Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rupert Wolfe-Murray

GET UPDATES FROM Rupert Wolfe-Murray
 

Romanian Village Blocks Canadian Cyanide Mine

Posted: 16/07/2012 00:00

Corruption, poverty, stray dogs, orphanages - these are the impressions most people have about Romania, an East European country of 19 million souls that has been an EU member state since 2007. Those who know the country better appreciate its friendly people but despair at the corruption in their vast public sector. Even Romania's small charitable sector has been corrupted by a people who have learned that the quickest way to get things done is to bribe the underpaid officials. Unscrupulous investors have a field day in Romania.

With such an unpromising background it is boggling to see that a residents association in the Transylvanian village of Rosia Montana have managed to block a multi-billion dollar open cast gold mine, a project that would destroy three villages and create the biggest cyanide lake in Europe. The protestors say that groundwater in the whole region would be contaminated and if the cyanide dam bursts it will poison the Danube River and the Black Sea.

What's remarkable about the victory of the local charity is the fact that the Canadian mining company, Gabriel Resources, have invested hundreds of millions of Euro in a national marketing campaign that promises thousands of jobs and billions of Euro in taxes (a promise that is disputed by opponents). The Canadian miners have the uncritical support of the local and county council, the president of the country (Traian Basescu) and most of the national media. But they didn't manage to buy the legal system, which has blocked them by refusing planning permission. This is the most encouraging news about Romania's legal system in the last 20 years.

How did it happen? How did a bunch of peasant farmers and volunteers, operating on a shoestring budget with no access to the national media, manage to block one of the biggest investments in Romania? I went to the remote mountain village of Rosia Montana, located in the Apuseni mountains in western Romania, to find out.

The Residents Association that has caused such a headache for the Canadian miners is called Alburnus Maior. It was set up by Eugen David, a local farmer in Rosia Montana. We went to his house, admired the stunning views of woods, hedgerows and mountains, sat in his kitchen and drank unpasteurised milk. He told us how he got together with about 50 other villagers who all refuse to sell their properties to a mining company that would demolish three villages and four mountains (one of which contains several kilometres of ancient Roman mining galleries). This refusal to sell-up has been a thorn in the side of the mining company since it started buying up local properties over 10 years ago.

Mr David said "our best weapon is to challenge the gold mining project in court" - an approach which is far more effective than the usual noisy street (or online) protests. In April this year they won a landmark case in the Alba County Court that declared the company's "urbanism" plan (the basis for all subsequent permits) null and void. This decision has been upheld by Romania's Minister of the Environment, Rovina Plumb, a former MEP who signed the anti-cyanide mining petition in the European Parliament.

But the mining company refuse to admit defeat. They are like supermarkets in Britain who stake out local councils until more compliant councillors are elected. Having been defeated in court earlier this year the mining company tell their investors back home that all is well, that this devastating court judgement is in fact irrelevant and they are on the verge of getting all the permits they need. Because the story is complex (much of the original contract is classified as a state secret) and it has been going on since 1995, the media aren't interested in investigating properly. As a result the mining company can monopolise the media with its version of the truth.

Romania's voluntary sector is starting to find its voice. The "Save Rosia Montana" village charity only has 60 members, all residents in the threatened village, but they have over 50,000 fans on Facebook and claim that a majority of Romanians support them. Like most Romanian charities, they lack access to professional design, PR and communication services - until this year when a Bucharest-based ad agency produced a brilliant pro-bono TV ad which uses a Holocaust inspired concept (and a Jewish actress who played Mary in Mel Gibson's Passion of the Christ) to oppose the mining project. You can see it here.

To see a more detailed article on this subject click here

N.B. The opinions in this article are entirely my own and have nothing to do with my job at Castle Craig Hospital.

 

Follow Rupert Wolfe-Murray on Twitter: www.twitter.com/wolfemurray

FOLLOW UK
Corruption, poverty, stray dogs, orphanages - these are the impressions most people have about Romania, an East European country of 19 million souls that has been an EU member state since 2007. Those ...
Corruption, poverty, stray dogs, orphanages - these are the impressions most people have about Romania, an East European country of 19 million souls that has been an EU member state since 2007. Those ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
14:37 on 17/07/2012
What about the thousands of residents of Alba County who are being kept from working because of the fifty you mention? It is a mining community that is not being allowed to mine. What is unemployment in the region? Incredibly high. And to say that it is blocked by fifty people is bad reporting. It is well documented online that the opposition to the mine is being funded from outside Romania. We need jobs.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rupert Wolfe-Murray
19:37 on 17/07/2012
I appreciate this comment as it gives me a chance to correct some misinformation put out by the mining company -- namely that they will create thousands of local jobs. Indeed, a few thousand jobs will be created in the first few years as they build the cyanide processing plant, 185 high mine for the cyanide lake etc, and there will be jobs for lots of drivers to carry the rubble of the 4 demolished mountains. But most of these jobs will be for highly skilled outsiders, trained in the handling of toxic chemicals and complex machines (and trusted not to speak to the media) not for locals who may object to their region being poisoned and almost certainly lack the skills needed. Even the mining company don't claim they will create more than 200 long term jobs. But who cares if they are lying as they will simply sell the whole project to the highest bidder if they ever get approval.

It's interesting that you say that Rosia Montana "is a mining community that is not allowed to mine". This is very true. But it was Gabriel Resources that closed the functioning gold mine at Rosia Montana so that they could create a much bigger open cast mine.

I know you need jobs but this is not the way to create them. Think of the damage that will be done to the roads and bridges by trucks running on them 24/7 for 20 years.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rupert Wolfe-Murray
19:42 on 17/07/2012
I would be interested to see some of these documents you mention to show that "the opposition to the mine is being funded from outside Romania". I had heard this rumour, which I suspect has been put about by the vast PR machine of the mining company, but I could find no evidence of anything more than a few small grants, And the opposition NGOs show no sign of having any extra cash; they go around in old cars unlike the Gabriel Resources employees who all have new Japanese 4x4s. And what about the local people who are paid to appear in press ads saying they want the mine to go ahead? Aren't they being paid from outside Romania? In fact, isn't this whole scame being funded from outside Romania?

I suppose you think I am being funded "from outside Romania" for writing this article? You can check with Huffington Post if they plan to pay me for this article but so far they haven't paid me for any of the previous articles I've written for them. They don't pay. Like everyone I've met in this campaign to save Rosia Montana, I am doing this work pro bono.
00:03 on 23/07/2012
Hello Rupert,
you can simply ignore this guy and many others like him. The reason is simple: they are getting paid by RMGC to make positive comments on all articles on the web about their activity: extraction of gold from Rosia Montana.
All these guys (the commentors) are so smart and well-informed, they have numbers (they know what concentration of cyanide it will be used), they know the laws (what's the maximum limit admitted by the EU legislation). They go forward by saying the project will create many many work places and the poverty will disappear like a nightmare in the morning.

If people from that area want to work, I am not against them. I am not one who supports the company RMGC and I am neither against them. I am simply against cyanide, pollution, lies, corruptions, bribe, thiefs, and I hope that the unemployment rate will get lower by diversifying the economy of that area. From tourism to agriculture, craftsmanship and mining.
06:50 on 17/07/2012
I believe in the Romanian village. This is the most valuable treasure of the country, not the gold underneath it. An intelligent and well written article. Congratulations to the author!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rupert Wolfe-Murray
12:09 on 17/07/2012
Thanks. I totally agree that the Romanian village is one of the most incredible things in Europe. Imagine if small scale agricultural production (and small renewable energy systems) could be delivered at this level -- rather than in the interest of the corporations. I wonder what will collapse first: the Romanian village or the global economic system?
10:42 on 16/07/2012
i think it's only a matter of time until the deeply corrupted political class will approve the beginning of the mining operations and the canadians know it, that's why they wait...
i'm from romania btw...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rupert Wolfe-Murray
14:32 on 16/07/2012
This is how I thought for many years and this is how many people (including the mining company) think. But the amazing thing about this story is that the local courts really have stopped it and despite what the President of the Romania, the county council and the national govt say they can't just bypass all those planning regulations. This is the most exciting thing about all this: that a local protest and a local court can block an investment project worth tens of billions. It's actually very encouraging about the future of Romania as it shows that the non corrupt elements of society (small but significant) can actually have an impact. The evil corporations can't have it ALL their way.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rupert Wolfe-Murray
15:39 on 16/07/2012
The other factor that hasn't been reported is that Gabriel Resources, the mining company, are on the verge of going bust. They have been telling investors for over 10 years that approvals are just round the corner and that they are on top of things in Romania, and they can do this by having the biggest and best PR operation in the country (they also have a very impressive PR operation in London). But the fact is they can't keep spending tens of millions of Euro every year on PR, not to mention the 450,000 Euro fee of the Irish CEO and they are under various legal and financial obligations that will come to a head by the end of this year. Don't be surprised if they pull out within a year.

The other interesting fact about Gabriel Resources is that they have never earned one dollar from any kind of commercial activity and they have certainly never done any mining operations. It is a pure financial shenanigan from start to finish: the company was born out of a corrupt (and secret) contract with the Romanian government in 1995, the company is registered in the Carribean, the shares are traded in Toronto and if they project ever does get going the whole shooting match will be sold off to the highest bidder (probably Russians) which makes a mockery of all those beautiful promises they made to Romanian politicians

To find out more see the website of Romanian MEP Victor Bostinaru.
16:17 on 16/07/2012
sir, for the sake of us all, i hope you are right!
in the last 6-7 months there were some sparks of social unity and i hope this attitude won't die down.
i didn't know all those facts regarding Gabriel Resources, but it was clear that their PR campaings are really expensive and on some level they really got a part of the population on their side.
you should also check the situation regarding fracking, the Romania-Chevron deal.
10:31 on 16/07/2012
Congratulation Rupert! Finally, a very well documented article on Rosia Montana situation. This is a true impulse for our cause. Keep up the good journalism and remember: Save Rosia Montana! :)
09:58 on 16/07/2012
I am from Romania and I support "Save Rosia Montana" campaign.
We shall fight, we shall never surrender!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
11:12 on 16/07/2012
Congratulations, power to the people!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Daisy May Boldock
Yorkshire..Gods Own Country
13:08 on 16/07/2012
Absolutely right to fight for all your worth too. A mug of cyanide apiece for the investors!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
09:05 on 16/07/2012
This is inspiring. Thanks for the article.
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
03:14 on 16/07/2012
The former East Block countries have experience in stinging a system that stings them. Although the communist ideology did not produce good results on the ground, the mantra of uniting, 'sticking together' etc. was not wrong and is still in their minds. Having just seen the docu about the Brooklyn Barcley's Centre, one would hope that the courts don't go after the money in Romania, or they have better legislation than in New York.

Creating the biggest cyanide lake in Europe so more people can afford gold necklaces? I hope not.