11/07/2013 15:16 BST | Updated 22/05/2015 06:12 BST

The Saturdays Super Short Shorts Raise Important Fashion Question: Are Nude Tights Ever OK?

Who? The Saturdays


What? On their mission to break America, The Saturdays took to the stage in New York last night, wearing some of the shortest shorts we have ever seen. Yes, it got them noticed, but their matchy-matchy style also revealed a little too much flesh and raised the ever-important fashion question: are shiny, nude tights ever a good look?

Where? XL Nightclub, New York, 13 September

Verdict? Part of us thinks, at least they wore tights, but the other thinks, why couldn't they have just worn something a bit longer? Let us know your thoughts below and see more of the stars in their style evolution below:

See more of The Sats taking on the US below: