Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Martel Maxwell

GET UPDATES FROM Martel Maxwell
 

Reflections on Burns Night From a Scot Living in London

Posted: 25/01/2012 00:00

There I was passing a shelf of specially-ordered Burns Night haggises at Waitrose in Canary Wharf when I overheard a woman speaking to her friend.

"Any Scottish people I've known have always been really arrogant and loud," she said in an East End London accent.

"Yeah. Big drinkers too," her friend nodded, picking up a haggis and eyeing it suspiciously. I thought about saying hello, exaggerating my normally soft Scottish accent but instead left them to it.

Their conversation had turned to independence and the words "Couldn't survive by themselves," hung in the air.

Them and us; a mentality that has long existed in Scotland but is increasingly prevalent here.
I like to think it stems from hurt - that the English were wounded upon realisation there was growing support for independence and reacted with anger.

Phrases bandied about by commentators - Scotland is subsidised, Scots are ungrateful - fuelled venom. But surely you (if you are English and reading this) are a little bewildered as to the seemingly sudden sentiment of Scots to break our ancient union. Why now? Why at all?

Spending my time between Scotland and London, I have gleaned an invaluable insight into the relationship between the two countries and an understanding as to why we have reached today's tense stalemate.

I am Scottish and intensely proud of being so. I also live in London and value the British identity on my passport.

As a weekly columnist for Scotland's biggest-selling daily newspaper for six years, I replaced opinion writers for the London-based version such as Jeremy Clarkson and Kelvin MacKenzie, not least because they were increasingly prone to anti-Scots comments.

Whenever I made mention of the Auld Enemy on my page, my inbox would strain with readers' expletive rage.

This is in not a political analysis of the situation and what has caused it - there are plenty of experts who do that superbly not least here; it is an attempt to explain the Scottish mindset caused by everyday experience.

The sentiment of being hard-done-by by England is hardly new but for a substantial part of the nation it is current, ingrained and passed down by generation. Exacerbated by the drip-feed of English bias through media, it sticks in the collective throat.

For instance, when Scotland plays an international football game, the England match is often shown instead because TV budgets and decisions are made - though the BBC is attempting to regionalise - in London. Can you imagine turning on the box only to see tartan banners in the crowd when you had expected to see England play?

The views of sports presenters are solipsistic towards England - building their players up as word champions in the early rounds before we all see the ugly truth unfold - the latest disgrace of course, the rugby stars' unsavoury behaviour in Australia. Little mention if any is given to Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland, three nations fed up since 1967 with comparisons to 1966. The adage that if a competitor wins they are British but should they lose Scottish, is exaggerated for laughs but not wholly an untruth.

We hear Her Majesty referred to as the Queen of England by English people answering questions on quiz shows; politicians lamenting that hundreds of English soldiers have died in Afghanistan. I am sure you can understand for a nation whose soldiers' bravery in fighting for Queen and country is legendary - and not least for the families of Scottish soldiers - this is hugely offensive. We hear such English narcissism ad nauseam and each instance parlays into a final moment where we stop and shout "hold on, this isn't fair. What about us?" That moment has come and the real reason it is now? We had no choice but to support Alex Salmond at the last election.

Hatred towards Margaret Thatcher stems from her treatment of Scotland as her own personal political laboratory decades ago and yet still the word 'Tory' is a dirty one, reflected by the fact we have just one Conservative MP.

While presenting a radio talk show in Edinburgh I once said that "Thatcher wasn't so bad and I would have no qualms voting Conservative given the mess Labour was making" only to see the caller phone lines go into a meltdown of wrath and a cab driver swear on air.

Our mentality - and of course I generalise - is of underdog and we sneer constantly at our southern neighbour's arrogance. I rather suspect we sometimes enjoy doing so.

While the brain-drain to London of able, eloquent and ambitious MPs (whatever you say about Gordon Brown, he still got the top job) was left unchecked, Westminster viewed Holyrood in journalistic terms as a quaint local newspaper to their mighty Financial Times. And Scotland suffered.

Salmond was the best of a bad bunch and while Tony Blair, Brown, then Cameron let him get on with it, devolution flourished into a country so restored it now wants independence (though a recent Sun poll showed just 29% of Scots would vote for it compared to a hefty 41% in England and Wales). Could this mean the unthinkable: that we like you more than you like us?
Along with a terrier of a right hand woman in Nicola Sturgeon, Salmond played a waiting game that has paid off.

The Tories were never an option but neither was Labour. For Scots knew a Brown-led government had left Britain on its knees financially, the fatal decisions had been made in London and wanted revenge. England too was angry at the economic hangover and reacted by voting Cameron into No10. We simply chose Salmond instead.

But we are a long way off breaking away.

It seems one hell of a gamble to find out if we would be financially better off as Salmond says as a result of keeping money from North Sea oil, by breaking up the union to find out. And before you go quoting the Barnett formula, which gives the Scottish taxpayer £1,600 more than in England, please remember the figures were not dreamed up by Scots - they were thought up by esteemed Englishman Lord Barnett who thought that, after much consideration, it was fair.

The threat that is more imminently real than independence is a change in attitude to the way the Scots are perceived by the English. Play the surly lodger for too long, blaming Westminster for our woes, and is it not to be expected you will fall out of fondness with your little cousin?

I believe Scotland is the best country in the world and that to be Scottish, the best nationality.
Come on, don't you envy out pride, identity, belonging, personality, ginger genes, freckles, kilts, tartan, whisky, humour, haggis, lochs and beauty? Wha's like us?

But that's the beauty of being British - we get to be proud of being Scottish, English, Irish or Welsh - and British too. To dissolve the ancient union would dilute the power of all of us four.

Go on, celebrate the Bard tonight, 25 January.

Google your local area for restaurants serving haggis, buy one from the supermarket (vegetarian options are normally available if you don't fancy sheep intestine) or simply raise a glass to the Scots. And remember - a good many of us do not want to part with your esteemed company.

Happy Burns Night.

My Burns Night picks in London:

Scottish food specialists Boisdale offers superb fine dining with divine game dishes and one of the world's biggest whisky bars at its Canary Wharf, Belgravia and Bishopsgate restaurant.

Green's on Cornhill, near Bank and bustling with business minds, is serving its Burns menu until Friday - www.greens.org.uk

Martel is the author of showbiz romantic comedy Scandalous, published by Penguin and available here on Kindle.

 

Follow Martel Maxwell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MartelMaxwell

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:04 PM on 03/10/2012
It is wholly wrong to confuse the Words British with English, British refers to the union, not to the English alone, this is what annoys us. We are not annoyed at Scotland leaving the union but hopeful it happens and happens soon. We are anonoyed at not have the same national status, equality and right from devolution that Scots, Welsh and N Irish got. Yet we are having to pay for it in terms of Jobs, money, taxes, democracy and riots. Thanks to devolution and the barnett formula. Devolution ended the union.
04:43 PM on 02/16/2012
Hi Rolf
I am Scottish and live in London. That doesn't make me any less Scottish. I moved for the work opportunities which are limited in media in Scotland. I plan to move back to Scotland soon - or at least try to work out working and living between London and Scotland.
I am proud of being Scottish and British whereas you seem to think that if you consider yourself British you are in fact English. It may come down to opinion, but I wholeheartedly disagree. I can and will be proud of being Scottish and British. Just you watch me!
Thanks for your comment, Martel
01:02 AM on 02/16/2012
The "proud to Scottish and British" bit is a cop out. The English have long since appropriated the "British" label. Travel and live overseas and you quickly find that to the rest of the world the UK is "England" no ifs, buts or maybes.

So "British" is just the local slang for being 'English" as far as the world is concerned.

If people are content to be Scottish provincial second class English "Brits" the fair enough.

Personally, I regard it it a bit a face saver for those lacking the emotional robustness to make a clear cut choice.If you live, work and put down roots in a country, say England, then you are part of that country, ie English.

Poncing around with a bet each way as "I'm Scots living in England but unwilling to own up to being English, so I'll call my self British" is simply sad and pathetic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:55 AM on 02/06/2012
As you are a writer I expect you have a good education - Are you going to be paying back £27,000 as the English do, or getting it Scot free?

£7.40 per prescription - well, only if you are English - everyone else gets 'em free.

Union? Where? disunion more like - let's put an end to it properly - I'm sick of being bled dry. When do I get to vote on getting rid of Socialist Scotland? It's not just about if the Scottish want in or out - we have a say on this so called Union too you know.
04:36 PM on 02/16/2012
x1x I appreciate the frustration of listening to Scotland moan about Westminster rule when it appears we have it rather good - not least in free tuition fees and prescriptions.
What I would, however, say is that the university issue is reciprocal. Scotland changes English students but then Scottish students pay in England. And one could argue that it is within Salmond's power to decide how to spend money best on people in Scotland. That Cameron does not elect to give free university education or prescriptions is his choice too.
Thanks, Martel
08:47 PM on 01/31/2012
I agree wholeheartedly with you, this is an insightful and balanced point of view from a Scotlander living in England .....I lived in London 1970-1979 and the English loved the Scots then, but disliked the Irish primarily because of the bombings and trouble at the time. It makes me wonder if the English actually now prefer the Irish to us Scots. We have the best of it all being part of the UK - free prescriptions, free personal care for the elderly and lots of other anomolies exist between us and our bigger cousin. I think Scotland risk becoming too big for their boots if the nation go down the road of independance Some hae meat wha cannae eat and some ..................food for thought!
10:02 PM on 01/31/2012
Thank you annemax. It's interesting to hear your point of view having lived in London in the Seventies. Even ten years ago when I first moved to London, there was a jokey fondness towards us I just don't see and hear as much now. Food for thought indeed.
09:47 AM on 01/26/2012
I bought my haggis in the Co-Op, Shandwick Place last night. There was a group of Spanish tourists standing next to me at the time saying, "Sheep guts...euuuugh...eeees no possible". Undeterred, they purchased said haggis and off they trotted. I wish them well.
My mother is English, however being born in Scotland I'm intensely proud to be Scottish. I would also class some of my closest friends to be English and the rivalry we enjoy is healthy and light-hearted. A completely independent Scotland though? C'mon, dont be ridiculous... it will all end in tears...
07:10 PM on 01/26/2012
Exactly Thisishowwedoit, exactly. The rivalry should be good-natured and a bit of fun - though sometimes is not with a minority and seems to be turning a bit bitter. It may well end in tears - actually having to be independent to find out if we would be richer or poorer is too far a step to find out. Thanks for posting!
10:08 PM on 01/25/2012
There seems to be a section of people who are hell bent on telling the majority ,how the Scots hate the
English and visa versa. In my experience, when working in London, the imprssion I got was the further out of london you
went , North, the more chance you had of entering a world of ignorant idiots, a simula attitude was
expressed from north to south which shows a minority who hate anybody who has the same amount
of brain cells and whos dna would pssibly match and turn out to be distant relatives.
As I am one of instantkarma war babies I am against the E.U. because I have seen administration and goverments,local and national, grow out of all proportion, Watching the E.U is like watching a elastic band being streched to breaking point,with polititions growing at at an alarming pace on salaries that have come from cloud cookoo land. There is no doupt that the great plan is for a european goverment which will move the people further away from democracy as we know it now
06:09 PM on 01/26/2012
Rod My Prophecy was not built on desire but a sense of inevitabillity.The Grand Design.We are minnions.I see you come to that conclusion.A USSR of our own creation
07:39 PM on 01/26/2012
Sadly yes, ufortunatly the british public have ivolved into sheep like characteristic's plenty of bleating ,but without any strong leadership we just go with the flow. I include my self in this before anyone takes personal offence.
09:56 PM on 01/25/2012
Nicely said.
This comment has been removed.
04:58 PM on 01/25/2012
Martel,I believe that the real issue here is EUROPE.The question of Scottish Independence ,rather like many "New Countries" in the EU is inevitable.Equally,l England Wales and a United Ireland will follow.During this Century, the EU will become a United States of Europe, as we move further away from the Post War 1945 Generation and their children.The dilema is the present recession and Fiscal Union.It will happen it is just a question of when.So God Bless you Scotland! "Yes the Times they are a Changing"
04:48 PM on 01/25/2012
Martel as ever an excellent piece of Journalism.The decision for Scotland to go it alone is, a definitive moment for all of us in Great Britain.Scotland is a Great Country, and those who believe in Great Britain, want it to remain part of a Great Country.My concern is that Scotland will become a small fish in the EU .England and Wales will follow and then it will be completed.The Big Question for me is about EUROPE.Are we moving inexorably to the Country of EUROPE the USE,United States of Europe like America.I believe we are whether the people want it or not.In the end you cannot stand in the way of progress, and that is where the end game will be.
09:26 PM on 01/25/2012
Thank you IKN. Europe is a huge issue. I for one would rather have an identity as a Scot and Brit - and all the history that comes with this union - than be Scottish and European. In geography, of course, but our identity is shared in so many ways - monarchy, culture, language - and I believe more people value this than we give credit. I think that now more than ever though there is less of an appetite to have a stronger 'European' identity..no?
06:22 PM on 01/26/2012
I love being British, I love my Country and all that it has done for me and others in my lifetime.History has a way of unfolding inexorably.Todays News Tomorrows history.You look back at WWII Churchill Hitler Stalin, they were once in the "Present".We will all be encouraged by Big Brother to keep our "quaint rituals" Royalty etc, but the end game is a Big Brother EU State,where everything we do will be monitored recorded evaluated, a Secular EU ,where the young and unborn to come will know no different.Think Orwell 1984.Regrettably that is where we are heading!
thephuqqer
not the chicken plucker.
04:15 PM on 01/25/2012
As the saying goes; "there are only two types of people in the world, Scots, and those who aspire to be Scots."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
03:48 PM on 01/25/2012
Before I incur the wrath of all I am also immensely proud to be British,where the term refers to, proper English,Scots,Welsh and N.Irish
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
03:38 PM on 01/25/2012
To be born English is to win 1st prize in the Lottery of life ( to paraphrase Mr Rhodes) who am I to contradict that?
09:09 PM on 01/26/2012
What a night out one or ------ pints with Daviejohn and thephuqqer interesting
01:49 PM on 01/25/2012
Hello
I'm keen to respond but having a few problems setting up a log-in on a train from London to - you guessed it - Scotland. Hopefully this will work as a temporary post.

From comments, so far I'm alone on the 'you can be proud of both being Scottish and British' front.
I have long sensed the tide turn - when once Scots in London were regarded fondly, as the fun and ambitious little cousin, we are increasingly vilified and mocked. I believe, however, a good many do believe in the union - they are just not being as vocal.

Eric14 my apologies you thought London-based TV coverage in Scotland was a criticism of the English. It was merely factual. My intention was to demonstrate Scots do get frustrated with constant English content with little heed paid to the other nations.

If viewers in England were fed Glasgow-based media with Scottish commentators talking about Scottish issues, we would hear about it. It would affect the psyche of England. Of course showing England games on BBC Scotland is not a serious component in the growing support for independence (or perceived growing support) but it is constant and therefore exacerbating.

When I say 'we' I generalise. My overall sentiment is that - as I say - I hold England in high esteem. Scottish people do sometimes have a chip on their shoulder and I perhaps should have made more of this in the interests of balance.

Thanks and happy Burns Night,
02:36 PM on 01/25/2012
All we get on TV where I live in East of Scotland is Rangers and Celtic and the Edinburgh parliament. Local government is ignored. On English TV there are programs about local government. It is not the task of English regional broadcasters to cater for Scots. The Scots share of national TV, pro rata would be around 2% as time goes to UK and foreign affairs. Your complaint is specious.

Your evidence of anti-Scots feeling is not my experience. However, I have witnessed much anti-English behaviour by Scots, especially West coast, (usually Glasgow) Celtic supporters who seem to think the IRA is an organisation of local heroes.

The Scottish people have a lot of serious issues to address, I would place sectarianism above nationalism. Current approaches to sectarianism are pathetically weak.