YOUNG VOICES

Conservative MP Alec Shelbrooke Just Compared Unpaid Internships To Slavery

'We have heard these arguments before when we were banning the slave trade.'

01/11/2016 14:05 | Updated 16 November 2016

A Tory MP has caused uproar after comparing unpaid internships to slavery, saying young people are “forced” to work for free. 

Alec Shelbrooke, who is set to introduce a Commons’ Private Member Bill to ban unpaid internships on Friday, made the comments on BBC’s Daily Politics programme. 

In a debate with Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) news editor Kate Andrews on the show, Shelbrooke said: “We have heard these arguments before when we were banning the slave trade.” 

John Stillwell/PA Archive
Alec Shelbrooke is set to introduce a Private Members Bill to the Commons on Friday to have unpaid internships banned 

Apparently quoting the views of Pimlico Plumbers CEO Charlie Mullins, Shelbrooke continued: “I think it is a form of slavery - we just had a modern slavery act. You are asking people to work for free. 

“They are being forced to volunteer their time.”  

The Elmet and Rothwell MP’s controversial comments led IEA’s head of public policy Ryan Bourne to start the hashtag “voluntary activities Alec Shelbrooke compares to the slave trade”.  

He also commented on Shelbrooke’s “chutzpah”, accusing him of trying to frame himself as the “freer of intern slaves”, despite wanting to limit what the poor can spend their benefits on. 

Others also shared their outrage at the comparison between work experience placements and the slave trade. 

 

However, some took Shelbrooke’s side in the debate, including former Great British Bake Off finalist Richard Burr, who said the MP “spoke well” on the issue. 

Commentators have said it is unlikely Shelbrooke’s bill will be passed, but employment minister Damian Hinds confirmed on Sunday that the government is separately considering making the controversial work placements illegal.  

If the change is made, companies will be forced to pay interns the minimum wage. While some have supported the move, others have argued this will mean fewer business will offer work experience opportunities. 

Suggest a correction
Comments

CONVERSATIONS