Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Louise Kirsh

GET UPDATES FROM Louise Kirsh
 

At Last, Politicians Are Taking Mental Health Seriously

Posted: 29/10/2012 15:19

This morning I went along to the Royal College of Psychiatrists' office to hear Ed Miliband's speech on mental health - and I was rather excited. Partly because I'm a bit of a politics nerd, but more because of what the speech represents.

Ed, the leader of the Labour party, has a million things in his in-tray. A challenging economy, rising energy prices, badgers, you name it. And yet he chose to speak to the national media about mental health. Whether or not you agree with his politics, the very fact that he made this speech is a good thing - it's a sign that the subject we've been campaigning about for so long has moved up the political agenda.

Ed told us mental health was one of the biggest challenges in our country - affecting millions of people, old and young, rich and poor, north and south. He acknowledged the stigma and discrimination that surrounds mental health, preventing people from seeking help, telling their employers, or speaking to family and friends. And he urged us to fight against this last form of intolerance just as we have fought against racism, sexism and homophobia.

The speech also covered the failings of the Work Capability Assessment, the role of employers, and the need for more and better crisis care - all areas people have told Mind are important to them and that we campaign on. He argued that successive governments had prioritised physical health over mental health, and promised that a Labour government would reverse this by rewriting the NHS Constitution to guarantee access to services, integrating physical and mental health services and expanding the use of personal health budgets. And importantly, he emphasised that mental health is not just a challenge the NHS should address, but something for everyone everywhere to take on. At the Labour conference in September, Ed set out his ambitions around creating "one nation" - a nation where everybody prospers and everybody plays their part. It's clear that he's looking at mental health through this prism.

But the language around cuts to mental health services was guarded. When Mind asked our supporters what the most pressing issues were, they told us that it was access to services. And having spoken to many of our local Mind's over the last few weeks, it's clear that service providers are having to do less with more as local authorities and the NHS try to make savings. I'm not sure what the Labour party would do to stop this.

Nonetheless, for me the speech is part of a good year for mental health in Parliament. MPs' understanding of mental health is increasing all the time. The Mental Health Discrimination Bill is making its way through the Commons with support from all sides. Some MPs even feel able to talk about their own mental health problems now. And we've had a number of conversations with politicians about the need for more and better crisis care, and the message has been well understood.

I know that lots of people are cynical about politics, and often with good reason: Parliament still seems to be dominated by able-bodied, privileged white men; the 'Punch and Judy' atmosphere of Prime Minister's Questions makes politics look silly; and the expenses scandal ruined many people's faith in politics. I'm not quite so cynical because the majority of the MPs I meet work hard to make life better for their constituents. They're motivated not by power or greed, but by a desire to bring about change. But whatever your attitude to politics and politicians, the fact remains that the decisions made in Westminster affect all of our lives. That's why it's so important to ensure that politicians are talking about mental health - and if the leader of the party is doing so, you can be sure that others are too.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
This morning I went along to the Royal College of Psychiatrists' office to hear Ed Miliband's speech on mental health - and I was rather excited. Partly because I'm a bit of a politics nerd, but more ...
This morning I went along to the Royal College of Psychiatrists' office to hear Ed Miliband's speech on mental health - and I was rather excited. Partly because I'm a bit of a politics nerd, but more ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:28 PM on 11/03/2012
Continued...

Remember who Carl Jung was?

Here's a quote from him, which hits the nail on the head: "The foundation of all mental illness is the unwillingness to experience legitimate suffering." ~C.G. Jung

Guess why I no longer suffer from clinical depression? It's not because of the meds or because of anything the authorities did. It was because I took a long and hard look at myself and my life and then I decided to stop fighting, and to accept my situation as it was. And then I made changes. That lifted me out of the blackest period of my life, and I haven't looked back since. It's a CHOICE! I suggest if you suffer from depression that you need to make different choices if you truly want to recover and lead a happier life.

The one thing I wish I did differently: I wish I had stuck with education and work through my depression. It's vital to stay busy and to keep things as normal as possible, even with moderate depression.

So absolutely, if you suffer from depression, you should be encouraged to go back to work or education even if it's part time, if possible. Even volunteering would do you the world of good instead of sitting around doing nothing useful. After all, why should the nation support you moping around at home because you are "too depressed"?

Start helping yourselves more! Take more responsibility for your own health.
05:27 PM on 11/03/2012
It's often difficult to treat mental health issues such as depression because many patients don't do enough to help themselves.

I used to suffer severely from depression (which meant I was suicidal on a few occasions, and I went through a very bad breakdown), which also affected several of my relatives. None of us really help(ed) ourselves in terms of recovery. From what I've seen and heard, it's pretty much like that across the board, and it's actively encouraged.

Depression wasn't such a big problem for older generations for a reason. We need to relearn new ways of coping.

We are responsible for our own lives and the sooner we grasp that instead of being so reliant on the government and local authorities, the sooner we'll start to see an improvement in mental health, and in society in general.

The authorities don't help matters either. Why aren't therapies such as hypnotherapy on the menu for treatment, when they have been proven to be helpful in treating depression? At the very least these therapies should be researched a lot more.

Part of the problem is, mental health professionals seem to be too keen to get and keep patients on medication. This is not a good thing as it can be habit forming, psychologically speaking. They need to address the root problem using other therapies, and only use medication as a short term thing when necessary. The treatment needs to be more holistic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
humphry
The Voynich Manuscripts.
10:51 PM on 10/29/2012
I would love to think that Ed is not like the New Labour of old..But the truth is the labour party is still full of Blairites, who all believe privatisation is a good thing..So Milliband would have a fight on his hands getting these proposals passed by the Blairites in his own party..Parts of the NHS were sold under new labour, and will carry on being sold under this one....Alas in the future we are going to have to rely on the voluntary sector and charities more and more, plus private insurance for those who can afford it..........
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:34 PM on 10/29/2012
Ed told us mental health was one of the biggest challenges in our country
-----------------------------------------------
NO. IT IS NOT.

It is mental illness.

If you want to be taken seriously, do not play last centuries' games of political correctness.
08:17 PM on 10/29/2012
`MPs' understanding of mental health is increasing all the time` Except D Cameron and the persecutor of the sick and disabled the disgusting Ian Duncan Smith, maybe these two should listen to some of the people with severe mental health problems who have been through Smiths work assesment test with that foreign French company `ATOS` !!!!!! AND DECLARED FIT TO WORK, A NATIONAL SCANDAL!!!!
07:08 PM on 10/29/2012
The biggest single problem/issue with mental health is that in reality we know so very little about what REALLY goes on in our heads...
This said it makes treatment difficult, expensive and of course no one's sure if they'll get a positive result at the end..
So, it very often gets kicked into the 'long grass' until someone 'loses it' and either seriously injures a few people or someone gets killed..
Given that it's reckoned that 75/80% of us will experience some sort of mental health issue in our lifetime, isn;t about time that the 'politicos' put aside partisanship and worked together to put sufficient resources into this area, so that we might actually see some genuine results??
06:02 PM on 10/29/2012
As someone who has had mental problems i honestly wonder if they are. Yes its good mental health is in the open. Yes those who have been treated know the problems. But what about the solutions? I will agree when there are actually results. I doubt it as they might work together for a bit but as soon as one of the parties lose points they will revert to party politics. Also i can see this as a wasted moment, look at those brave ( I don't think i have ever used that to describe a MP) MP's who openly talked of their problems, and what happened since.
04:56 PM on 10/29/2012
Mental health care has been neglected very badly by successive governments over decades, of that there is no doubt at all. Far too many have virtually little or no support at all in the community!

There is no doubt either, in my mind, that the whole area of mental health issues have been devalued by both mental health professionals and GPs.

Psychiatrists now have a label for just about every minor deviation from what most of society consider to be normal behaviour, be it by badly behaved children to habitual criminals. Often seized upon by canny lawyers out to make a fast buck and get their client off, or a reduced sentence, whilst those with genuine illnesses cannot get the help, support and treatment their condition warrants!
05:13 PM on 10/29/2012
The neglect is possibly because it's expensive to treat with even a hope of success. There's a great deal of stress in the community particularly during these times with job insecurity, repossessions of homes, bills stretched by terrific energy hikes, bullying, the dangers of internet socialising, many things. Some victims will end up needing psychiatric treatment.

The question is how much can be done? Psychiatrists pull the victims out of the system, repair them as best they can, then "rehabilitate" them back into the very system that damaged them. Psychiatric units formed from the old-fashioned ex-workhouse-type hospitals staffed by nurses too overloaded to afford the time to care properly will probably worsen some victims' disposition than "cure" them. In the late 1950s there were pleasant places that could at least afford rest and sanctuary - and put space between the immediate cause and rehabilitation, aside from providing treatment and therapy. I doubt any now remain - places like Bethlem Royal (Bromley) or St Ebba's (Epsom)?