Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Right To Know Campaign

Abortion: The Case for Independent Counselling

Posted: 29/08/11 20:33 BST

Next week the House of Commons will debate new proposals that mean that every woman considering a termination should receive an offer of independent counselling provided by someone with no vested financial interest in the outcome of her decision. Under these moves counselling will be non-compulsory and will not be an obstacle to women who have already made up their mind.

For those women who have made up their mind and who don't want to take up the offer of counselling, they will be able to proceed in exactly the same way that they are today.

But for the first time ever, an offer of independent counselling will be made to all women requesting a termination. After these proposals are adopted, no woman will ever say again, that she felt rail-roaded through the process, or that she was on a conveyor belt and that no-one ever stopped to ask me what I want, because every woman will be offered access to this very basic level of independent support.

So why are these measures needed?

Every year thousands of UK women will have an abortion, for some that experience makes no major impact and life carries on as normal. For others, it can have a significant and lasting effect that requires follow-up post abortion counselling, treatment and in some cases therapy.

Organisations like the British Association of Counselling and Psychotherapy have been working in this space for years. As it is their Counsellors who are most likely to see women after an abortion, it is little surprise that they too have recognised that there are big deficiencies in the availability of pre-abortion counselling. The article, a Woman's Right to Choose Counselling, published on BACP's site makes many important points, two are extracted below:

'Few patients 'mourn' their appendix when it is removed. Many women who choose abortion still 'mourn' the lost possibilities of the life that will not be. Several years ago the privately funded Post Abortion Counselling Service was established in London to cope with these very problems. However, that leaves the rest of the nation and those who cannot pay.'

For these women independent counselling will offer a space in which they have the option of fully thinking through their situation.

At the most basic level our abortion system should contain checks and balances to enable women to fully explore their situation in a space that is designated solely for them. Experience tells us that this space doesn't exist and the system as it has evolved over the years doesn't stand up to scrutiny.

The amendments will introduce equity into the system. Women who pay for abortions privately, can afford to pay for independent counselling wherever they choose, but a woman who is referred to an NHS outsourced organisation for an abortion, is restricted to accessing counselling through that organisation alone. A captured market for the abortion provider.

Abortion providers are conflicted

The experience of women who suffer trauma after an abortion is one example of evidence that demonstrates problems with the current system. The other type of evidence can be found from scrutinising how private providers operate and where their emphasis lies.

Abortion providers such as bpas and Marie Stopes operate in a very business like way. I'm sure they feel like they do a good job, but when you examine their operating ethos, their obsession like emphasis on promoting the abortion choice, it's very easy to see that they are in a very conflicted position. This doesn't do anyone any good, least of all women who are forced to access their services.

In our report The Case for Independent Counselling we explore these conflicts further.

The report demonstrates that abortion providers are motivated to increase their revenues and grow their market share. Like any business, they employ business development managers; bpas state that they see a 13% growth in the number of abortions that they preform as a 'significant achievement'. If it's a success to increase abortions, the converse is equally true; it cannot under any circumstances be a success if the abortion numbers go down. Is an organisation with this clear level of motivation the right body to be providing counselling? Not only this, but women who are referred to bpas or MSI are prevented from accessing any other form of NHS funding counselling.

Counselling, information and advice should be delivered in a completely neutral environment. A kind of woman centred bubble, that allows the woman facing the situation to explore fully her own feelings and emotions. That is what the amendments to the Health and Social Care Bill will deliver.

It's purely an optional facility, but it is one that is very much needed and which will deliver a better outcome for women. Some commentators have said that the provision of independent counselling actually bolsters choice for women as it's about ensuring that every woman who undergoes an abortion, has the right to fully explore whether that choice is right for her, without being influenced by those with a financial vested interest in the outcome of her decision. These very basic changes are long overdue.

 

Follow Right To Know Campaign on Twitter: www.twitter.com/right_to_know

 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
been2there
Facts have a liberal bias.
08:40 AM on 09/14/2011
No, there isn't a case. Abortion providers are not out trying to persuade women to give up on pregnancy. If you want to reduce the number of abortions, encourage both chastity and contraception.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freddie27
Liberal Gay Jewish Atheist
02:41 AM on 09/01/2011
To anyone who believes these "counsellors" will be something other than Christian pro-life social conservatives: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/newsnight/9577247.stm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freddie27
Liberal Gay Jewish Atheist
01:33 AM on 09/01/2011
I'm pretty sure that those who work for BPAS and Marie Stopes didn't go into what they do to make a profit. They went into it to help women make one of the most difficult decisions of their lives. You, I have little confidence in.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
10:25 PM on 08/30/2011
I'd like to exercise my right to know who's funding your campaign?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miserable Swine
09:53 PM on 08/30/2011
As has been pointed out, given the cuts, just how is the counselling to be provided?
07:40 PM on 08/30/2011
Because these people hold opinions on the basis of emotive stories rather than reason it's very easy to phrase questions to them to get contradictory answers to essentially the same question.

e.g suppose your daughter had got a place at Oxford and during her gap year had got pregnant with someone she met in Bolivia, she's not seen the guy since and if she has the baby she won't be able to go to Oxford. What do you advise?

A question like that will certainly elicit a contradictory response from a Tory MP who says they support this move. And how many of these Tory backbenchers also believe that the lower classes are breeding too much and are against single mothers who live off of the state? They can't keep straight thought in their heads.
This comment has been removed.
02:21 PM on 08/30/2011
Interesting article, and interesting comments especially as majority of the comments seem to be from men, which is great. Surely, offering counselling in a situation like this can only be viewed as a positive step?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
saileyboy
living on land sucks
02:02 PM on 08/30/2011
Rightwing heads would explode over here in the states if they read this article. And those left unexploded can read Cheney's new book, where heads are promised to explode by the author.

This is a woman's issue and I would no more want women making decisions about my body anymore than I would theirs.
01:14 PM on 08/30/2011
"Every year thousands of UK women will have an abortion, for some that experience makes no major impact and life carries on as normal. For others, it can have a significant and lasting effect that requires follow-up post abortion counselling, treatment and in some cases therapy."

Independent Counselling is a neccessary step for these people. Those who are going to have mental health issues for the rest of their life because of abortion. And some people are being bullied in to having an abortion by other people - family, friends, or even their boyfriends and husbands. So before anyone tries to shoot my explanation down, try thinking about those women who will regret having an abortion for the rest of their lives. Try, for once, to think about them, before you start waving the finger at IC. Independent Counselling (IC) can step in to prevent women and teenagers from being forced to do something they don't actually want to do, and give them some time to actually listen to both sides of the argument, to make a healthy concious decision that will, eitherway, affect them for the rest of their lives.

In the modern world, people are out-of-touch with their conciences , perhaps because we live such busy lives, and counselling just gives women a chance away from all that, to really think, question and decide if abortion is really the best option.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freddie27
Liberal Gay Jewish Atheist
02:39 AM on 09/01/2011
Except, they're not exactly impartial, are they?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/newsnight/9577247.stm
12:12 PM on 08/30/2011
What actual evidence is there that the advice they receive is biased. Has an impartial actual study been made? Have the women who've gone through the process been asked? Not all companies are only out for profits. What is your evidence?
If these women cannot afford counseling, and the NHS cannot afford to pay then the only alternative is christian charities. Since this alternative isn't precluded, this must be the true reason for the bill. Can you imagine the trauma of being counseled by someone who believes that your actions means that you are about to murder your own child? And then actually going through with the procedure? This is horrendous!
01:59 PM on 08/30/2011
Why do you presume the NHS cant afford to pay for counselling? As far as I understand the amendment makes it compulsory that a GP has counselling available to a woman who wants it. A GP will decide the counselling orginisation and I am sure they will try their best to offer ones which are not biased. Your obsession with Christian groups seems (in this case) to be unfounded.
03:27 PM on 08/30/2011
Have you seen the waiting list for patients with mental health problems? Even patients with schizoprenia, paranoia, suicidal tendencies etc are not guaranteed immediate help. Most patients with depression are not even considered for help. As I understand it, under the NHS reforms many of the services are likely to be given to private companies/charities etc. If the NHS doesn't have the capacity to offer 'independent counseling', much of it is likely to go to counsellers funded by various charities. Many of which are anti-abortion.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
10:48 PM on 08/30/2011
Rightygodbotherer, you deserve fewer fans.
10:58 AM on 08/30/2011
This article from the New Statesman covers the reasons that people are opposing these measures. http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/laurie-penny/2011/08/anti-choice-abortion-women
Next time, writer, do some research!
01:35 PM on 08/30/2011
notm - not sure what you mean by do some more research, you seem to get all your arguments from a clearly bias magazine.

At first I have to say I was slightly sceptical with this amendment, but after doing some RESEARCH it seems clear to me that it can only benefit women. The decision to have an abortion can leave long lasting psychological scars, it can only be a good thing that a woman gets as much support as possible to help make what may be a life changing decision.

I have worked in an abortion clinic and the author is right, it is like a conveyer belt, patients sometimes giving consent for the abortion on the trolly on the way down to the operating theatre. Many of these woman are young and vulnerable. I have also been very concerned about the pressure on woman from men to have an abortion, especially when the woman is young and not in a stable relationship.

I can only see this as a positive thing. As the author says, a rich person can afford counselling but a poor person is often left on thier own with little support and in particular no independent counselling.
03:32 AM on 09/02/2011
The problem isn't that the women will have access to counselling, which I am very much in favour of. The problem is that the counselling will be provided by religious organisations with a 'pro-life' prerogative which will coerce women into having children they cannot afford financially and might be unwilling to sustain emotionally. That's far more damaging.