Gaza Attacks: Guardian's Steve Bell Sparks Outrage Over Israel 'Puppet Master' Cartoon

16/11/2012 14:49
  • The Huffington Post UK

A Guardian cartoon showing Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu as a "puppet master" holding dolls of William Hague and Tony Blair has sparked outrage, with claims the image harkens back to anti-Semitic propaganda.

In the background of the cartoon by the newspaper's resident illustrator, Steve Bell, Israeli flags are depicted with stars of David printed on missiles and the slogan "Vote Likud", Netanyahu's political party, above his head.

The cartoon has attracted more than 300 comments.

steve bell

The Guardian's cartoon on Friday featured Netanyahu and puppets

Foreign secretary Hague has been accused by some of a statement too critical of the Palestinians, after saying on Thursday: "Hamas bears principal responsibility for the current crisis.

"I utterly condemn rocket attacks from Gaza into southern Israel by Hamas and other armed groups.

"This creates an intolerable situation for Israeli civilians in southern Israel, who have the right to live without fear of attack from Gaza."

The Community Security Trust, which monitors anti-Semitism in Britain, said in a statement on its website: "What is striking about Steve Bell’s cartoon is that he seems to have reached for the ‘puppeteer’ trope to explain that fact that William Hague’s statement on the conflict was presumably not critical enough of Israel for his liking, as if this is the most plausible explanation for Hague’s view.

"The anti-Semitic trope of Jews as puppeteers, controlling the politicians of ostensibly much more powerful nations, should be familiar to the Guardian: Jonathan Freedland wrote about it in their pages in 2011, when he described it as 'an image with long-established service in the cause of antisemitism'."

The Board of Deputies of British Jews' chief executive Jon Benjamin said the cartoon could be "straight out of Der Sturmer", the Nazi propaganda newspaper.

Damian Thompson, editor of Telegraph Blogs, wrote in a post on the site: "My sense is that the odious Steve Bell has produced a cartoon so unquestionably anti-Semitic – Jews as puppet–masters, for God's sake – that even the Guardian won't be able to shrug this one off."

The cartoon caused fierce debate on Twitter, with many arguing it was published purely to demonstrate the influence of the Israeli government and a criticism of Netanyahu's influence.

A spokesman for the Guardian said the newspaper had not yet decided what would be their response to the criticism.

Guardian Cartoon Row

CONVERSATIONS