10/05/2012 08:45 BST | Updated 22/05/2015 10:12 BST

Masterpiece Or Disasterpiece: Lindsay Lohan's Metallic Mini Dress

Who: Lindsay Lohan and Jeniffer Love Hewitt

What: A metallic lace mini dress vs a contrasting scoop neck cocktail dress. Obviously, Lohan was in the metallic mini, which she wore with matching suede platforms and a statement pink pout. Hewitt played it safe in raspberry and nude pumps.

Where: The A&E Networks Upfront event in New York, 9 May

Bonus info: Even though Jennifer's dress wasn't quite as short and Lindsay's, she covered up in skin-coloured tights, a few shades lighter than her sun-kissed glow. Fashion faux-pas or a not-so-subtle way of covering up in the cold?

lindasy-lohan Photo: Wenn

Let us know how you rate the ladies' looks in a comment and see more of Lindsay in her style evoltuion below.

jennifer-love-hewitt Photo: Wenn

Passion for fashion? Follow us on Twitter and become our fan on Facebook