MRI Scans Show Babies Are More Sensitive To Pain Than Adults

MRI Scans Show Babies Are More Sensitive To Pain Than Adults
|

Whether babies can feel pain has long been a subject of debate in the medical profession, but a new study has found that newborns do feel pain more strongly than adults.

Researchers from Oxford University have used brain scans to show that babies' brains react to mild pain in much the same way as adults.

Open Image Modal

Lead author of the report, Dr Rebeccah Slater from Oxford University's paediatrics department, explained why the findings are "particularly important":

"Obviously babies can’t tell us about their experience of pain and it is difficult to infer pain from visual observations," she said.

"In fact some people have argued that babies' brains are not developed enough for them to really 'feel' pain, any reaction being just a reflex – our study provides the first really strong evidence that this is not the case."

The study involved 10 healthy babies aged between one and six days old, and 10 healthy adults aged 23-36 years.

The babies were placed in a Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanner where they usually fell asleep.

MRI scans were then taken of the babies' brains as they were poked on the bottom of their feet with a retracting rod creating a sensation "like being poked with a pencil" – mild enough that it did not wake them up.

These scans were then compared with brain scans of adults exposed to the same pain stimulus.

Open Image Modal

MRI giving a comparison of brain activity in adults and babies when poked with a special retracting rod. Red-yellow areas represent active brain regions.

The researchers say it is possible to see pain 'happening' inside the infant brain and it looks a lot like pain in adults - as 18 of the 20 brain regions active in adults experiencing pain were active in babies.

The scans also showed that babies’ brains had the same response to a weak poke as adults did to a stimulus four times as strong.

Rachel Edwards, 33, from Oxford, gave permission for her son Alex to take part in the study.

Open Image Modal

Rachel Edwards and her son Alex.

"Before Alex went in I got to feel all the things he would feel as part of the study including the pencil-like retracting rod: it wasn't particularly painful, it was more of a precise feeling of touch," she said.

"He didn't wake up during the scanning and seemed really content afterwards.

"People know so little about how babies feel pain, you can tell they are in distress from their reaction and I was curious about why they react in the way they do."

Last year a review of neonatal pain management practice in intensive care found that although such infants experience an average of 11 painful procedures per day 60% of babies do not receive any kind of pain medication.

"Thousands of babies across the UK undergo painful procedures every day but there are often no local pain management guidelines to help clinicians," added Slater.

"We have to think that if we would provide pain relief for an older child undergoing a procedure then we should look at giving pain relief to an infant undergoing a similar procedure."

7 Things To Know About Babies
They Can Tell Good From Evil(01 of07)
Open Image Modal
Using puppets that act out good and bad behaviors, Yale's Baby Lab has been studying infant ethics for decades.

In one experiment, a cat puppet was struggling to open a box when a bunny puppet in a green t-shirt came along and helped him. The puppet masters then re-did the scenario with a bunny puppet in an orange t-shirt who cruelly slammed the box shut and ran away.

The lab's studies revealed that over 80 percent of babies under 24 months showed a preference for the puppet that demonstrates good behavior -- the helpful bunny in the green shirt. With 3-month-olds, the number increased to 87%.
They Have A Sense Of Self-Control(02 of07)
Open Image Modal
A 2014 study published in the journal Cognitive Development looked at 150 15-month-olds. The babies watched an adult demonstrate how to use several noise-making toys. Then, a second adult entered the room and angrily scolded the first for making so much noise.

After the demonstration, the babies were welcome to play with the toys, but for half of them, the angry second adult left the room or turned away, while the latter half remained under that adult's gaze.

Babies in the former group did not hesitate to start playing with the toys, but the ones in the second group generally waited a little bit and then played with the toys differently than they'd seen in the demonstration. This indicated that they were trying to adjust their actions to avoid the anger of the second adult -- therefore, they are able to resist their impulses and show self-control.
Foreign Languages Sound … Well, Foreign To Them(03 of07)
Open Image Modal
Mere hours after their birth, babies can sense the difference between sounds in their native language and a foreign one.

Researchers in Sweden and Washington state studied 40 newborns wearing pacifiers that were wired to a computer. When the babies heard sounds from foreign languages, they sucked the pacifiers for much longer than when they heard their native tongue -- this indicates that they could differentiate between the two.

According to researcher Patricia Kuhl, "The vowel sounds in [the mother's] speech are the loudest units and the fetus locks onto them."
They’re Tuned In To Each Other’s Emotions(04 of07)
Open Image Modal
By the time they reach 5 months, babies are able to sense each other's feelings.

In a BYU 2013 study, 20 5-month-old babies and 20 3.5-month-old babies sat in front of two monitors, which showed a video of a smiling baby and a video of a frowning baby. Then the scientists played two audio recordings: one of happy baby and one of a sad baby.

Upon hearing the the sounds of the happy baby, the 5-month-olds looked at the monitor with the smiling baby, and when they heard the sad baby audio, they turned to the frowning baby video. The 3.5-month old babies were less successful in matching these sounds and images.
Their Ears Register More Words From Mom Than Dad(05 of07)
Open Image Modal
A recent study published in Pediatrics found that infants react more to words from moms than from dads. All 33 babies in the study wore sound-recording vests which revealed that they heard three times more words from moms than from dads.

A researcher from the study, Dr. Betty Vohr, told Time that "a possible explanation is that the pitch of mother’s voice or its proximity is more stimulating for babies."
They Have The Ability To Learn Sign Language(06 of07)
Open Image Modal
Although babies generally don't start speaking their first few words until 12 months old and still have a limited vocabulary by age 2, they have the ability to develop an impressive mastery of sign language from the age of 6 months.

After noticing that the children of his deaf friends were communicating with their families with sign language from a very early age, Dr. Joseph Garcia founded the "Sign With Your Baby" program in which instructors teach parents and babies American Sign Language.
And, They Can Read Lips(07 of07)
Open Image Modal
A 2012 study showed that babies read people's lips when they're learning to talk.

Researchers at Florida Atlantic University observed almost 180 babies at ages 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 months and studied their behavior when they saw videos of adults speaking. The experiment showed that when babies are about 6 months old, they stop looking into adults’ eyes and start focusing on their lips to learn how to make sounds.

So next time you’re in the presence of a lip-reading baby, you might want to be a little more mindful about what you say.