Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gemma Goodman

GET UPDATES FROM Gemma Goodman
 

The World of Intermarriage: Stepping Out of the 'Jewish Bubble'

Posted: 19/12/2012 00:00

It was late one night, for hours I had been plucking up the courage to take that first step into my mum's room and say to her "I have something to tell you." The fears of extradition, anger and general disappointment had put me into such a state of blind panic that it's hard to remember the exact run of events. I began nervously, "I've met someone and he's not Jewish." I wait, my mum doesn't say anything, I carry on. "I think I am going to be with him for a long time, what will you and dad do about it will you cut me out?..."

From the day I was born I have been brought up in a very traditional Jewish household, keeping the Sabbath and going to synagogue every Saturday with my family. I attended both a Jewish primary school and secondary school and only had Jewish friends. I had absolutely no exposure to the world of intermarriage. I was brought up in shall we say the 'Jewish bubble.'

But in my mind, the 'Jewish bubble' was not all its cracked up to be. I became jealous of my less religious friends who went out on a Friday night, I longed to try non- Kosher food and I lashed out against the tight Jewish traditions I had been brought up in.

When I started university I made a concerted decision that I would stay away from my fellow Jewish students and reinvent myself. I wanted to be identified as my own person rather than a Jew. I lived in a non-Kosher flat and moved in with six of my non-Jewish friends. I had become, truly assimilated. My new life didn't involve any Judaism and dating non-Jews became normal. Although my parents had been aware of my floundering Jewish attitude for years, my decision that Judaism was no longer a priority in my life still shocked them.

I sometimes ask myself would my lifestyle choices and attitude towards Judaism be different if I hadn't been brought up the way I was. Am I representative of everyone who grew up like me? This is like trying to answer the age old question of nature vs. nurture. In this instance I think my headstrong and independent nature has led me to be who I am today. I can't blame everything on my parents.

Making this decision to move away from my Jewish roots has not been easy. The push and pull of the pressure of belonging to such an insular community and losing my faith in God has led me to experience a crisis of identity of sorts. At the age of 21, I am having to make the important life choices about whether I will bring my children up Jewish, how important that concept is to me and how it effects others around me.

Because of my choices, I endure resentment from my family members and the shame of being shunned by the wider community. I turn to an amusing anecdote to demonstrate what I have to deal with on a day-to-day basis. It was the day of a close family member's funeral, emotions were high, there I was sitting alone not expecting what was about to occur. Out of the blue, one of my older religious cousins came up to me and embarked on a long and rather horrifying story of his close sexual encounter with a non-Jewish girl making me burst unsurprisingly into tears. Even in the most inappropriate of settings I am never safe from comment and confrontation.

I've often thought about conversion as my decision doesn't just impact me but the way my children would be brought up and how my family is viewed in the Jewish community. I realised however that as selfish as it sounds, being with a Jew is no longer important to me.
It's a shame I experience so much friction with my family and that this matter will never be resolved between us as I am proud of culturally being a Jew. Although I will never be a practicing Jew, I will never lose my Jewish identity which has been deeply ingrained in me. I believe that although I have chosen to be with a non-Jew, I will be able to combine my two lifestyles as I don't want to forget my roots. This is sadly something my parents cannot comprehend.

I hope that in the future the Jewish community will come to terms with young Jews who choose to intermarry. This is not a new phenomenon; intermarriage has been happening for generations and this, whether they like it or not, is something that the Jewish community in the Diaspora has accept otherwise it will be left behind. In the end, most of us have not engaged in a relationship with a non-Jew just to rebel against our upbringing and our Jewish cultural identity.

 

Follow Gemma Goodman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/gemgoodman

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
It was late one night, for hours I had been plucking up the courage to take that first step into my mum's room and say to her "I have something to tell you." The fears of extradition, anger and genera...
It was late one night, for hours I had been plucking up the courage to take that first step into my mum's room and say to her "I have something to tell you." The fears of extradition, anger and genera...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:05 PM on 12/20/2012
Gemma -- there are many ways to be Jewish. It is possible, if you want to and if your partner wants to, to raise Jewish children and to identify your family as Jewish even if your partner is not Jewish. This is increasingly common in the US and something you can find a great deal of support for from the non-profit i run, InterfaithFamily. Good luck
Ed Case
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ian Rennie
It irritates people that I'm a librarian :)
03:17 PM on 12/19/2012
I've never understood the fuss over marrying outside your religious group, for much the same reason I never understood the fuss about marrying outside your racial group. People are people.
02:46 PM on 12/19/2012
Seems like, in the words of Woody Allen, you're not a Jew. You're just Jew-ish.
02:45 PM on 12/19/2012
Even though I am an observant Jew, I can totally see where you're coming from, and even, yes, reluctantly agree with you.
It sounds like you were brought up in a family atmosphere of "we're Jewish, and this is what we do, and you should do it too", without any real understanding or love of what the religion actually is. Of course you're not going to care too much for it when you become independent! To desperately cling to it would be unhealthy.
Your children will have interesting lives, though - for good or for bad. They will ask lots of questions, and find some way to answer them. I know - I am one of those children.
12:29 PM on 12/19/2012
Everyboy knows intermarriage has occured and will still occur, but it is still the exception. The Jewish community strive to continue as a community, religiously, culturally and socially and to do so it needs to be continued.

You do not pose Judaism in a favourable light to those non-Jews who may not understand the 'jewish bubble you refer to' and having come from a similar description, it is fair to say that I do not find it insular but rather comforting. It is the personal choices you made that made it feel so harsh for you.
04:51 PM on 12/19/2012
Then everybody is right; but it happens a lot. Which is one reason why, in the UK at least, the observant Orthodox community is in decline. In this case all the children will be Jewish, whereas if a Jewish man marries a non-Jew, they won't. Now we know about DNA, should this really matter? It's up to them what they make of it; one of my relatives has married back in and converted, and his family is comfortable with their Liberal Jewish environment, but it really is no big deal except for the people who cling to Jewishness as a comfort blanket, and who are really no different from Christians or Muslims who do the same thing. Grown ups go and meet the world on its own terms, and treat people as they find them, while taking pride about the good things in their cultural roots.
Oh yes, good on you, Gemma Goodman.
photo
hearthammer
If left is right and right is wrong, decide!
09:36 AM on 12/19/2012
I always thought that intermarriage didn't exist! I mean, how any people marry aliens? Marrying outside of a religious group isn't intermarriage, it's common sense!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:59 AM on 12/19/2012
You certainly had a battle with your background and your story will perhaps help others who wish to overcome their own upbringing.
This is the great problem with nationalism and religion, they put us into groups and strip us of our true humantity. You will not forget your narrow-minded roots, but you can never return to them now you have a wider view of reality.