Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Genevieve Stewart

GET UPDATES FROM Genevieve Stewart
 

Holy See and Sex

Posted: 26/06/2012 00:00

The declaration text at the UN Conference on Sustainable Development contains no references to reproductive rights.

The weak language pertaining to gender, health and education is largely due to the influence of the Vatican.

The Vatican's permanent mission to the UN, the Holy See, has been included in UN processes as a "permanent non-member observer state" since 1964.

At the Rio Earth Summit in 1992, the Holy See fought and failed to remove the clause calling for "include women-centered, women-managed, safe and effective reproductive health care," and at Rio+20 took up that mission again.

This time, they succeeded in removing any reference to reproductive health and rights from the text though. During the negotiations, the Holy See proposed nearly one hundred deletions and alterations to the text on gender, health and education. More than any member observer state present.

The Holy See's influence at the UN, despite not actually being a member state, is granted based on recognition of the Holy See's religious, spiritual and moral authority in the world.

This position is disputed by Catholics for Choice, who have lobbied against the Holy See's inclusion in UN negotiations since 1999. They argue that they have a "dogmatic agenda" and "[seeks] to use its privileged position under the banner of the Holy See at the UN to impose its agenda on everyone."

That agenda, at Rio+20, has largely been to block progress on advancing sexual health and reproductive rights.

The original text was endorsed by the Major Groups for Women and Children & Youth, with mention of "ensuring universal access to safe, effective, modern, affordable and acceptable family planning." The final text contains the somewhat less decisive verbs "recognise" "aim" and "support" in relation to women's health.

The consequences of the Vatican's agenda could be disastrous for women's rights and sustainable development as a whole.

"Everyone who cares about women should be very, very worried about the Holy See's interference with reproductive rights," says Tania Dethlefsen of a Danish family planning association.

Ensuring access to sexual healthcare, including contraception, is a millennium development goal, yetthe Vatican opposes the use of all types of contraception other than the notoriously unreliable "natural" methods.

Socially and environmentally, the Holy See's position on reproductive health is unsound. Population management through effective family planning is an essential component of sustainable development.

Family planning is the cheapest avenue to sustainable development with six dollars saved for every one invested. It is also a human right, and one which is too often denied to women, despite the profound influence on women's quality of life. The right to medical care is enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and includes the right to reproductive healthcare.

The Holy See's claim to legitimate statehood - and thus permanent observer status at the UN - is tenuous at best. Unlike the Vatican, the Holy See does not have any permanent citizens or land and their representatives are only allowed in Geneva because other states have permitted it. If the Holy See were to be used as precedent then any religion could claim a seat at the UN, if only they were centralised enough.

The UN Charter expressly ensures "fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to religion." The Vatican's anti-choice, anti-women agenda is clearly a religious one. By blocking UN resolutions on these issues, the Vatican seeks to impose its religious dogma on all people, no matter their beliefs.

Religious dogma has no place at UN negotiations which seeks to improve the lives of many regardless of their faith. The Vatican must not be allowed to continue its anachronistic agenda in such an important international arena.

 

Follow Genevieve Stewart on Twitter: www.twitter.com/gen_stewart

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
The declaration text at the UN Conference on Sustainable Development contains no references to reproductive rights. The weak language pertaining to gender, health and education is largely due to the ...
The declaration text at the UN Conference on Sustainable Development contains no references to reproductive rights. The weak language pertaining to gender, health and education is largely due to the ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:38 PM on 06/26/2012
But who will have the nerve to suggest kicking them out?
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
06:16 AM on 06/27/2012
ME!!! When the secular forces are not allowed to meddle in religious matters the religious forces should not be allowed to meddle in secular matters.

In 1970 East and West Pakistan together had 100 million inhabitants. Last time I looked Pakistan and Bangla Desh together had 390 million inhabitants.
03:49 PM on 06/26/2012
The Holy See's ability to influence a vital aspect of international health and development is completely inappropriate and unacceptable. Allow them to observe, by all means, but do not allow them any say in decision making.
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
06:18 AM on 06/27/2012
I can't find a Holy See on my map, Holy Sea not either. Help.
09:32 AM on 06/27/2012
You could try searching for possible variations: 'Holy See Batman', 'Holly Sea', 'Holey C' or maybe 'Whole EC'. If that fails, we might have to face the fact that international policy is being dictated by an imaginary country...if only it was Erehwon...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
honeynutcornflakes
your micro-bio is empty
03:45 PM on 06/26/2012
"...granted based on recognition of the Holy See's religious, spiritual and moral authority in the world"?

religion, evidently, has absolutely nowt to do with morality, don't pretend it does.
12:20 AM on 07/04/2012
Don't worry, I'm certainly not pretending that. Those were the reasons given by the UN for accepting the HS as a permanent observer.
lastpost
see biography
01:51 PM on 06/26/2012
"The Holy See's influence at the UN, despite not actually being a member state, is granted based on recognition of the Holy See's religious, spiritual and moral authority in the world."
If not already present, shouldn’t paedophilia be appended to the list of crimes against humanity?

"Population management through effective family planning is an essential component of sustainable development."
Unless the practicalities of manna manifestation can be definitively demonstrated. As a realistic method of preternatural sustenance provision.

"The Vatican must not be allowed to continue its anachronistic agenda in such an important international arena."
Science has (allegedly) shown that, by its gift a means to change the climate and thus endanger our species has been presented. Religion may merely be attempting to trump that card, with its own Ace of Spades. This partnered pair of players obviously oblivious to the fact that in this game, if we’re dealt out so are they.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
queenoferne
09:17 AM on 06/26/2012
The Holy See represents nobody - it is a self perpetuating mysogynistic club of meddlesome old men and should not be permitted to have input at the UN. When Catholic laity elect their religious rulers their Pope and cardinals may be allowed some credibility but not now when their political and moral credibility is zero.
09:42 PM on 06/26/2012
Do not underestimate it. It is by no means all old men. They have very sharp, highly educated, corporate-experienced guys, thirty upwards, behind the scenes doing everything from image work, PR, diplomacy, commerce and banking. The business side, the real estate side, tourism, pilgrimages are all immense.
10:03 PM on 06/25/2012
When a country's women are empowered (able to make decisions regarding birth control, involved in the decision-making process, etc) the country benefits. It seems like the so-called Holy See is trying push back the clock on the rights of women, and foster ignorance and intolerance. When all of the world's citizens and countries should be focused on controlling population (for the sake of our species and the planet) there is a religious group trying to work to the opposite. The See's influence should not be condoned or allowed.
06:28 PM on 06/25/2012
At the end of the day, human life is created at the moment of conception. All this talk of 'rights' is just a way of preventing that new life from fully developing. That is wrong. As for contraception, it is taking direct action in preventing conception from taking place. That too is wrong.
Sophisticated language and extensive use of words doesn't change the unalterable fact that life is a gift and is not to be tinkered with.
10:17 PM on 06/25/2012
"As for contraception, it is taking direct action in preventing conception from taking place. That too is wrong"

Who are you or the Vatican to impose this dogma on other people? The Bible makes no reference to contraception whatsoever. Unless we moderate the rising world population we'll run out of food, water and poison the planet. Does God want us to be stupid?
08:50 AM on 06/26/2012
The so-called moral prohibition on contraception proclaimed by so many religions is based on nothing more than the religions' need to to sustain or increase its followers. If this was expressed as a straightforward request for parents to do their bit to populate the world with true believers it would be less hypocritical, although less powerful, than religious moral blackmail.