Very Rev. Kelvin Holdsworth, who belongs to the Scottish Episcopal Church, wrote the original post nearly two years ago. (A version was reposted on Jan. 27.) His words resurfaced on Twitter and in a number of media outlets ― including The New York Times, The Guardian and Time ― last week after the 4-year-old George’s uncle, Prince Harry, announced his engagement to American actress Meghan Markle.
The piece, “How to change the Church of England,” outlined Holdsworth’s take on how acceptance of same-sex marriage would be achieved. Though marriage equality was legalized in England and Wales in 2013, same-sex marriages are not recognized by the Church of England.
Holdsworth suggested that marriage equality advocates pray “for the Lord to bless Prince George with a love, when he grows up, of a fine young gentleman.”
“A royal wedding might sort things out remarkably easily,” he said, “though we might have to wait 25 years for that to happen.”
Prince George is third in line to the British throne, following his grandfather, Charles, Prince of Wales, and his father, Prince William.
The minister’s remarks were condemned on social media.
“Beware of the false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly are ravenous wolves.”— Denny Burk (@DennyBurk) December 1, 2017
“Anglican Minister Urges Prayers for Prince George to Be Gay” https://t.co/3e521VuFuFpic.twitter.com/zfSQ3NcCQ1
This is outrageous - apostate church minister wants Prince George to be gay. Stop sexualising children. https://t.co/mqZELyTp4m— David Kurten ن (@davidkurten) December 3, 2017
Prince George is four years old...— Sammy 🎄 (@MadWorldOfSam) December 1, 2017
Praying for someone to be gay is just as bad as praying for them to be straight.
Whoever he is sexually attracted to when he grows up shouldn’t matter.
Damaging this kid by putting pressure on him to be gay will do more harm than good.
Religious leaders were similarly critical.
Gavin Ashenden, a former chaplain to Queen Elizabeth II and a Christian Episcopal Church missionary bishop, accused Holdsworth of using Prince George as “a gender-political football” among followers.
“What is especially odd and incongruous is the fact that it is suddenly OK to pray for someone to be gay,” Ashenden told the BBC, “but totally unacceptable to pray for them to be free from being gay and to resume a sexuality that was in tune with their biology.”
Susie Leafe, director of the conservative evangelical group Reform, told the BBC, “As a Christian minister he should pray for all people to come to know the love of Christ, rather than a fine young gentleman.”
In a Dec. 1 blog, Holdsworth apologized for the outrage he had ― belatedly ― ignited, but stressed that his words had been widely misinterpreted.
“I could spend the next few weeks defending that post and keep reminding people what it was originally about. However, it seems to me that isn’t likely to be fruitful,” he wrote.
“The issues about the church and its capacity to welcome same-sex couples who want to be married remain important,” he continued. “I’m not interested in continuing it through a conversation about Prince George. I would urge others, those who agree with me strongly and those who disagree with me strongly to turn our attentions to the actual matter at hand.”