Jack Straw Calls For Direct Elections To The European Parliament To End Due To 'Democratic Deficit'

Straw

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 21/02/2012 16:11 Updated: 21/02/2012 17:54

Former foreign secretary Jack Straw has claimed that failing to give voters across Europe a proper say about joining the Euro has contributed to the problems facing the single currency, and warned against any further major EU treaties being passed without the direct approval of the public.

The senior Labour MP has also called for root-and-branch reform of the European Parliament, suggesting that direct elections to it are a waste of time.

Speaking at a debate organised by the IPPR think-tank in London on Tuesday, Straw said: "If the Euro had been put to voters, there would have been major stress-testing… and if it did pass, we’d be spared a whole lot of trouble”

Straw’s attack on the EU comes after former chancellor Alastair Darling's recent warning that the EU may threaten Parliamentary sovereignty. Straw echoed Darling’s concern about Greece’s frail economy as he warned: “Greece is a country on the brink”

Speaking at the IPPR, Straw attacked the "major democratic deficit" at the heart of the European Union, adding that they had been "over the last 30 years... a project of elites".

The European Parliament has “not worked” as a democratic institution, Straw claimed. He pointed to declining turnouts in European elections to show that “as [the European Parliament] got more powers, it has got less legitimate”.

Straw was reluctant to rely too much on the turnouts themselves as, he argued, voters used them as a “referendum on the current national government”.

He attributed this to popular disenchantment. “They [voters] have no idea what is going on in Brussels… and they feel alienated” he said.

The former foreign secretary declared that the European Union “has got to do less, and do it better”. He added as an example, “we’ve got to argue that the EU should not be involved with working time directives and health and safety”. Straw complained that the “single instruments designed to make a level playing field have done the opposite”.

Straw called for the European Parliament to be reformed so it was an “assembly of national parliaments”. He declared – “enough is enough with the EU Parliament being directly elected”.

On the euro, Straw made a candid admission. “Were I starting with a clean sheet, I’d say to Spain, Portugal and Greece: don’t join the Euro”. Despite this, he predicted that it was “more likely than not” that the Euro would survive.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

Former foreign secretary Jack Straw has claimed that failing to give voters across Europe a proper say about joining the Euro has contributed to the problems facing the single currency, and warned aga...
Former foreign secretary Jack Straw has claimed that failing to give voters across Europe a proper say about joining the Euro has contributed to the problems facing the single currency, and warned aga...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:43 PM on 02/24/2012
So Jack "Boot" Straw wants to abolish democracy in the EU? No surprise there
04:43 PM on 02/22/2012
Seems Jack Straw has a selective memory, did not hear him making these announcements when he was Foreign Secretary, but what does one expect as all politicians tell so many untruth they eventually forget what they did say. Put him out to pasture and ignore any more drivel that comes out of his mouth.
04:17 PM on 02/22/2012
Voting wouldn't have changed a thing. People would have been pushed to vote in favor of what the "humeur du jour" was, as it happened in Ireland. Furthermore, people vote on an idea but can't vote on its execution afterwards. The problem of the Euro is not so much the idea and the concept in general but the flaws in execution; strict deficit limits were set in the mechanism to avoid the situation we know but the Germans themselves broke them because of their re unification. Then the devil was outside the box.
photo
WRH Mike Rivero
Humble and concise
02:54 PM on 02/22/2012
"Former foreign secretary Jack Straw has claimed that failing to give voters across Europe a proper say about joining the Euro has contributed to the problems facing the single currency, and warned against any further major EU treaties being passed without the direct approval of the public."

... even though that is exactly what the Greek people were NOT allowed to do in this latest bailout "deal!"
01:13 PM on 02/22/2012
I strongly disagree with Jack Straw, who wants to turn back the clock to a time when there was an European assembly of national parliamentarians (from 1958 until 1978).
He proposes effectively abolishing an institution that represents the citizens of 27 countries, just because levels of voter participation in the UK are lower than he would like. Some of the member states have very high voter turnout for elections to the EP. Why should they be punished?
MEPs have a lot of work to do scrutinizing the budget, amending legislation and holding the European Commission to account. It is not a part-time job that can be done "on the side" by members of national parliaments.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allyb999
03:22 PM on 02/22/2012
But they are not held to account, please feel free to tell me when was the last time the European Commisions books last signed off?
05:11 PM on 02/22/2012
Commissioners can't do anything without the approval of the European Parliament, and they regulary answer questions in Parliamentary Committees.
The point is that the rules and institutions of the club (I mean the EU) were recently revised and agreed by all 27 Member States, when they ratified the 'Lisbon Treaty'. One member state cannot change the rules without the agreement of the other 26.
I guess Jack Straw knows this (as a former Foreign Secretary). So why is he moaning? It's just typical attention-seeking behaviour of a former front-bench politician who is missing the spotlight. It's also an insult to all of the UK's elected MEPs (many of whom work very hard) and especially Labour MEPs who would expect more sensible and constructive comments from comrade Straw.
12:56 PM on 02/22/2012
As levels of voter turnout seem to be Jack Straw's test of democratic legitimacy, then presumably no local council has any form of mandate. Fewer people in Britain tend to vote in local authority than in European elections.

Has he really considered the implications of his very curious test?
10:08 AM on 02/22/2012
Jack Straw said because the voters don’t know what is going on in Brussels the voters feel alienated. It is because I know exactly what is going on in Brussels I am alienated.

The best solution to the problem of the euro and the EU is to scrap the whole project, it has failed and it is time for the nations of the EU to return to governing themselves, running their own economies and having their own currencies. This worked well until the EU came along and screwed it all up.
01:36 PM on 02/22/2012
Spot on :-))
08:29 AM on 02/22/2012
I agree with root and branch reform of the European Parliament. First pull it up by the roots and then use the branch to beat those who believe in having the laws of this country overruled by an unaccountable Brussels bureaucracy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GingerlyColors
No will to change it, no right to criticize it
06:59 AM on 02/22/2012
Like many people, I disagree with the European Parliament but I always vote in European elections. The reason is that while we are saddled with it I still want the best representation out of it - no vote, no voice. When we joined the Common Market in the 1970's we were assured that it was just going to be a free trading bloc and that there will be no erosion of sovereignty. Then came the European Parliament then came the Euro. EU no, European Free Trade Area yes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
06:34 AM on 02/22/2012
If only some of these labour politicians had shown some cajones during their time in government we would not be in the position whereupon we signed up to provide financial guarantees for struggling member states at great cost to ourselves and our own people, with little chance of ever recovering those huge amounts.
08:34 PM on 02/21/2012
I've gotta say that these Labour boys have some cracking ideas in opposition.
07:12 AM on 02/22/2012
Yes built on the ideas of BNP, Britain First and UKIP! Remember it was the Main 3 that signed us up to the EU and signed away our rights too! Vote for change of the main 3 by voting BNP, British First and UKIP! A refreshing change for the British people!
06:34 PM on 02/21/2012
I agree and have said the following here several times.

Euro-MO's should be chosen by the British Parliament from the British Parliament. Then we do not need Euro-Elections.

These EURO-nominated MP's can come back and answer to the British Parliament.

In the nineties I worked full-time for four days on a Labour Euro-campaign. I tell you most people Labour Party MEMBERS did not know the name of the candidate or their sitting MP.

No-one had clue how they were selected. Do you?
concodtob
16 stone athlete and intellectual
07:23 PM on 02/21/2012
I used to be a Labour supporter but turned to the UKIP after Labour denied us a referendum they promised on the Lisbon Treaty.The same document that was rejected unaminously by French and Dutch voters.I haven't met a Europhile yet who can answer as to why the Lisbon Treaty is still here?Yet it is now part of the EU project which is all about federalism and against national sovereignty,fact!
07:31 PM on 02/21/2012
I visited Brussels a few times for work. The french and Italian officials I dealt with had an easy-going ''federalism is coming'' attitude. They are building an undemocratic Federal Europe. And worse, they think it is ''meritocratic'' as the best of the best are there. That is not the case. One thing I must also say. As long as the UK is in the European Union, could we send a higher caliber of person to work there on our behalf? the people I met were being manipulated by other nationalities who were cleverer, more mature and much more cunning. Our folk - nice, dull, civil, unimpressive and too young.