the marketing strategy it has committed to for March next year, and should consider legislation if it has not been found to be effective.

 
The call yesterday by the British Medical Association (BMA) for a total ban on smoking in private vehicles is a welcome recognition by the country's doctors that this issue should be at the top of the...
The call yesterday by the British Medical Association (BMA) for a total ban on smoking in private vehicles is a welcome recognition by the country's doctors that this issue should be at the top of the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:11 PM on 11/18/2011
You increased the exposure of children to tobacco smoke by obtaining a ban on smoking in all non-residential buildings. I suspect much car smoking goes on because the driver is soon to arrive at a place where he or she will be prohibited from smoking. Similarly at the end of the day on leaving a place where smoking is prohibited. Smoking prevalence was falling steadily before the smoking ban. For the three years following, it remained at 22%. None of this smoking is now done indoors apart from at home or in the car. Allowing smoking rooms in pubs and cafes would lessen children's exposure. Allowing employers the choice of providing smoking rooms would lessen it even more.
09:33 PM on 11/17/2011
A ban on smoking in cars is NOT welcome! Adults should have the right to their own lifestyle choices without interference from the despised Nanny state. Thanks to govt Smokers remain persecuted and can no longer enjoy a comfortable night out in a pub or even stand and smoke at a bus shelter. Smoking tobacco is a legal activity and adults should be able to be able to continue to smoke if they wish in their own cars.
Adults need to be rationally educated, about real health issues concerning exposing children to smoke if there are any. They must put the welfare and comfort of their children first. A car smoking ban of any kind is a step too far though. Isnt this more about further denormalising smoking and persecuting smokers than protecting children ? The proposal is completely disgusting. Britain has become a police state.
03:47 PM on 11/17/2011
This country is screwed. Despite everyone knowing the stats on smoking in cars is pure fantasy we will hear it spouted time and time again in the HOC on the 25th. l certainly won't watch it on TV, I can't afford a replacement when l throw something at it through sheer disgust.