Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alastair Campbell

GET UPDATES FROM Alastair Campbell
 

How Red Nose Day Is Improving Mental Health Services in Ghana

Posted: 12/03/2013 23:00

In 25 years, Comic Relief and its famous Red Nose have helped to raise £600million which has been used to help millions of people both in the UK and Africa. On a trip to Ghana earlier this year I met some of the most recent beneficiaries, as the country struggles to address growing need for psychiatric services.

It is hard enough campaigning for mental health services in the UK, where the government's austerity programme means they are going to the back of the queue again, as psychiatric care is not quite as 'sexy' as cancer, children's services or even accident and emergency. Recently I protested that two of the four emergency centres in Camden, North London, where I live, are closing. But compare and contrast with a country of 25million people, which has just three psychiatric hospitals, and just a dozen trained psychiatrists compared with 46,000 'traditional healers.'

That country is Ghana, in so many other ways one of Africa's success stories. But they know that when it comes to looking after the most vulnerable people in their midst, they have a long way to go. On the day I visited one of those three hospitals, Accra psychiatric hospital, it was impossible to be anything other than shocked, but also in awe of the handful of doctors and the smartly dressed nurses doing their best in difficult circumstances. A children's ward largely made up of mute, seriously disturbed youngsters, some of them dumped on the doorstep by their parents. A men's ward where dozens of 'ordinary' patients mingled with dozens more sent by the courts for assessment, one of whom had been there since the '80s on a murder charge. A women's ward where new admissions mixed with women, some naked, others aggressive - there had been a murder three days earlier - for whom the hospital was likely to be 'home' for years to come.

Even using words like 'ward' risks giving an inaccurate picture. To a Western mind that conjures up shiny floors, beds with sheets and pillows, and machines humming. There was none of that. There were hundreds of patients and small teams of nurses doing their best to look after them. There seemed to be enough medication, but it was hard to imagine how the doctors and nurses could do much more than sedate and calm. On the day we were there, chief psychiatrist Dr Akwasi Osei, said he and a colleague might see as many as 75 patients individually, in between actually running the place, and acting as an advisor to the government. At a second of the three hospitals, Pantang, Polish-born doctor Anna Puklo-Dzadey, with 300 inpatients and around 100 outpatients daily, said they ran to stand still. 'It is hard to do more than that.'

But the government is trying to move in the right direction. They have passed a Mental Health Act, which both Dr Osei and Dr Puklo-Dzadey say has the potential to transform services. 'Implement the Act, implement the Act, implement the Act,' says Dr Osei when I ask what one thing could make the most difference. Dr Puklo-Dzadey says 'the Act is a great thing in that it shows they understand the need for change. But without the resources to make the change real, we will continue to run to stand still.'

The scale of the challenge, not just in terms of the services, but also attitudes, can hardly be overstated. 'Even some doctors believe mental illness is contagious,' says Peter Badimak Yaro, director of the mental health charity Basic Needs Ghana, 'or caused by witchcraft, or sins in a past life. The reason there are so many traditional headers and so few real psychiatrists is that those attitudes are deep rooted in some parts of the country.'

At a Basic Needs self-help group for mentally ill women in Nima, Accra, we hear from schizophrenics who say they are shunned, and epileptics who say their problems are exacerbated by the fact that many think if you touch an epileptic, you will catch the illness. One after another, the women explain how the self-help group has given them a support network they lacked before. 'We look out for each other, make sure we take our medication, feel stronger for knowing there are other people in the same situation,' said Leyla Suraka, 53, a schizophrenic who went ten years without treatment.

Several have stories of the so-called prayer camps, where instead of medication and therapy, treatment is often made up of beatings, fasting, exorcisms and being tied to tree trunks to prevent escape. It will be hard to break down the attitudes, but again, the government is trying. Nana Oye Lithur, a human rights campaigner, has been appointed by the new president to a new position of minister for gender, children and social protection. She intends, as part of the social protection brief, to ensure the prayer camps are properly regulated and inspected.

'Mental health has been neglected,' she says. 'The stigma and discrimination prevent people from accessing proper care. It will take time to turn it round, but we can.'

The small beginnings of one self-help group have now grown. There are 193 of them. Eight drama groups perform plays about the main mental illness to dispel some of the myths. But Basic Needs Ghana also provide direct support for the medical services people require, with more than 20,000 people having benefited from their work. I spent a morning at a polyclinic where men, women and children queued in the heat to see two nurses. It is basic care, but it is care nonetheless.

As to what this has to do with the good people of Britain, the answer is simple - you help to pay for it. Basic Needs Ghana, and the Mental Health Society of Ghana, are part funded by Comic Relief. As Red Nose Day comes around again, there will be the usual mix of extraordinary generosity, and cynicism about whether the money actually does any good. Compassion fatigue is perhaps inevitable when so many give so much to so many causes. But if anyone reading this feels the compassion fatigue setting in as the Red Nose films come across their screens, try to remember people like Memunata Sale, who was given money for a sewing machine so she could make clothes and earn what she needs to look after her sick father. People like Asibi Nabase, 39, who is visibly ill, but whose mother says she finds sanctuary in the self-help group meetings. People like Ernest Appiah, 38, who was rescued from a prayer camp, treated by nurses, and now has a job in a bank. People like Dickson Dorcoo, 63, suicidally depressive and so ashamed of mental illness that his wife felt she had to hide him away until she heard about the polyclinic. People like Sahara Jubila, 30, who needs regular medication to live sufficiently well with her schizophrenia to be able to look after her eight children, People like Leyla, in and out of hospital for years, but who has not been back for five years. People like Francis Pii Kugbila, who was chained to a tree for two years until Basic Needs Ghana found him, and is now back at work as a teacher. So think of the children he is teaching too.

Things are in Ghana - indeed across Africa - are changing for the better and not just with regards to mental health. Access to education, clean water and mosquito nets are all making fundamental differences to the way millions of people live. As Red Nose Day marks its 25th year, I've seen the good work that is being done with the money it raises. There is still a long way to go, but Pii now has a future to look forward to, partly in thanks to someone donning a red nose or wearing pyjamas to work.

Alastair Campbell is an ambassador for the Time to Change campaign.

Red Nose Day is back on BBC One on Friday 15 March, tune in from 7pm to watch Comic Relief - Funny for Money. To find out more go to rednoseday.com

 

Follow Alastair Campbell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/campbellclaret

FOLLOW UK
In 25 years, Comic Relief and its famous Red Nose have helped to raise £600million which has been used to help millions of people both in the UK and Africa. On a trip to Ghana earlier this year I met...
In 25 years, Comic Relief and its famous Red Nose have helped to raise £600million which has been used to help millions of people both in the UK and Africa. On a trip to Ghana earlier this year I met...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 43
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:27 PM on 03/24/2013
Witchcraft believers... 'traditional healers'

... sounds a bit like parts of London after 13 years of Labour!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neil Christiansen
Dogs never bite me. Just humans
08:51 PM on 03/18/2013
Why is this man dragged out whenever an article dealing with mental health appears? Over the years he's been trying to present himself as a man-of-the-left whereas he is the equivalent of a Karl Rove to Tony Blair's George Bush. Surely the world has more suitable members who have suffered from depression?
10:56 AM on 03/18/2013
Mr Campbell, I'm more concerned with the health and well-being of people in this country and with the greatest of respect shouldn't we let Ghana sort out its own problems?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Eric Ehrmann
Blogs on sports and politcs from Brazil
09:24 PM on 03/17/2013
What better than to celebrate the order of the Red Nose than with some snooker and Claret at the original Ghana Club, but alas, it is but a legend now

There ae two sides to the story here.This one, http://www.mentalhealthaidghana.org/

and this one... http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-19836287

Even an old boy who ate too miuch yellow cake at the Fettes dining room can sort this one out.
08:02 PM on 03/17/2013
You really are pathetic Huff Post! You won't post comments you disagree with will you? And you're an American company as well. The home of free speech when it suits you!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richie2012
Your micro bio is empty.
07:28 PM on 03/17/2013
Will someone from the Left, who has an appropriately large social conscience, please tell me why I should wake up in the morning and be pleased that mental healthcare in Ghana is being supported by the UK when 1,200 UK citizens were (and possibly still are) needlessly left to die in a place they were supposed to be safe in? I just don't get it. Perhaps it is my heartless brutish right wing nature but I'd rather we took care of our own. Is it the Left's version of projecting power abroad? The right do it through Vanguard Class nuclear submarines. The Left through social health intervention. Both can claim, Britain is still a world player (which, dear American cousins, is still true). But something is going to have to give and I feel safer at night knowing that we have 4 Vanguard Class nuclear subs that - whilst in harbour at Portsmouth - can hear a Destroyer leave port in New York. Or for that matter, any port in Western Russia (no offer Vladimir).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treborc
once Labour now none voter...
12:06 PM on 03/18/2013
I suspect I'm to the left and to be honest I cannot answer you, what I can say is that Campbell is not to the left he is another of those unelected hangers on which Labour seem to have plenty off, unelected and worth nothing. Not forgetting he now works for Blair faith aid charity or he did.

I cannot answer why in the UK people with mental health are out on the streets and not in care or hospitals, I suspect it's the cost.

I can say not to long ago a program on TV spoke to a politician in African who proudly stated the poor will always be poor, because unlike him he knew how things worked so would be rich, while he was talking the camera zoomed into a pile of sacks hidden in the back ground by a large tarpaulin which stated food aid, later on it was said the MP had been arrested for selling food aid to the people we had given it to.

I have no answers but it maybe why I only give not to the British red cross the Salvation army for helping people on the street, and I gave to the red nose this week. but not nearly as much as I use to.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richie2012
Your micro bio is empty.
01:14 PM on 03/18/2013
"later on it was said the MP had been arrested for selling food aid to the people we had given it to."
 
Staggering. Clealry this is not a Left Right thing. Seems to be a "Sense" "Nonsense" thing. Nonsense seems to cross the political divide.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neil Christiansen
Dogs never bite me. Just humans
08:41 PM on 03/18/2013
You're comparing apples with pears, and to an extent your points, valid as they are, don't make much sense together.

But to denigrate mental health, which even in Ghana (& the fact that part of the reason why the UK is such an important and rich country is that it siphoned wealth out of countries of the ex-Empire) is a better use of 'our; money than selling them 4 Vanguard Class nuclear subs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richie2012
Your micro bio is empty.
10:23 AM on 03/19/2013
Sorry, I do not buy that "siphoned wealth out of countries" argument. I have never seen much valid evidence to support it. On the contrary, we built India's national transport system and their textiles industry. Whilst India was in British ownership we allowed India to dwarf our own world beating textiles industry. It became a major earner for India after independence. We screwed ourselves but it makes me proud that we helped them. Hong Kong - we built that place into a jewel then handed it back to China. Zimbabwe? Screwed now. It was beautiful under our ownership and under Cecil Rhodes (as Rhodesia). Indeed, we handed these countires back because we could not afford not keep them - why would we hand back a country that is supplying us with wealth???? As for the subs - you carry on your mission. We need people like you in the world. You genuinely make it a better place. But without people like me, protecting people like you, both you and I would be living in a much worse place.
02:38 PM on 03/17/2013
Also left out of the above article Ghana has some the biggest oil finds in Africa (6th largest) . Its oil revenue for this year alone is over $580 million.
02:33 PM on 03/17/2013
The problem with handing over Aid to African countries is that the place is full of corruption something Mr Campbell doesn't mention. Yes Ghana is a poor country but the fact remains there is money, but it just doesn't filter down to the little people instead the people in power depend on western Aid in which to do their work for them.
Do a google on; Ghana spends $1.4m on gold medals
to see what I mean.
01:53 PM on 03/17/2013
Hey,
Cherie Blair and Alistair Campbell both on the same page!! How nice - just like the bad old days having these self-servers trying to influence the masses....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:21 PM on 03/17/2013
When GPs sign people off work due to depression they ask the patient if they want the actual diagnosis put on the med cert.

That is because stigma exists.

Would you like to comment on the topic rather than its poster (especially when the 'influence the masses' is in both this and CB's column about empathy for others)?
05:25 PM on 03/17/2013
No but I'll happily reply to you.... "When GPs sign people off work due to depression..." - you done a survey? Or was it just yourself? I am only too aware of the stigma of depression.  I also don't like CB - she and her husband just love the limelight. Anyomne who defends CB is probably an aquaintance of hers and therefore has a distorted view of the world. Each to their own view, ma cherie!  
05:38 AM on 03/14/2013
I'd rather be tied to a tree in Ghana that have to languish under the care of the inescapable UK Mental Health system where CTOs have transferred the uncheckable, unlimitable power of the modern day omnipresent shrink.
07:36 PM on 03/13/2013
What awful people you all are. Given that the EU and UK effectively price Emerging Economies out of the global market, depriving the nations of any hope of positive growth, don't you think we as consumers of other peoples' anguish should do something in return? Possibly one of the only redeeming qualities of most world religions is charity.

And before any of you start going on about 'charity begins at home', how many of you have been down to Centrepoint? How many of you volunteered at a soup kitchen? How many of you voted for better mental health care in your own communities? Or did you vote Conservative?

As someone below posted, caring for someone at home doesn't stop you from caring for your neighbour.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edgar H
Keep the Press free!
07:47 AM on 03/17/2013
I'm caring for a load of unwanted scroungers, so I guess this ones up to you.
Fakestinian
If you think your sword is too short,take a pace f
08:00 AM on 03/17/2013
So it's our fault that these countries are failures?
Newsflash......it's down to them!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:55 PM on 03/17/2013
The other end of your assessment of the poor's predicament means that you regard your own situation, born (presumably) in to this comparatively strong country, allows you the credit for it?
Birthright eh?
Sense of entilement (rather like Cameron's and Osborne's et al re inheritance)?

Our forefathers worked and explored and received education and benefit via our wonderful inventors of the past and WE own their credit?

Got yer ..... :-s not. You're the gift that keeps on giving, on whatever topic.
11:16 AM on 03/13/2013
It is about time the comic relief funds started to help those in distress in this country. Thousands short of food and having to rely on Food Banks, and we raise more money to send abroad?????????????? Sheesh, hav'nt they had enough foreign aid out of us already. I for one will not support comic relief if the money is going out of the country. Lets start to support our own.........PLEASE>
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treborc
once Labour now none voter...
12:45 PM on 03/13/2013
Yes well said
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:13 PM on 03/13/2013
Donors know fine well that funds are spent abroad as well as at home.

The £12 per person as described in the article sounds like money well spent to me, especially if it enables patients to become more confident and independent.
10:50 AM on 03/13/2013
This is an important issue. In 2008 I was volunteering in Ghana. Through the programme a number of volunteers were placed in a boarding school for mentally ill children. I went along on a day off and was thoroughly shocked by the conditions there. Fevered, distracted, the children did seem, on the whole, happy and kind, but some were seriously ill and some aggressive (I was bit, though not hard enough to cause concern). The worst was when I was told that though the school is not officially open year round, they have to operate as such since many families never return to collect their children, there is such a stigma against having mental illness in the family. The most vulnerable people are often the easiest to overlook.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treborc
once Labour now none voter...
12:51 PM on 03/13/2013
I think we have all seen and remember the harm and abuse of the mentally ill within the UK, do not need to go to Africa to watch patients being abused.
01:25 PM on 03/13/2013
Well, while I agree, you do in a way illustrate my point. We have all SEEN and REMEMBER the harm and abuse of the mentally ill in the UK. Of course this should be corrected. I was merely recalling a personal anecdote this article reminded me of and observing that the "Africa" we are often presented with consists of much more diverse and much deeply vulnerable people. Incidentally, I do not think you need to stop caring about Britain's mentally ill to be able to care about those in Ghana, or any and everywhere for that matter.
04:03 PM on 03/13/2013
New years day on the beach in Durban, google it. Multiple thousands of Black Africans hit the beach, you cant see the sand for people, a few of those died if I remember right it was 12 people, there were multiple rapes, robberies and at the end of the party 30 plus children had to be taken into care by the authorities, a month later only three had been claimed. The local authority were then left with a cleanup operation, tons in rubbish was collected by the workers but due to the amount of faeces and its health implications it was deemed more appropriate to continue the cleanup with bulldozers to basically turn over the beach. I've been to Africa on several occasions, various countries, working a real job, and I feel absolutely zero sympathy for these people, they do not like us and show it, only with outstretched palms the volunteer brigade cannot see it, try volunteering around the UK, we have masses of homeless with mental health issues left on the streets to die here, but for the likes of you I suppose its got to be sunny with black babies or abandoned kids before you take any notice, stuff Africa.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
10:08 AM on 03/13/2013
£600 million to help 50 million people = £12 million /person.
25 Million in Ghana, are the other 25 Million in the UK?
In what way imaginable is £12 million / person value for money?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
treborc
once Labour now none voter...
12:51 PM on 03/13/2013
Your forgetting the back handed payments to the politicians in Ghana
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:40 PM on 03/13/2013
Oh well, I'll try again :-s

The presence of the word 'million' after both the figures 600 and 12 mean your cost per person is out one million fold.

This time definitely funny ;-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
06:12 AM on 03/14/2013
I know...I know.... been a busy day and my head was up my ar*e. Apologies.