Scottish Independence: SNP Plan To Scrap Trident 'Unacceptable For Nato' Warn Ex-Military Chiefs

Posted: Updated:
TRIDENT SUBMARINE
Jeff J Mitchell via Getty Images

The SNP's plan to scrap Trident would cast a "dark shadow" over the international reception given to a newly independent Scottish nation, according to a dozen high-ranking defence veterans.

Admiral Sir Mark Stanhope, former first sea lord and chief of naval staff, has sent a letter to First Minister Alex Salmond co-signed by former heads of the army, navy, air force and intelligence warning that the SNP's proposed constitutional ban on nuclear weapons "would be unacceptable for Nato".

Scotland would be "a new small nation in an uncertain world" in need of allies, but Nato "could hardly be expected to welcome a new member state whose government put in jeopardy the continued operation of the UK independent nuclear deterrent", Sir Mark said.

"Many, if not most" of the 7,000 staff employed at Faslane and Coulport "would lose their jobs", he added.

He criticised the Scottish Government's White Paper on independence, which was published in November last year.

The letter states: "The White Paper admits that this part of their plan has been drawn up with the help of the unilateralist Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament.

"For the continuing UK such a demand, not least in the time-scale envisaged, would cause huge practical problems and upheaval for the Royal Navy and require massive additional expenditure - running into many billions of pounds - and would be deeply resented by many.

"The negotiations with Westminster following a Yes vote, covering such vital matters as currency, financial settlements and re-allocating existing UK defence and other assets, can be expected to be complex and difficult.

"If the very future of the UK nuclear deterrent was also in the balance, it would inevitably sour those negotiations.

"Were the Scottish people to vote for independence, then Scotland, as a new small nation in an uncertain world, would need international partners to help secure its economic and social objectives and allies to provide national security.

"Nato, as an Alliance with nuclear deterrence as a central part of its strategic concept, could hardly be expected to welcome a new member state whose government put in jeopardy the continued operation of the UK independent nuclear deterrent - a deterrent which protects not only the UK but all of Nato as well.

"The United States and France as two of the P3 nuclear powers could be expected to be particularly concerned at the risk that an independent Scotland was effectively pushing a unilateral nuclear disarmament agenda that they and Nato have consistently opposed.

"They would also view with alarm the White Paper suggestion of a constitutional ban on nuclear weapons in Scotland - a move which would be unacceptable for Nato allies.

"The consequences for negotiations with the continuing UK for EU and Nato membership are impossible to predict, but the very prospect of implementing the Scottish Government's policy would cast a dark shadow over the international reception given to a newly independent Scottish nation."

The letter is also signed by former chiefs of the defence staff Air Chief Marshal Lord Stirrup, General Lord Walker, Admiral the Lord Boyce and Field Marshal Lord Guthrie; first sea lords and chiefs of the naval staff Admiral Sir Jonathon Band, Admiral Lord West of Spithead, Admiral Sir Nigel Essenhigh, Admiral Sir Jock Slater; former chief of the general staff General Sir Mike Jackson; former chief of the air staff Air Chief Marshal Sir Peter Squire; and former permanent secretary and security and intelligence co-ordinator at the Cabinet office Sir David Omand.

Also on HuffPost:

Suggest a correction