Budget 2012: Tory MPs Worry About 50p Tax Rate Cut

PA/The Huffington Post  |  By   |  Posted: 20/03/2012 15:27 Updated: 21/03/2012 07:59

Osborne50ptaxrate

George Osborne is facing unease on the Tory benches over the prospect of cuts to the top rate of tax, with one MP warning the the public would not understand why the rich needed a tax cut.

The chancellor is widely expected to use his Budget statement tomorrow to set out how he intends to reduce the 50p rate for people earning more than £150,000 a year.

The move has been warmly welcomed by some Conservative MPs who believe the 50p rate - introduced by the last Labour government - is a deterrent to enterprise and is holding back growth.

They argue that it is an inefficient means of generating revenue, with the wealthy able to avoid paying or simply leaving the country - a view expected to be supported by research by HM Revenue and Customs due to be published alongside the Budget.

But others in the party fear that it will play into the hands of Labour, enabling them to argue that the Tories are handing a tax cut to the better-off at a time when low and middle-income earners are still feeling the economic squeeze.

Conservative backbencher Jesse Norman told BBC Radio 4's The World At One: "I do think that the possibility of cutting the top rate is a concern. I don't think people will understand that this is being done in order to raise more money.

"That idea I don't think is going to get across without an enormous amount of communication."

Labour continued to press home their attack, with shadow Treasury minister Owen Smith describing a cut in the 50p rate as the "wrong priority".

"At a time when there is a huge squeeze on families on middle and low incomes, cutting the top rate of tax for people on over £150,000 would be completely the wrong priority and show just how out of touch this Government is," he said.

FOLLOW UK POLITICS

George Osborne is facing unease on the Tory benches over the prospect of cuts to the top rate of tax, with one MP warning the the public would not understand why the rich needed a tax cut. The chan...
George Osborne is facing unease on the Tory benches over the prospect of cuts to the top rate of tax, with one MP warning the the public would not understand why the rich needed a tax cut. The chan...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
08:12 AM on 03/21/2012
Of course I need a tax break, I mean, I have to pay Eton fees, and the new extension (for the billiards room) is turning out to be a little more expensive than I thought. The money I saved by avoiding stamp duty on my second home was barely enough to pay for the Bentley.
As a banker I have worked hard gambling with, sorry, investing other peoples money in businesses that have failed to pay me back, the free jollies were nice, I thought they had the ability to pay.
And of course the off shore bank account and multi-million pound pension fund administration don't come cheap.
5p off of my income tax will solve most of these worries, increase my sense of self worth and provide more security for my family.

Invest in Britain?
Good grief NO, just a nation of lazy scroungers and cheats.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ozybrum
02:46 AM on 03/21/2012
If no money is being collected from the 50p rate as the coalition claims, why are all the toffs jumping on the bandwagon to get it abolished? Even a child could understand the logic of this.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
09:00 PM on 03/20/2012
Maggie said something similar 'if you understood you would agree with me'.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
08:50 PM on 03/20/2012
They don't NEED a tax cut at all, they want one, just plain greedy, it must be the rich all have that gluttony gene I have been reading about. lol
northern git
fed up with all the political crap in life
09:38 PM on 03/20/2012
they need TAX HIKE

we get the hike in what we have had to spend

the richer always have had the means now they need to feel a pinch

75% sounds about right to me


how about you?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
08:21 PM on 03/20/2012
The public is also unlikely to understand why MP's on the fiddle cannot be named and why no one has yet been made to answer for starting the credit crunch which almost destroyed the world's financial system and put millions out of work and out of their homes.
northern git
fed up with all the political crap in life
07:52 PM on 03/20/2012
they will all worry

come an election the voters WILL remember

and then the 50 they will remebr all their lives will be the 50% that lose their seats

roll on that day of reckoning
07:21 PM on 03/20/2012
The public wont understand why the rich need a tax cut ? dont under sell us we know why, its called sheer greed, every body and his dog gets a pay freeze except the rich ,and thats rich !

They have given all of our public to their friends the bankers ,and destroyed this country .
Welcome to Mad Max UK .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
George McAulay
Delighted to meet you
12:38 AM on 03/21/2012
F&F mate from down under.

The UK is in the sewer and all the punters have to tighten their belts whilst the rich man gets a benefit.

Unbelievable !
07:20 PM on 03/20/2012
The problem for GO + DC - and their 'best boy" Nickkers - is that cutting the 50% tax band will be (a) deeply divisive and (b) quite possibly cost them the next election as it's benefits - quite possibly notional anyway - won't have'kicked in' in time. There's also the possibility that the very people who it will benefit, will simply export their additional wealth "offshore" thereby giving UK PLCs' tax account a double whammy! Therefore I ask, why do it???
07:13 PM on 03/20/2012
The wealthy need not pay more than 30% if fairness be told....Give the wealthy their tax break, bring everyone's tax rates DOWN, CUT spending on BENEFITS, SUPPORT Pensions because those were WORKED FOR and lets GET ON with the business of living in the UK....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
08:52 PM on 03/20/2012
yay make poor people poorer and the rich even richer!
northern git
fed up with all the political crap in life
10:01 PM on 03/20/2012
give 'em a tax break

how does 75% sound?
07:06 PM on 03/20/2012
All income tax should be a percentage of earnings i think that would be fairer than the tiered system
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
08:54 PM on 03/20/2012
why is that fairer? 25% of minimum wage and 25% of someone earning £150,000. Doesn't look fair to me.
09:36 PM on 03/20/2012
So, jannoOOO, you don't think it's fair that someone earning £150,000 should pay £37,000 a year in tax? Seems a fairer system to me - especially as, if you really are on the minimum wage, you probably aren't earning enough to pay much tax, if any at all..

No-one should have to pay tax on the first £20,000 or earnings.
10:14 AM on 03/21/2012
Did i say 25% NO read the comment correctly
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
werba
06:10 PM on 03/20/2012
Actually I don't know anyone who objects strongly to 'the rich' paying less than 50% tax. What people do object to is being seen as 'rich' when they earn something like £75,000 pa, out of which they have to pay school fees and transport costs. People I know do object strongly to 33% of their taxes going to the benefits system.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
08:56 PM on 03/20/2012
You must know some pretty selfish people then, why would they not want to support pensioners, the sick the disabled the unemployed? You are saying precisley what the govt wants you to say well done! Let's hope you never need benefits in the future because there won't be any. Wake up!
09:50 PM on 03/20/2012
Perhaps we can start exterminating people who lose their jobs and end up on the dole through no fault of their own ,then you wont have to feel so strongly about where your taxes go while were at it we can bring in compulsory death for anyone over the age of 65 then you wont have to prop up their pension but dont forget not all privately educated kids make it in the big wide world
06:07 PM on 03/20/2012
I think 50% tax rate should kick in at some level, not sure where, I never earned more than £30000 per annum so these large salary figures would just have have been a pipe dream.
We must stop individuals buying property in this country through made for purpose companies registered in foreign countries, I am sure multi millionaires who in some cases have made their wealth easily could afford stamp duty.
04:49 PM on 03/20/2012
I am glad those rich people are getting a tax credit there is nothing as bad as seeing miserable looking rich people this should cheer them up. Of course the amount of money it takes to implement every single change the government makes means more training programs need to get cut and a few more hospitals and A&Es will have to close.... Maybe we can tax non rich people who live in social housing and have a spare bedroom, maybe an asylum seeker could rent it out .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
08:58 PM on 03/20/2012
perhaps they could tax the air us poor people breathe and give them a bigger tax cut.
04:18 PM on 03/20/2012
The plain truth is, the rich top percent will not willingly invest in this country.

We have a situation where the money is flying from our shores faster than it can be counted, and this has been happening ever since tax rates were first cut for the rich.

Reducing this 50p rate will do nothing for OUR economy.

When the rates over in the USA were as high as 95%, that tax, and the wealth it was based on, was directed into the US economy, with startling results, giving the US the best few decades of internal investment and growth it had ever experienced.
This came to a sudden halt when the last few GOP administrations under the Bush and Reagan regimes, relaxed the financial regulations, a practice emulated here by Thatcher and subsequent administrations, leaving the door open for the wealth that had been locked into the economy, leave to depart for other places.

Instead of recognising this, and acting upon it, this dozy coalition are simply kicking the door even further open, giving yet more encouragement for those with the wealth to hive it off out of the economy that desperately needs it to be once again locked into the economy of the UK. not some third world region just because their labour element is cheaper than ours.
04:18 PM on 03/20/2012
Oh, my, I do hate being patronised.

We understand, Mr. Osborne, we just don't like it.