Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Emma Reynolds

GET UPDATES FROM Emma Reynolds
 

Labour's Call for EU Budget Cuts Is a Principled, Pro-European Argument

Posted: 01/11/2012 18:05

In the wake of the deepest global economic crisis in the post war period, governments across Europe and the world are tightening their belts. In this context, Labour has set out a principled and pro-European argument that the European Union budget should not be exempt from these same challenges.

The economic climate in 2012 could not be more different to the last time the seven year European budget was negotiated. In 2005, our economy was growing and so were many of the economies of our European partners. We had just pushed through the biggest enlargement in the EU's history and had secured the reduction and reform of the Common Agricultural Policy budget.

At a time when my own constituents are seeing severe cuts to police and school budgets, I passionately believe that the government should be trying to secure a cut in the EU budget. Whitehall is imposing a massive 30% cut on the budget of Wolverhampton City Council, a far bigger cut than in Tory heartlands. Labour MPs represent constituencies in which there are high levels of deprivation and we are therefore even more acutely aware of the dire situation those on low and middle incomes find themselves in. So it should come as no surprise that there was not a single Labour MP who voted with the government's position for an inflationary increase in the EU budget.

It is regrettable that at this crucial point in negotiations, the prime minister is weak at home and abroad. He is spending more time managing both his backbenchers and cabinet ministers than negotiating with our European partners. By walking out of the December European Summit last year, the prime minister isolated the UK, squandering vital political capital. The government's stock is now at an all time low which raises questions about the prime minister's ability to secure a good deal for the UK.

The eurozone crisis has provided fertile ground for eurosceptic MPs and journalists to intensify their anti-European campaign. However, the Labour Party has consistently argued for engagement and reform in the EU. For over twenty years, the vast majority of our party has judged that it is in our national interest to remain a full member of the European Union. That remains the case today. Even against the backdrop of the eurozone crisis, the benefits of our membership are clear.

The rest of the EU has for a long time been our major trading partner. The eurosceptic argument that we should choose to focus on the BRICs rather than the EU presents a false choice. The emerging economies of Brazil, Russia, India and China have trillion pound economies and billion person populations. Only with the collective weight of the EU of some 500 million consumers, can we have any hope of negotiating trade deals and prising open markets for British businesses. The UK is immeasurably stronger as part of the largest single market in the world.

European countries have been successful in coming together to meet global challenges, such as climate change, terrorism and cross border crime. European cooperation has far outstripped international cooperation in successfully tackling these problems. For instance, the European Arrest Warrant recently expedited the extradition of the school teacher, who abducted 15 year Meagan, from France back to the UK.

After this divided, shambolic Tory-led Government was defeated on Wednesday evening, overly excitable eurosceptics have tried to paint the Labour Party as anti-European. Nothing could be further from the truth. We remain a united, pro-European party. To allow the budget in Brussels to rise in these straitened times would damage, not promote, the pro-European case.

Labour's pro-Europeanism cannot and should not be measured by the level of EU spending that we are prepared to accept. The EU budget should be subject to the same scrutiny as domestic budgets in the UK and across the Europe. It should strip out inefficiencies, further reduce spending on the Common Agricultural Policy and focus spending on creating jobs and growth. This would be a progressive European budget which recognises the depth of the economic crisis and challenges that all Europeans face.

 

Follow Emma Reynolds on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@EmmaReynoldsMP

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
In the wake of the deepest global economic crisis in the post war period, governments across Europe and the world are tightening their belts. In this context, Labour has set out a principled and pro-E...
In the wake of the deepest global economic crisis in the post war period, governments across Europe and the world are tightening their belts. In this context, Labour has set out a principled and pro-E...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dan Belcher
British National Party Life Member
13:06 on 05/11/2012
@Emma - The labour party are a peadophile ring and you say they've got principles? LABOUR25 (now up to 40+)
16:07 on 02/11/2012
Aye, putting all our eggs in the EU basket has done wonders for our economy, jobs and world standing, we've been relegated to the fourth division in all categories thanks to our "trading partners", anyone old enough to remember when we had the largest merchant shipping fleet on the planet trading with everyone in the world while producing the best goods in the world can see just what being in "partnership" with this organization has done for the good old UK, and its not mostly good, also anyone under the illusion this happened at the dawn of time might be mildly impressed by the fact our self destruction began a mere forty years ago, a thousand years being THE WORLD LEADER to complete meltdown in four decades is a fantastic feat of achievement FOR OUR THREE MAJOR POLITICAL PARTIES.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roy Fowler
I try....I really do!
13:08 on 02/11/2012
Under our EUSSR overlords, my local Ford Transit plant has just closed, dumping another 500 people into the benefits system........meanwhile, the EUSSR is GIVING Turkey a £15 billion "soft loan" so.........yes, can you guess........to open a NEW Ford plant making Transit vans......

And where did part of this money come from? Yes, you know it......the British Taxpayer!!!

Are we just mugs or what Britain!?
18:27 on 02/11/2012
Its government policy Roy, we in the North first got wind of it in the eighties and have now succumbed to having no manufacturing here whatsoever, (oops forgot Nissan, who employ 3000 out of say 2 million pop. of this area) anyway after devastating the Northern half of the country our illustrious leaders are far from happy with the result and have now started on the south, unless you're a politician, top civil servant or banker you're a disposable commodity and your labour is no longer of any value to either our government (a joke) or the EU (the biggest laugh of them all)
ZEB
never fear the zeb is ere
16:24 on 05/11/2012
I am sorry that the ford transit as closed in Southamton, but you have got remember, Ford is a US comp, and they will move to the country that will give them more for cheaper dollers.
Also the transit, looks now days a box on wheels, nothing more or nothing less, tha Mec spriter, or the VW van, can just wipe the Transit off the market.
The transite is out of date, the name needs to reinvent a new kind of van, that can complete with the Mec and VW, sorry that is a nasty fact
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:24 on 02/11/2012
Will someone at HuffP please explain why my perfectly reasonable reply agreeing with jacksdad41's comments regarding Labour's position on the EU budget has been removed? If you're deleting comments simply because Labour supporters disagree and flag them, it tells us all we need to know about you...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mfa11e
Tell the truth ,regardless
16:05 on 02/11/2012
Had the same my self over a different posting.If someone has a moderator badge and they dont like it ,as in a fair and democratic society ,they have the right to remove it.
Seems fair eh?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
16:12 on 02/11/2012
I agree, it’s totally unfair. The politically motivated censorship on here is getting out of hand. If these so-called moderators carry on like this people will start leaving this site in droves. What’s the point in bothering to comment?!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:25 on 02/11/2012
Of course it was dear, you keep telling yourself that! Might sound convincing but not how it looked!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
humphry
The Voynich Manuscripts.
00:37 on 02/11/2012
Yes Labour was in favour of enlargement and just have a look at what happened...Countries like Greece invited to join, and we all know what happened to them Bankrupt!,and Spain and Italy are not far behind them, we would have been in the same boat as well had we joined...Just how much more austerity is the EU going to impose on these countries before they realise they should never have been in the EU in the first place, and cut them lose..Its only a matter of time till the EU implodes and shrinks down to its core members, with Germany running the show.......
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
20:30 on 01/11/2012
And this is from a member of the Labour party! The party that gave up our multi-billion rebate for nothing and which agreed to massive increases in our budget contributions. Now Emma Reynolds says this is a principled pro-European argument! Who does she think she’s kidding?! Labour’s backing of the amendment was hypocrisy and opportunism of the worst kind. It seems Labour will dump their so-called ‘principles’ in a heartbeat for a cheap political advantage…
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jacksdad41
Quant Je Puis
01:47 on 02/11/2012
"Labour's Call for EU Budget Cuts Is a Principled, Pro-European Argument"

You really have to admire the sheer neck of Liebour - they can even spin a lie to make it look like they really actually believe this stuff.

Meanwhile, Neil, Glyniss and Mandy continue to enjoy the ride on the EU gravy train - a shoe in of a job for failed Liebour politicians.
This comment has been removed.
20:12 on 01/11/2012
Labour have no principles. The lbaour party wanted the cut as they know it won't happen and the EU budget will increase.

So the Labour party want an increase in the EU budget.

The EU is about state greed and corruptiona nd nothng else, thats also what the Labour party is about.
concodtob
16 stone athlete and intellectual
18:44 on 01/11/2012
"Labour's Call for EU Budget Cuts Is a Principled, Pro-European Argument".

It's called opportunism and Labour aswell as the Government know full well that to get an actual cut -is impossible. The EU parliament will not go for a cut. They'll be a freeze but that actually translates into another rise in real terms.

It's all a smokescreen to make it look as though the government and opposition are getting tough with the EU. In reality, this is another boot lick from our political elites. Still, the British people get what they deserve - they voted for it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
18:15 on 01/11/2012
The European Parliament is too remote from the voters of Europe and too disconnected from national Parliaments which are sovereign.

The present relationship is dysfunctional because of its anti-democratic nature.

Having a federal structure without federal powers and responsibilities is leading to indecision, bad policies and a lot of careless spending.

Euro-MP's do not answer to anyone. They are a law unto themselves.

The whole edifice needs reforming.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edgar H
Keep the Press free!
17:48 on 01/11/2012
If the best argument for staying in the EU is the European Arrest Warrant makes it quicker to extradite a teacher who wasn't opposing bail, then its best we get out and join Norway and Switzerland on the fringes.