Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joe Ware

GET UPDATES FROM Joe Ware
 

Time for Tax Dodging Multinationals to Learn From Jimmy Carr

Posted: 23/06/2012 00:00

Good for Jimmy Carr. In the face of a national outcry and a Twitterstorm of protest at revelations that he uses tax havens to pay as little as 1% income tax, the acid tongued comedian has seen the error of his ways and apologised.

After being outed in an investigation by The Times newspaper the issue of tax dodging has been lighting up airwaves and twitter feeds all week. Even Prime Minister David Cameron has come out saying that what Carr has done is 'morally wrong' (although he has refused to be drawn on the tax dodging practices of Gary Barlow and others).

It's good to have the PM's condemnation on the record, coming hot on the heels of George Osborne's statement that aggressive tax avoidance was "morally repugnant". The question now is what are they going to do about it?

But back to Jimmy. Now he's come out and admitted his "terrible error of judgement" and pulled out of the K2 scheme which saw his millions stashed in the tax haven of Jersey, a similar act of contrition should be made by multinational corporations.

If it's worth the time and money for moderately successful stand-up comics to employ accountants to squirrel away the odd million quid, just imagine what global companies worth billions of dollars are doing. There have been recent high profile cases of thriving companies dodging their UK tax responsibilities.

But if Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs in the seventh richest country in the world cannot keep on top of tax dodging multinationals, how are the world's poorest countries expected to enforce tax laws for companies operating in their country?

In Britain we can imagine what these lost millions do to the national coffers. How much more so for the world's developing countries which desperately need these tax revenues to build hospitals, schools and infrastructure. The Government of Zambia for example, recently suggested that mining companies might owe the country as much as $1 billion in tax.

Christian Aid campaigns on the issue of global tax dodging and estimates that developing countries lose out on $160 billion a year from the practice. As a report in the New Statesman points out it's hard to imagine the sheer size of these numbers. But to put it in perspective, a million seconds is eleven and a half days, while a billion seconds is almost 32 years.

Unscrupulous multinationals are known to do this by manipulating internal corporate trading in a way that poorer countries have neither the expertise nor resources to counter. Companies using such strategies need to understand that there is a growing recognition that while aggressive tax avoidance schemes may be legal, they are morally reprehensible.

Both Cameron and Osborne have now said the practice is wrong. It's time they act on those words and close the loopholes that lets this kind of activity to go unchecked, particularly when it allows corporations in rich countries to have such a damaging impact on peoples' lives in poorer countries.

And let's hope Jimmy's example can be followed by these multinational corporations. If a public outcry over one man's tax dodging can bring about change, companies which sell stuff to the public should be aware they might be the next target of a justified moral backlash.

 

Follow Joe Ware on Twitter: www.twitter.com/wareisjoe

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Good for Jimmy Carr. In the face of a national outcry and a Twitterstorm of protest at revelations that he uses tax havens to pay as little as 1% income tax, the acid tongued comedian has seen the err...
Good for Jimmy Carr. In the face of a national outcry and a Twitterstorm of protest at revelations that he uses tax havens to pay as little as 1% income tax, the acid tongued comedian has seen the err...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:08 on 24/06/2012
At the end of the day it is for Parliament, who is well aware of such practices, to undertake legislation so that this sort of blatant tax avoidance is curtailed. However turkeys do not vote for Xmas.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
20:26 on 23/06/2012
Such a joke that Cameron takes the moral high ground on the issue of tax evasion here when the millions inherited from his father came from exactly that.
Such hypocrisy!
Such arrogance!
The seeming hallmarks of his tenure of the post of PM.
18:27 on 23/06/2012
So Jimmy`s sorry. Not that he is worried about the effect it may have on his career to make more millions. Of course, since he fears that he has unfairly used questionable tax avoidance schemes, he will probably donate the extra cash made by using them to charity. No I`m not one of Jimmy`s joke writers and I`m not holding my breath either.
15:08 on 23/06/2012
I agree wholeheartedly with Joe Ware's comments! it stands to reason that the "best" lawyers, accountants, tax advisor's, solicitors and barrister's are employed in the private sector, that's where the highest earnings are. The ones that fail to make it big in the private sector enter politics or work for the civil service where they vie to become a big fish in a much smaller pond.

The tax legislators need much better brains if they are to outwit the private sector who will exploit every single loophole they can for their clients. That's what they are paid to do!

The government of the day and it's adviser's need to rapidly close the existing loopholes and be more thorough when formulating new legislation!

Mark my words! Cameron, Clegg and the rest of their lack lustre public schoolboy cronies (from all major political parties) are facing a far bigger backlash from this than the MPs expenses and bankers bonus scandal!

Successive chancellors have always taken the easy option of consistently and persistently raising taxes on income tax, fuel, tobacco, alcohol, VAT and stamp duty, and ignoring the billions stashed away by the multi-nationals and top executives! the lower paid majority are tired of bankrolling the super-rich with their "Sheriff of Nottingham" attitude!
14:53 on 23/06/2012
Leveson type enquiry MK2. ? Don't hold your breathe - too many vested interests for the Tories and potentially vote losing I guess.
photo
FairPlayTony
I'm trying to think, don't confuse me with facts
14:24 on 23/06/2012
Agree 100% with Joe's post. Let's see the actual percentages paid by PLCs. Shouldn't take longer than I week for one HMRC employee. Why aren't we seeing this info already?

On personal taxation Warren Buffett has justified higher rates of tax for the wealthy, on the basis that they couldn't have made their fortunes without the great mass of institutions and markets which they did not create themselves. Good for him eh? I heard he gave $1bn to the Melinda (?) Gates Foundation.
12:29 on 23/06/2012
It will never stop as soon as one scheme is closed another one is found.
These large cmpanies have saved billions in tax and all the hmrc does is do deals with them yet you or i owe a few pounds and there chasing you big style
11:54 on 23/06/2012
Now he's apologised, is he going to pay back the tax he has scammed, or not? Is he going to bring this income in line with most hard working tax paying British people and pay what is due, in full?

No? though not.
11:35 on 23/06/2012
"Time for war mongering, bank knighting, money wasting politicans to Learn to quit wasting our taxes."

Thats better.
01:35 on 23/06/2012
The Guardian newspaper hides £300 million in the Cyaman Islands, we need those fakes to pay up.

As for me, I support paying less tax and governments start all wars and are corrupt to the core. Not paying tax is mor emoral than paying it.

My money is for me, not the state. flat 20% tax is fair, any more is theft.

Now pay up the Guardian.
06:40 on 23/06/2012
And what exactly do you think pays for the countries infrastructure? schools, roads, hospitals, defence, police, .................the toth fairy?
11:30 on 23/06/2012
Switzerland has better " schools, roads, hospitals, defence, police, ", yet they have much lower taxes than the UK and thus more jobs.

Government needs to quit wasting our money giving it to their friends.

£400 laptops bought by the govenrment from their friends for "12000, thats immoral.
photo
mrs w waugh
Hail Caesar We Who Are About To Die Salute You
10:17 on 23/06/2012
You dont want to pay tax,So instead you prefer others too,It doesnt work that way,as everything you buy is taxed........................................
11:22 on 23/06/2012
Exactly I pay VAT on everything I buy. So I pay too much tax already.   Switzerland's government spends less than the UK, yet have better schools, roads and infrastructure.   Government waste is the real problem. The high taxes are causing unemployment.
20:21 on 22/06/2012
What we need is a list of tax avoiding companies so we can avoid giving them our custom!
22:22 on 22/06/2012
Damn right, but we know who the tossers are - they're the cheapest !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
12:21 on 23/06/2012
That's the main point. If anyone is outraged by companies optimizing their tax structure, they should vote with their wallets. Absent that, all the rest is pure BS and fake moralism