Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Adnan Al-Daini

GET UPDATES FROM Adnan Al-Daini
 

Austerity in the Midst of a Depression - Mad, Bad and Immoral

Posted: 01/06/2012 15:43

Right wing politicians and commentators have always been able to appeal to the lowest instincts of human nature in a way that chimes with the aspirations of the many. Take, for example, the issue of the savage cuts in government spending; they are presented in the guise of a "family finances" argument. As a family "wouldn't you want to pay your debts and live within your means?" is an appealing argument.

There is, of course, a crucial difference between running a household budget and running the country's finances.

If you are lucky enough to be employed, and you discover that your expenditure exceeds your income or you are in debt, the right thing to do is for your family to economize, so that it lives within its means and pays its debts.

The income of a government, however, comes from the taxes we pay, and that depends on the economic activity in the country and the level of employment. In a recession economic activity is down, unemployment is up, and thus the tax intake goes down.

Austerity and cuts will depress economic activity even further and unemployment will increase, thus reducing government income. Moreover, the rise in unemployment has to be paid for by the government to ensure that people do not descend into the sort of poverty that currently exists in some developing countries. Austerity, therefore, hits the economy with a double whammy, low income for the government and greater expenditure.

"The doctrines that are animating core economic policies [on] both sides of the Atlantic are in fact absolutely bonkers", so said Paul Krugman, the Nobel Prize-winning economist. "It is actually deeply destructive policy to pursue austerity in the midst of a depression". A collective madness seems to have gripped our politicians.

It is clear to anyone with an open mind, willing to be guided by reason, that severe cuts and austerity as a medicine to cure the patient are doing nothing of the sort; actually they are killing it. The evidence is all around us with the blighted lives of tens of millions, particularly the young, in the eurozone.

Of course, as pointed out by Paul Krugman, the eurozone has the additional problem of having "a single currency without a single government". Many of those governments, Greece, Ireland, Spain etc... are reluctantly being pushed into the economics of austerity and cuts by the German government.

It is galling that the UK government has embarked on this route voluntarily, as if this is some sort of a virility test to show that the "Brits" are more macho than the rest of Europe. Or could it be that the mantra of "shrinking the state" and "the market knows best" is trumping reason once again.

Running the economy of a country is not the same as running a household budget, Mr. Osborne. Look at the evidence; listen to the experts; perform another U-turn; change course and lay the foundation for a sustainable recovery, and with it improve the lives of millions.

 

Follow Adnan Al-Daini on Twitter: www.twitter.com/respect65

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Right wing politicians and commentators have always been able to appeal to the lowest instincts of human nature in a way that chimes with the aspirations of the many. Take, for example, the issue of t...
Right wing politicians and commentators have always been able to appeal to the lowest instincts of human nature in a way that chimes with the aspirations of the many. Take, for example, the issue of t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:11 AM on 06/05/2012
One cannot borrow ones way out of debt and sadly the credit card is maxed out. The fact is the UK's manufacturing base has declined significantly in the last 20 years and we no longer export as much as we did. We spend humungous sums on foreign policing, defence of the Realm, on overseas aid and welfare benefits. Throwing more cash at the problem and printing more, QE will simply delay the inevitable - a breakdown in society and our financial systems.

My father always said if you cannot afford to purchase it then do not buy it. The same is true of governments but unfortunately it is not directly their monies so they are not as careful. Just look at the PPI schemes which are becoming unaffordable.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Adnan Al-Daini
02:24 PM on 06/05/2012
The article is making the obvious point that the method chosen by the government, austerity and cuts, to cure the problem is not working. It has never worked according to Ha-Joon Chang - a Cambridge University Academic - (link to Guardian article) below. How can it be right that the solution, chosen by the elite, to this crisis involves the collective punishment of almost the entire population, apart that is, from the “moneymen” who caused it in the first place? I agree entirely with your point regarding the decline of the manufacturing base of the country. It is real engineering that creates wealth. Not financial engineering.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jun/04/austerity-policy-eurozone-crisis
05:25 PM on 06/05/2012
You forget the elite you refer to happen to be the persons we democratically elected for the next 5 years to guide us through this financial crisis which I agree was not of the making of the majority of the people. However, penalising the moneymen and the elite will demonstrably not resolve the problem when we are forced to borrow £1 for every £6 we spend. In the short term we need to curtail State expenditure, cut Government overheads wherever possible and make the things people overseas wish to buy. Sadly, no government will be able to transform the economy overnight or replace the manufacturing output now so desperately needed even were they to loosen the purse strings as many of their detractors would have us do. it is simply Punch and Judy politics by the Labour opposition who many would say led us into this.