Johnny Mercer Told 'Facts Matter' During Bizarre Question Time Performance

Tory minister makes a series of dubious claims, and faces criticism for “shouting across every member of the panel".
LOADINGERROR LOADING

A Conservative minister has been ridiculed online for his performance on BBC Question Time.

Johnny Mercer clashed with Labour frontbencher Bridget Philipson repeatedly on the corporation’s flagship politics show, and faced criticism for talking over fellow panelists.

At one point, the Opposition MP was joined by host Fiona Bruce and guest Dale Vince, the green energy entrepreneur, to correct the veterans minister wrongly suggesting the Labour Party was funded by climate protestors, Just Stop Oil.

Here's @JohnnyMercerUK making, frankly, an absolute ass of himself on #BBCQT.

Gets his facts totally wrong then just doubles down with more lies - as if a donor giving money to two organisations is the same as the organisations funding each other.

Out of control arrogance. ~AA pic.twitter.com/HnA7HJG3IH

— Best for Britain (@BestForBritain) July 6, 2023

An almost unbelievably appalling performance from Mercer this evening

pic.twitter.com/7f30TYSBwH

— Liam Thorp (@LiamThorpECHO) July 6, 2023

Mercer said: “You’re funded by Just Stop Oil, right? Which you’re not gonna give back.”

Philipson replied: “What are you talking about? That is categorically untrue.”

Mercer then tried to argue Vance donated to Just Stop Oil and some Labour politicians, including leader Keir Starmer.

“Facts matter,” Bruce interjected, as she pointed out this was not the same as Just Stop Oil funding the Labour Party.

“Would you like to set the record straight now, Johnny,” asked Philipson.

He was also slapped down after misinterpreting Labour’s position on the NHS.

During a question about the NHS, as the service marks its 75th anniversary, Philipson made the case for the NHS remaining free at the point of need – meaning the public has access to healthcare regardless of whether they can afford it at that moment or not.

She said: “I believe the principle of access free at the point of need is what has built the NHS, and made it so great, that we know that however much you’ve got in your bank account you can get the care you need, or you should be able to get the care you need at the point at which you need it.”

She added: “The sad reality is after 13 years of the Conservatives, that isn’t the case for people right now.”

But the point was was later given a different spin by Mercer.

The Plymouth MP said: “I mean, this idea that Bridget came out with, it depends how much money you’ve got in your bank account, whether you get served in A&E, is obviously garbage.”

Philipson swiftly responded: “That wasn’t the point I was making. You’re misrepresenting my position.”

Mercer continued: “You did say it depends how much money you’ve got as to how quickly you get treated.”

Philipson continued that she apologised if she “misspoke”, adding: “The point I was making was that it shouldn’t depend on how much you have in your bank account, whether you get access to healthcare.”

She ended the back and forth by saying: “Your government has broken the NHS and now you quibble about semantics.”

"Your government has broken the NHS and now you quibble about semantics."

Johnny Mercer misquotes @bphillipsonMP on the NHS. Bridget corrects and shames him #BBCQT pic.twitter.com/WstpH3ppUs

— Farrukh (@implausibleblog) July 6, 2023

Johnny mercer needing an instant fact check 🤦♀️

Makes up some LaLa land story that Bridget Phillipson said it depends how much money you have in the bank whether you can get seen in A&E 🤔

So I put the 2 clips together so you can see his pathetic lies#bbcqt #ToryLiars pic.twitter.com/SDinmvJkKA

— kerry ✊💙Save Our NHS (@hewitson10) July 6, 2023

Johnny Mercer says on BBCQT that the govt brought in “the living wage”. That’s not actually true, it brought in the national living wage, which is slightly lower than the rate calculated by @LivingWageUK & only applies if you are 23 and over

— Rachel Wearmouth (@REWearmouth) July 6, 2023

Another shameless Tory lie from Johnny Mercer

"The minimum wage was actually bought in by this government"

Dale Vince and even Fiona Bruce correct himpic.twitter.com/Za7zRGbsOn

— Central Bylines (@CentralBylines) July 6, 2023

What the fuck was Johnny Mercer talking about? Christ this babbling display reminded me of the time my mate brought his estate agent colleague to the afters, except worse because THIS guy is supposed to be a minister!

Yeah, the minister for talking absolute bollocks. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/nbUDX20raK

— Supertanskiii (@supertanskiii) July 6, 2023

The Tory MP was later accused of “shouting across every member of the panel tonight” by an audience member.

Mercer on the show stood by his jibe at critics of “collective bed-wetting” after the backlash he faced for saying armed forces personnel don’t need to use food banks.

Close

What's Hot