Purple Book Released - What People Are Saying

Purple Book Mandelson

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 15/09/11 11:14 BST Updated: 14/11/11 10:12 GMT

The Purple Book - essays written by the so-called 'progressive' wing of the Labour Party - hits the bookshelves today. It's a long-awaited anthology with contributions by current shadow cabinet members Ed Miliband and Douglas Alexander, among others. There are also essays from former Labour big-hitters like Peter Mandelson, Jacqui Smith and Lord Adonis.

The book aims to reposition Labour as a party capable of winning the next General Election, and has been widely viewed as an alternative school of thought to the Blue Labour movement, which argues that Labour needs to re-connect with its working class roots.

The publication comes as rumours are beginning to circulate that Ed Miliband is planning a shadow cabinet reshuffle after Labour's party conference, which starts on the 25th of September.

In his foreword to the collection, Labour leader Ed Miliband writes: "You may not agree with all the views expressed in this book. Nor do I. But I believe strongly that a vibrant debate across the party, in all its colours, is a necessary condition of renewal and returning to power."

Very few people appear to have seen the book in advance, but even before its release the Purple Book was making waves within Labour, with accusations of anonymous briefings against it by the left of the party. Sources told The Observer the contents of the book were 'lazy and idiotic'.

Guido Fawkes' first comment on the book was to sieze on a quote Peter Mandelson, who writes that some within Labour are "prone to clutch at straws and grab at any passing fad."

Mandelson writes:

The problem with killing off New Labour and putting nothing in its place is that it leads us to clutch at straws and grab at any passing sentiment. This is what has happened with blue Labour, which seeks to reconnect the party with its old, post-war, apparently white and male, industrial working-class base. These people have moved on, to other jobs, to other aspirations and, in the main, to an entirely different identity

Writing at Labour Uncut, Anthony Painter also finds Peter Mandleson's essay to be one of the highlights, where the former Business Secretary argues Labour lost the election in 2010 “not because of our record…but because voters weren’t convinced we were the right choice for the future”.

In his essay the former Hartlepool MP delivers a riposte to Blue Labour, arguing:

Now some suggest we should look elsewhere for electoral support by proposing reconnection with (what is left of ) the traditional working class on the basis of a nostalgic longing for a lost communitarian past. I doubt if my former supporters on the Hartlepool estates would understand what they are on about and, if they did, they would reject such patronising assumptions about their aspirations and ambitions.

Whiile broadly welcoming the book as a whole, Painter feels there is one crucial essay missing, arguing: "The collection as a whole misses an additional essay on the economic future. Co-operatism is everywhere, as you’d expect. But that is only part of the new economic future."

The Guardian's political editor Patrick Wintour writes of the Purple Book: "Overall, the book tries to avoid reheated Blairism since it accepts the Brown and Blair governments both placed too much faith in the value of a globalised market, misread the signals on the squeeze on living standards and offered a top-heavy state that disenfranchised too many communities."

Those wanting to read the Labour MP Tristram Hunt's contribution to the Purple Book without buying the whole thing can download his essay from his website [pdf].

Hunt describes the Big Society as the "most audacious of Cameroonian land grabs", and argues:

Electoral success is based on two factors: economic competence and the ability to communicate a compelling vision of a future society. Without a clear strategy for deficit reduction, Labour will fall at the first of these two hurdles. Embracing more democratic models of ownership can help to communicate the vision of society and our values of solidarity, cooperation, reciprocity and community empowerment in ways that the public can understand.
FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

The Purple Book - essays written by the so-called 'progressive' wing of the Labour Party - hits the bookshelves today. It's a long-awaited anthology with contributions by current shadow cabinet membe...
The Purple Book - essays written by the so-called 'progressive' wing of the Labour Party - hits the bookshelves today. It's a long-awaited anthology with contributions by current shadow cabinet membe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Haselden
An Enemy of Rupert Murdoch, since 1984.
02:50 PM on 09/16/2011
Don't care , I won't be wasting my money on it. I've got to eat.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AceNewsServices
Changing The World One Step At A Time
01:20 PM on 09/15/2011
Does it really matter what color the book is as it is what is written inside that really matters, or not as in this case.

Today we spend far too much time on how we should look and not what they say. It is time to say style is OK but substance is better and OK he/she looks well dressed but it is not really going to get this country back on its feet.

We measure success by the car and house not what that person does everyday for other people, even though we think they need to be rewarded with some sort of plastic gong or given a title of hero of the year, the true hero`s and giver`s never do it for reward they do it for people.

So stop trying to change the cover of your book and put into it what people want a way forward enabling them to have the simple basic in life a job to obtain food, clothes and a roof over their heads for their family but all at the right price, time to do something for somebody else not yourselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
11:25 AM on 09/15/2011
I have little faith in anything that the LORDS spin doctors have to say about the Labour Party, I would not trust them to see a blind man across the road.
11:05 AM on 09/15/2011
Sources told The Observer the contents of the book were 'lazy and idiotic'.
-------------------------------------------------
I get that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Haselden
An Enemy of Rupert Murdoch, since 1984.
02:52 PM on 09/16/2011
Most are discredited anyway. It'll be the usual repositioning "Bollocks" that the parties do to distance themselves from L'ancien Regime.