Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Reyhana Patel

GET UPDATES FROM Reyhana Patel
 

Killing Without Consequence: Why Are Palestinians Not Allowed the Right to Justice?

Posted: 04/06/2012 00:00

Meet Moira Jilani. She is the wife of Ziad Jilani who was shot and killed by Israeli border police in East Jerusalem on 11 June 2010.

Almost two years later and Moira Jilani and her three daughters, Hannah, 19, Mirage, 17, and Yasmin 10, are still awaiting answers from Israeli police as to why their beloved father and husband was killed.

Ziad's Tragic Story

Ziad was only 41 when he was shot. On 11 June 2010, the Jilani family was preparing for a day out to the beach as a treat for their daughters on completing their exams.

Ziad set out for Friday prayers but on his return to pick up his family for their day outing, he was involved in a routine traffic accident. According to a report by The Electronic Intifada, Ziad was trying to get out his truck to seek refuge in a safe place when Israeli border police officer, Maxim Vinogradov, walked towards Ziad, kicked him in the head put his foot on top of his neck, and with his M-16, let off three shots.

A number of Palestinian passerbys were also injured in the shooting and witnesses who were present at that time, described the shooting as 'crazy.'

Israeli police claim that Ziad had attempted to run them over with his car in what they called a "terrorist attack." However, Residents of Wadi al-Joz - the East Jerusalem neighborhood where Jilani was killed - said, that Jilani's car swerved towards the police only after a rock hit his windshield.

Ziad's family insists that he was never involved in such activity and is calling for the Israeli high court to take action against the police officers who were involved in the shooting.

It has been almost two years and the Israeli police have failed to investigate the events of that tragic day.

Ziad's family wants answers and those responsible to be held accountable for their actions. They have taken their campaign online with a petition entitled Killing without consequence to challenge Israeli impunity and demand justice for Ziad.

Already gaining more than 2000 signatures, petitions and media awareness seem to be the only way to put pressure on the Israeli courts to consider the Jilani's case and hear the evidence.

When it comes to justice, why is it different for Palestinians?

When I signed the petition, I was explaining to a colleague of mine who knew nothing about Israel and Palestine, the story of Ziad. The response I received was "Why are they allowed to get away with it?" I was at a loss of words because I really couldn't provide an intelligent answer.

Ziad isn't the first and will not be the last Palestinian to be killed as part of the Israeli government's discrimination against Palestinians. It is estimated that Israeli security forces have killed more than 6,450 Palestinians since the beginning of the second intifada, and that in this time, no Israeli soldier has been charged with murder of a Palestinian.

What is even more disturbing is that Israeli police officers are allowed to do this without consequence. A video report by Mondoweiss reveals the extent of the Israeli police's detestation against Palestinians.

Israel is supposedly a democratic country with strong support by western superpowers. But why are those that represent them allowed to kill without consequences? Why does it take an online petition and mainstream media reporting for Ziad's family or any other Palestinian to receive answers to the deaths of their loved ones?

It led me to think if a similar situation was to occur in Britain or any other western country. If a British police officer was to shoot at an individual for no reason, there would be condemnation, an enquiry and criminal proceedings. Why is it different for Palestinians? Do they not also deserve humanity? Isn't that what western governments are promoting; democracy, accountability and peace for both Israel and Palestine?

As Moira Jilani rightfully puts it, 'there is no justice when it comes to Palestinians. Our blood is cheap, whether Christian or Muslim, Palestinian blood is cheap.'

Even though Moira Jilani holds American citizenship, the Jilani family refuses to leave their homeland until those that are responsible for Ziad's death face the consequences of their actions.

 

Follow Reyhana Patel on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ReyhanaPatel

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Meet Moira Jilani. She is the wife of Ziad Jilani who was shot and killed by Israeli border police in East Jerusalem on 11 June 2010. Almost two years later and Moira Jilani and her three daughter...
Meet Moira Jilani. She is the wife of Ziad Jilani who was shot and killed by Israeli border police in East Jerusalem on 11 June 2010. Almost two years later and Moira Jilani and her three daughter...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:01 AM on 06/07/2012
Huff, why do you persist in shutting me down?? Some has to counter these anti jews.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
George McAulay
Delighted to meet you
08:26 AM on 07/14/2012
Probably your attitude and hate filled words I'm guessing that contribute nothing
12:15 PM on 07/14/2012
My comments are not hate filled, just frustration that you pro arab types refuse to see the truth. Look to history, you will not find a palestine pre roman occupation of Israel. Palestine did not exist at all before the romans came to Israel.Israel was renamed palestine by the romans in 135 A.D. The jews are the original palestinians, they called themselves palestinians and had a regiment in their army that was called the palestine regiment. Because the jews were forced out of Israel, the land became commonly
called palestine, or the Holy land. So the only people who have a right to the land called palestine, are the jews. The original Israel went from the euphrates to the Med and from Lebanon to the negev and this was the area known as palestine. Try using a bit of grey matter instead of following the media like a sheep.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
04:25 AM on 06/07/2012
Does anyone expect the Jewish to function like "true" Christians? How often do you hear of the Jewish being overly honest and overly fair? If their attitude and conduct today was their attitude and conduct in Germany would that explain anything? I don't know, all I know is what I observe, very seldom do I like what I see. Should I just look the other way? Right is right and wrong is wrong, when you claim to be "One of God's People" you should not function in a way that brings reproach on the God.
07:02 AM on 06/07/2012
What do you mean,?true christians. THEY ARE JEWS, not christians.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
03:29 AM on 06/08/2012
Exactly, and some of the Jewish have commented about how the conduct of some Jewish have made the term Jew sound like a bad word and sometime back there was a move to change the emphasis on the term Hebrew instead and they found there was a lowering of that term.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
courtb
04:05 PM on 06/06/2012
While I agree with your main point that there needs to be proper inquiries and consequences to police brutality in Israel, I'd like to focus on your question "What if this happened in Britain?"

I'd like to answer your question with another question. What if Britain had a similar situation to Israel? Take the IRA terrorism and multiply it tenfold, with their aims changing from a unified Ireland to the destruction of England. What if the IRA lobbed thousands of rockets into England a year? Etc.

These questions go both ways.
12:47 AM on 06/07/2012
The Palestinian people simply want their freedom, equal rights and justice under international law, as stated in their call for a boycott against Israel until Israel meets these reasonable demands.
07:06 AM on 06/07/2012
The arab palestinians have no right to any of the land of palestine, which before the roman occupation and their renaming of Israel, was Israel. Isreal originally stretched from the euphrates to the med. and from lebanon to the negev, so all this area was named palestine. Up until 1948, jews called themselves palestinians and had a palestinian regiment in their army, so who are the true palestinians???Stop being brainwashed by the wimpy news media, who dislike Israel.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
courtb
03:24 PM on 06/07/2012
Your post has absolutely nothing to do with my own, but alright - I'll bite.

How much do you genuinely know about the conflict?

I ask because you are grossly simplifying it. What does all that mean? What freedom? What justice, specifically? The justice of those who support a two-state solution? Or the justice of those who want to see the complete destruction of Israel (which includes a large segment of the BDS movement, which even Finklestein admits).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oferdesade
10:05 PM on 06/05/2012
its a shame that the talkbacks here are all so hateful. i read the article and was truly ashamed, because i know that it represents an ugly aspect of my country - one ugly aspect amidst many admirable ones. but then i started reading the talkbacks and all i see is pure unadulterated hate. not antisemitism (no, i wouldnt honor the sentiments below with even THAT), but simple, uneducated hate. חבל... not exactly a constructive basis for dialogue.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
04:07 AM on 06/06/2012
Very well stated Haver!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
George McAulay
Delighted to meet you
08:30 AM on 07/14/2012
Fanned mate, from Australia

You said it well.

Basically the extremists on both sides will always hold sway over the majority who just want peace and to be able to get on with their lives without animus.
This comment has been removed.
03:34 PM on 06/05/2012
Moira's husband was killed, as in any country in the world those who did it should stand trial, in all fairness. That is what one would consider a justice system. While there are hundreds of Palestinians in Israeli jails in administrative detention without charge, every soldier who ever murdered an innocent Palestinian walks around freely. Killing is killing, whether in uniform or without, killing of innocents cannot be justified. I visited Israel in this year & was treated badly by border police. Theirs seems to be a case of guilty until proven innocent, instead of the other way around. Had this been done for security purposes okay, but security is no excuse to treat people inhumanely. That is how they treated me, inhumanely. All human beings have the right to be treated with dignity. Moira's husband was killed & all she is asking for is a fair trial. In any other country this would be acceptable. No matter ur race or religion, had one of ur family members been killed, u'd want the perpetrator to stand fair trial. Why are the same principles not applied when it comes to Israel? When an Israeli kills he gets let off the hook, had it been a Palestinian they'd be imprisoned I assure u. All we ask is to be treated with dignity. Every human being deserves that. This is about simple human principles, no matter ur nationality. Three kids are now without a dad. I greet u in the name of peace.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
04:10 AM on 06/06/2012
Funny, I got every year, I've yet to be treated badly. When was the last time that Fatah or Hamas imprisoned or even investigated the murder of innocent Israelis in the hands of palestinians?
01:08 AM on 06/07/2012
Jewish travellers to Israel are not subjected to humiliation at the airport because Israel is a 'Jewish' state and not a democracy for all, but an Arab or Palestinian traveller is treated the worst of all. There are many documented cases of this. The worst story I have read is of a disabled Palestiian woman who had her sanitary protection removed by a female airport interrogator. After that, the woman was refused replacement sanitary protection and was forced to bleed all over herself until she boarded her plane. The airline staff were horrified at the state of her, but even more disgusted by what was done to her. As for the question about Fatah or Hamas investigations- Israel takes over these investigations from the Palestinian authorities concerned when it involves the murder or injury of an Israeli. During the course of this investigation, reprisals by the Israeli army against entire villages, or regions such as Gaza, otherwise known as collective punishment, which is illegal, occurs.
10:36 AM on 06/05/2012
Unfortunately, this is the the first case, and am afraid won't be the last, being born and raised in Palestine, under illegal Israeli occupation, I realized what kind of regime were are facing, a regime that is based on apartheid, on treating the indigenous Arab and Palestinian population as a threat, disregarding their legitimate right in the land, there have been so many cases where Israeli courts acquitted Israeli soldiers and policemen despite their crimes and their atrocities, crimes by settlers are also being committed with the state shedding a blind eye, all those criminals need to be sent to the International Criminal Court, starting with Israel's leaders, Israel's occupation is a crime, its colonies in occupied Palestine are crimes against humanity in addition to violating International Law, if peace is to come, the occupation must end, apartheid must be uprooted
This comment has been removed.
09:53 AM on 06/05/2012
Israel's disgraceful impunity for its crimes against Palestinian people must end. Boycott Israel until Palestinians have equal rights, the criminal, brutal military Occupation of Palestinian land ends, Israel's apartheid is dismantled and the right guaranteed by international law to Palestinian refugees to return to their lands is recognised by Israel. BDS apartheid Israel NOW!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
04:11 AM on 06/06/2012
No!
09:30 AM on 06/05/2012
It amazes me that all the people commenting begin arguing over this and that and who is right about Israel or Palestine etc... All in an attempt to take the attention away from the case of Vinogradov executing Ziad and making him accountable for his crime. Sure we have a few problems in America and some of our police are bad apples but we hold them accountable. What is so different in Israel? The executioner was just a police officer. Is there no forgiveness nor mercy to be found in all of Israel? I am beginning to think not. I think I understand why it is written that 'there shall not be left one stone upon another, that shall not be thrown down.' There is no love for a human life there only the love of money.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oferdesade
08:04 AM on 06/05/2012
for the life of me i cant understand why this is subbed under "UK politics".
This comment has been removed.
12:08 PM on 06/04/2012
Israel has a permanent "get out of jail free card" in the UN, due to support from the USA and others. Any other nation that behaved thus would be ostracized by most democratic nations. Their legal framework and central national policy are racist and repressive. We openly condemn the Syrian state, why not Israel?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlietuna11
12:44 PM on 06/04/2012
a free get out of jail card from the usa and others, who are the others?
03:03 PM on 06/04/2012
Unfortunately most of Western Europe including the UK. The USA effectively blocks any censure from the UN rendering it useless as a forum in this matter. The assumption has always been that Israel would ignore it anyway, leading to sanctions, a break down in communication and finally external intervention - so America kills any UN censure at birth.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlietuna11
12:00 PM on 06/04/2012
an equal injustice is the white house and congress continually giving israel deep cover for their crimes against the palestinians. time after time our nation uses their veto to protect israel from being censured for their human rights violations. this creates a hostility not only among arab/muslim nations but also other countries that were once neutral.nothing in life goes unrecorded, many will answer to a higher life form for looking the other way when they could of spoken up and made a differance. americas complicity in the cruel treatment inflicted on the indigenous palestinins will one day suffer from what the cia calls BLOWBACK.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
10:59 AM on 06/04/2012
To answer your question Reyhana, they aren't allowed rights to justice because in the eyes of the IDF, they're seen as mere 'collateral'. How can they expect justice when they're not getting full human rights?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
אני כלום בלעדיהם
04:14 AM on 06/06/2012
You need to replace IDF with Hamas then I'll agree with you.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
03:43 PM on 06/06/2012
I won't replace it, but that doesn't mean I'm a supporter of Hamas.