Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ian Wilson

GET UPDATES FROM Ian Wilson
 

Should Capello Take the Idiot Abroad?

Posted: 13/10/11 01:00 BST

As yet another lacklustre England performance fades quickly away, we're all left wondering how it was possible to snatch a draw from the jaws of victory against a team that's only been in existence for five years.

Clearly, the England team is not as good as it once as. Fans and commentators talk about the lack of passion and commitment, but the significant deficiencies run deeper than that. The rest of the world has caught up. Once where it was the number of hat-tricks Gary Lineker would score in qualifying that was the litmus test of success, now it appears as though qualification is success itself.

The trouble is, England have only one great player, or two when Steven Gerrard is fit. That in itself isn't a problem, it only becomes an issue when the player is bigger than the team he's playing in - or thinks so anyhow.

The enigma that is Wayne Rooney cannot be underrated. He is the 3rd highest paid player in the world, he averages a goal every 2 games for Manchester United. He's won four league titles, a Champions League. In 2004, he was going to be the best player we'd seen in an England shirt since Bobby Charlton; the boy can play. The stats support this undoubted ability. England have played three games without Rooney since the last World Cup and won none of them. In that same period, England have won seven of the nine games they have played with Rooney in the team, with the two draws against Montenegro accounting for the other two matches.

Beneath all of this though is something even more crucial than ability. Beneath the brilliance is a flawed and self-destructive character. His disciplinary record is well-documented, as are his off the field misadventures. All of this however, could be forgivable. England have had players of this ilk before, petulant, flammable characters with ability in droves and built of dubious moral fibre. Rooney is different; he's not able to focus in the face of adversity. He does not deliver when he is expected to and he puts himself ahead of his teammates far too often (rewind twelve months for an example of this).

A sign of things to come was the 2004 friendly in Spain. The team, outplayed, were subject to racial taunts from the home fans and a short-fused and angered Wayne Rooney was substituted before he got himself sent off. Yes, the chants were horrific, but there was simply no need for the outburst. It was unprofessional, foolish and immature. Fast forward seven years and the boy is still not yet a man.

Anyone who has studied team building theory will know that balance and togetherness are the fundamental building blocks of successful teams, not ability.

Take Norwich City as an example. Few would say that the Championship promotion winning side of last year had any 'Rooneys'. Cardiff City had ex-Premier League stars Craig Bellamy, Jay Bothroyd and Michael Chopra. Reading had Shane Long, Jimmy Kebe and Matthew Mills. Leicester City had the talented Yakubu amongst other internationals. Norwich boss Paul Lambert approached things a different way. He proved that selecting from a group of 15 or so hard-working, likeable professionals can achieve more than a team made up of envious 'side-show' players to the one or two gifted, but high maintenance stars. Lambert's team was balanced, focussed and together, a recipe ripe for over-achieving in the Championship.

There are many other examples of the importance of teams over individuals. Few could argue that Manchester City's 'money can't buy' dream team have achieved what they should have given the significant investment of Sheikh Mansour. The jury is out on whether anything is different this season. They certainly don't look a happy camp. International football is full of examples of groups of average players being moulded into great teams. Think Greece in Euro 2004 or even Germany in 2002.

Whether or not you want Rooney to attend the finals in Poland and Ukraine is a personal view. However, on balance, I'm not convinced that England are any better off with a player who is at times quite brilliant and at other times, a liability. Show some strength Fabio and put the best team out at Euro 2012, not the best players. Don't take the idiot abroad.

 

Follow Ian Wilson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Savvy_monkey

As yet another lacklustre England performance fades quickly away, we're all left wondering how it was possible to snatch a draw from the jaws of victory against a team that's only been in existence fo...
As yet another lacklustre England performance fades quickly away, we're all left wondering how it was possible to snatch a draw from the jaws of victory against a team that's only been in existence fo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:15 PM on 10/19/2011
Rooney should still go.

They have nothing to lose by taking him


It's not as if they have a chance of actually winning it.
09:53 PM on 10/13/2011
Thanks for all the comments people. Agree with the view that fans/media make it difficult to play for England, but it still should be the pinnacle of anyone's career for my money. I can't believe that now the 3 game ban has been announced, some are saying Rooney should still go. I just hope Capello does the right thing, a man who I used to have enormous respect for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
06:15 PM on 10/13/2011
Playing for England in general is a poisoned chalice. The fans expect gold out of - for the most part average players - then scream and jeer anytime you don't put on a Barca-like performance. The press are like carrion-eaters, sitting around and waiting to fil their column inches with criticisms as if they were all world cup winning managers or players...despite the fact that you qualified top of the group!!! Even the Rugby gets it in the neck...one loss in a World Cup quarterfinal and the knives were out.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Simon Heseltine
02:28 PM on 10/13/2011
Rooney should be thanked for what he did. This gives Capello the perfect excuse to drop him from the next few friendlies and try to find an alternative, because we don't have a plan B. On his day Rooney is brilliant, but when he's not on the top of his game, or he gets injured England just can't do it.

Of course one other reason that Capello should be thanking Rooney is that this takes any heat away from him for a not so great qualifying campaign.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
06:23 PM on 10/13/2011
If I were English I would not want to play for England...the supporters are brutal...and mostly supporters of lower league sides and have little time for the premiership players they see as "baby bentley's". The media rub their hands together waiting with glee for the next scandal or the next sub-par performance of a lad who plays well for their club - when surrounded by high quality foreign imports, but is exposed when forced to play with sub-par talent like Gareth Barry or Stewart Downing....The England supporters expect Capello to build a manor from a few wooden nails and a rubber mallet.....international football is shiiiite anyway.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Philip J Sparrow
When your work speaks for itself, keep quiet
12:05 PM on 10/13/2011
As a United fan I would have absolutely no problem in Rooney being left out of the England squad, or even in his interntional retirement. Everyone can see that his form at the start of this season is dramatically better than this time last year following the disastrous World Cup, and retirement has already prolonged the club careers of Ryan Giggs and Paul Scholes.
10:00 AM on 10/13/2011
It's a moot point, really; the difficult conversation that Wilson opens up here could never be had in the open. Can you even begin to imagine the media reaction if Capello suggested- even in passing- that Rooney's place on the team was open to question?

Rooney's a git; but he's England's git. It's too late for them to start building a team without him.

Take it from this Irishman who rejoiced when Mick McCarthy sent home Roy Keane- at that time OUR national git- from the World Cup. Does Capello have McCarthy's stomach? Do the England fans and media? I don't think so...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
06:31 PM on 10/13/2011
Name a handfull of footballer­s who are'nt gits...If I were English I would be worried about the current crop of talent for 2 reasons...­one very few of them have any talent when not surrounded by forein imports, secondly very few of them seem to care about playing for their country...­.they like the privilege of being capped by England...­..but once they need to report for duty, they don't seem to be very bothered by the idea of playing. Maybe it's burnout, maybe its playing in half empty staadiums across eastern europe...b­ut I've seen more effort put into a knees up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:25 AM on 10/13/2011
I'm a German National Team fan -

Please England! Please! Take the foul-mannered git along with you! Watching England crash out of tournaments is almost as good as watching it happen to Holland!

On a serious note: England's problem is that they would even consider taking him along. Try that garbage on the German National Team and see what happens to you. Even rumours of drug-use or extra-marital affairs will mean you won't get a call-up.