Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jill Shaw Ruddock

GET UPDATES FROM Jill Shaw Ruddock
 

Is Gluten the Culprit in Our Fight Against Obesity?

Posted: 15/09/2012 13:19

With the summer of 2012 coming to a close, British athletes have put the 'great' back in Great Britain. So, there is no time like the present for the Department of Health and the Royal Medical Colleges to renew their campaign to try and make real progress in addressing the issues to tackle the obesity epidemic. With a quarter of all adults currently classified as obese and a dramatic increase in obesity related diseases from diabetes to hypertension, Professor Stephenson, a spokesman for the Royal Medical Colleges believes, "Obesity is a much bigger problem than HIV was, much bigger than swine flu".

The 'big' question to the solving the obesity epidemic is: Is it diet? Exercise? Taxation? Food labeling? Changing how we market food to children? Changing the way food is advertised? Increased education?

For the past 30 years, the mantra to lose weight has been to cut out all starchy carbohydrates from our diet. However, the latest weight loss craze sweeping America is the great compromise for carb lovers: eat carbohydrates as long as they are gluten free. The premise is you can eat gluten free bread, pancakes, pasta, cereal, cookies, and cakes - and still lose weight, while reversing plaque, high blood pressure, arthritis, diabetes, and many other health problems.

The author of the Wheat Belly Diet, cardiologist Dr William Davis, has based his diet on the belief that "wheat is the single largest contributor to the nationwide obesity epidemic - and its elimination is key to dramatic weight loss and optimal health." Davis maintains that the modern wheat sold today has been genetically modified and has little resemblance to the four foot "amber waves of grain" referred to in the song "America the Beautiful" written in 1910. You don't need to be a sufferer of coeliac disease or IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome) to shop in the gluten free aisles; gluten free has now gone mainstream!

When I think back to when I was growing up in the late 1950s and 60s, there were maybe one or two fat kids out of the hundreds of children in the school playground. If in the 'good old days' we could eat whatever and whenever we wanted and not gain weight, is genetically modified wheat the cause of obesity that has become a generational phenomenon that started around the mid-1970s as Davis maintains? Is wheat the only culprit or could it also be the way that much of our food is produced and reared? Or are we getting fatter because food is too readily available and cheap?

Houses and cars cost 14 times what they did 50 years ago, but the price of chicken hasn't even doubled. Food has become much cheaper in real terms. This means that our weekly food shop today is a smaller percentage of the average family's budget than it was in 1960. Does it make you pause and wonder why you can buy a whole chicken at the supermarket for less than it costs to get a latte at Starbucks?

We will never see an advertisement on television promoting the nutritional wonders of a fresh apple or a bunch of celery. But manufacturers can make sugar-frosted cornflakes, chocolate pops or cereal bars sound like the most nutritious option of the day. In fact, the average 'healthy' cereal bar has more than eight teaspoons of sugar per 100 grams.

Due to the rise of factory farming and the use of additives and chemicals, most of the food we eat has been grown and reared in a different way than it was when we were growing up. This has had an impact on our overall health - and our waistlines. Fifty years ago, food did not have anything like the amount of preservatives it does today. Our mothers shopped daily at their local butcher and greengrocer and kept little food in the house. Children were told they needed to eat more to grow big and strong. Now 'big' is a national epidemic.

What is now considered to be safe farming practices are very different from what they were even 50 years ago. We have genetically modified foods, animals routinely fed antibiotics, and even beef full of growth-enhancers if it's reared in America. A bewildering number of chemicals in the form of colourings, preservatives, appearance enhancers and more are added to our food to keep it looking better for longer.

When it comes to bigger bellies, I think back to the breakfast I had this summer while on vacation in America. The three very overweight people at the next table all ordered corn pancakes because they were gluten free. They also ordered extra butter, bacon on the side and whipped cream on top but were furious when the waitress told them there was no sugar free maple syrup. It is clear as we try to find the answers to the obesity epidemic; gluten is just one of many culprits.

Part of the text for this blog has been excerpted from Jill Shaw Ruddock's book, The Second Half of Your Life

 

Follow Jill Shaw Ruddock on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jillshawruddock

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:42 AM on 09/30/2012
Agree with a poster below in Calories in and out.

yet, due to two out of three family members being Celiacs, I eat GF in the house. Croissants and pasta when I dine out. I feel better now doubt.

http://theceliachusband.blogspot.fr/
08:27 PM on 09/20/2012
I'm starting to smell an orchestrated effort to smear the low carb community here. How is it different pointing out the corn pancake eaters in this article than saying people on food stamps buy lobster and booze with them and drive off in new Cadillacs? Each is an attempt to broad brush and alienate an entire group of people by using straw man comparisons built on institutionalized prejudices. This is the third related article I've seen today trying to discredit the emerging scientific evidence. Shameful if you ask me!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fandabidozi
09:46 AM on 09/16/2012
As someone suffering from ceoliac disease and has been wheat free for many years I have to say that a gluten free diet does nothing to help you lose weight and believe it is all to do with "calories in v. calories out".

I was also told I'd have much more energy once on a gluten free diet.

I don't however this may be to do with having to take a drug [Dapsone] that works by killing red blood cells to control another auto immune disease which is linked to ceoliac's [dermatitis herpetiformis],this leaves me anaemic.

People in Britain with medically diagnosed ceoliacs disease can get bread and pasta on prescription.
10:02 PM on 09/15/2012
Jil, from experience a gluten free diet definately helps you to lose weight. The reason being most things you don`t want more of. Bread for example the taste and texture are nothing like the wheat based item. Whilst before I may have had four slices on an average day now maybe one, if I am really desperate and the price is more than double that of " normal " bread.
On a serious note I do feel I have more energy since I started on a gluten free diet. I went on the diet to support my wife who was recommended to try it by her chiropractor. I was very sceptical when I started and to be honest still wonder if it is all in my head.
By the way I was also sceptical about spending money on the chiropractor and was very wrong about that.
photo
Mneme
The truth shall make ye fret.
01:56 PM on 09/16/2012
Well it sounds like you're losing weight because you're eating less food overall as it's unpalatable, not because you've cut gluten out of your diet. You only lose weight if your calorie consumption is less than your expenditure. It doesn't really matter what you're eating as long as it's less that what your body needs.
06:19 PM on 09/16/2012
You may not have noticed I was making a tongue in cheek remark, but well done on your calculation that less in than out does help to lose weight..