Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gareth Edmundson

GET UPDATES FROM Gareth Edmundson
 

Poverty in America. The Silent Scandal of 6 November 2012

Posted: 06/11/2012 00:00

46.2 million Americans live in poverty. This represents 15% of the population. Give or take a million, that's about the same population as Spain.

The biggest economy in the world, the global wealth creator that is the United States of America is effectively living with country the size of Spain of people who are below the poverty line, living on a household income of $23,021 for a family of four. Of the 46.2 million, six million live on nothing more than the basic benefit of food stamps which provides an income of $6,300 for a family of three. Bear that in mind next time you're in the supermarket trying to decide whether you should spend more on the cheeky Chablis over the basic Calpol for adults (pinot grigio). The Obama and Romney campaigns have spent $2.6 billion on their campaign. If that was given to the poorest 6 million, each one of them could have received a $450 gift to get them through the winter.

But by listening to Romney and Obama on the campaign trail these statistics never get an airing. I checked recent speeches that both of them have given in their final smash and grab for votes and the word poverty barely even gets a look-in. On 2 November, in Paul Ryan's home state of Wisconsin, Romney's stump speech didn't even mention poverty once. And Obama, campaigning in the same state on 1 November mentioned it just once in his 25 minute address to the people of Green Bay.

If you look at both candidates' websites you find lots on the economy, jobs and healthcare but, again, almost nothing about poverty. This is all while 46.2 million Americans continue to go about their daily lives, the majority in low paying jobs, trying to stay afloat. A silent scandal, their plight ignored.

So what is the answer? Well, firstly, we need to talk about it more. We need to be relentless in the pursuit of this issue until the figure of 46.2 million is burnt onto the retinas of every single politician in America. They need to feel the weight of guilt from the stories of individuals, families and children in their districts and states from California to New York. People power is old fashioned but it's never been more necessary than now.

Allied to that, America must shift the debate. An answer needs be found to the problem of the gap between rich and poor getting wider and wider. Wages have stagnated for lower paid jobs whilst the top 1% of earners has seen their salaries sky rocket. I'm not advocating a drastic communist style solution to reset this but I do think that America must win the tax battle, once and for all, to make sure that the breaks don't keep being handed out to the wealthiest in the nation.

On jobs, politicians need to change their rhetoric. It is longer acceptable for an economy to create low-paid jobs that only keep families trapped in a never ending poverty cycle.

On the question of ideology more generally, politicians need to understand their decisions have huge impacts on the most vulnerable. They should give up using the poor as their favourite plaything. Romney's running mate Paul Ryan is one of the worst offenders for this type of almost evangelical ideological posturing. He claims that by cutting programmes like education, welfare and healthcare will actually help poor people to get out of poverty. Garbage. An honest, fair and pragmatic debate on solutions is needed (I'll believe that when I see it).

Finally, in capitalist economies, so much more can be done to create a better moral consciousness where the principles of giving and philanthropy become embedded in society. Giving should become an ever present and not just a reaction or an outpouring after a crisis.

So, not much then. But to start, on 6 November, when you're drinking your Chablis watching the election coverage, spare a thought for the 46.2 million people in America for which 6 November will be just be another day in their battle to survive.

 

Follow Gareth Edmundson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/garethedmundson

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
46.2 million Americans live in poverty. This represents 15% of the population. Give or take a million, that's about the same population as Spain. The biggest economy in the world, the global wealth ...
46.2 million Americans live in poverty. This represents 15% of the population. Give or take a million, that's about the same population as Spain. The biggest economy in the world, the global wealth ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Kerridge
That joke is not funny any more
10:48 PM on 11/06/2012
Excellent article Gareth. Ultimately politicians have the opportunity and I would argue an obligation to challenge the imperfections of whatever economic regimes they captin (capitalist or socialist) the fact that they often fail is down to the short termism because tackling poverty would not happen over night. It would also threaten the power balance. A free market economy needs poverty to inject fear as a motivator. In a similar vain extreme leftist governments need to inject fear through terror. Both are about control and protection of vested interests. The reality remains for many on the progressive left that a coherent alternative to free market economics is still required. Until we are able to 'socialise' our economics without terror and protect individuality and choice...then poverty will remain a disciplinary economic tool.
06:22 PM on 11/06/2012
Poverty is a major problem in this country as is the massive and rising gap between those who are at the top and those who are struggling - including the middle class. I don't have all the answers but I do know a few things. Continuing to provide tax breaks to the wealthiest individuals is NOT helping. The proof is in the fact that they have seen their incomes increase two, three, four and five fold during Obama's reign and this has NOT added jobs or an evening out of our economic situation. The wealthy need to be properly taxed and their tax loopholes closed. Banks were given a non-conditional ball-out and continue to hoard their money. They are not providing loans to even to well qualified individuals and companies. The government needs to intervene to stimulate lending as soon as possible. National healthcare is a requirement if we want to see this country in a recovery... and finally and most importantly, if we as citizens do not stand up and demand in as aggressive and visibly manner as legally possible exactly what we want from our government - nothing will change.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bakutin
Civil engineer and social libertarian
05:31 PM on 11/06/2012
Deindustrialization has been the main factor driving poverty in the US. Not everybody can be doctors, lawyers, or stockbrokers. Some people have to make things for a living and get a decent job without requiring a college education. They also need to have labor unions to protect them to make sure the employers don't exploit them.
02:46 PM on 11/06/2012
Parties & Presidents in Government are destined to disappoint.
02:41 PM on 11/06/2012
Wage stagnation is one of the worst problems of this period of recovery. In my case, I started working with a company at the end of 2007. I then struggled with them through the recession, the whole time grateful I had a job. Despite modest growth through that period, the company did not give raises, citing the recession the whole time. Managers were also giving us the impression that we were "lucky" to still have a job, which discouraged any complaining.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allene Stucki
02:37 PM on 11/06/2012
Poverty is a relative thing. We define poverty as income of $23,000 or less. There are millions of people in the world who never earn $23,000 in their entire lives. 80% of Americans "in poverty" have air conditioning, and 1 or more cars or trucks. We lament the "millions of American kids who don't have enough food to eat", but almost all of them are overweight. Again, poverty is all relative.
11:00 PM on 11/05/2012
As a person with a masters in social work, worked in the "hood", knows all about food stamps, welfare and the employment index; I believe it goes deeper. NY times, addresses this in "Empire of the In Between. Technology has taken away so many jobs it has destroyed America. All in the name of money. A person on welfare gets little, state by state case. When they get a job, assistance gets pulled and it is back to square one. The obstacles to overcome are so vast, that to make it out, is amazing and rare. People speak as if knowledgeable about the system when they have no clue. People are on food stamps because the government has done nothing to create jobs, besides sit on their hands and talk about abortions. All in the name of money, ALEC. Florida and AZ are considering a 3 dollar decrease in minimum wage. Everything is going up, those added fees. for what? In AZ a jail tax is on the water bill. State laws are being amended at a clipped rate. People who do still have money can't afford to buy food as food prices keep going up. Money to be made in poverty. With regards to education, just put people back to work. Plenty of knowledge out there to rebuild America and Lord knows it needs help. We are not all the same, or will robotics replace more jobs. One book I would recommend is, "And Never Stop Dancing,", Gordon Livingston.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:12 PM on 11/05/2012
Viable plan to end poverty: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcNA8dvc6Uc
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ZombieSM
Don't blame me I voted for Dr. Jill Stein
08:48 PM on 11/05/2012
Gareth,

If our government would actually redo the poverty index numbers, the same ones they've been using since 1965, peoples heads would explode in America.

There's a reason they won't.

The "little people " would revolt if they knew the truth.
08:33 PM on 11/05/2012
Reelect Obama and give him a Dem congress. That's the only way poverty will be impacted. Mitt has told us whom he favors, and it isn't the poor.
08:19 PM on 11/05/2012
Under the current administration, the number of people on food stamps has grown from 33 million to 46 million. Another four years of that growth would give us 66 million – a staggering 20% of the US population -- on food stamps. We have entered a food stamp economy, not a growth and jobs economy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gibranII
seeking peace through equality
10:27 PM on 11/05/2012
Im sorry to break it to you. . that is a direct result of a new economy that is evolving before our eyes and there is no quick fix unless you rigged it to begin with..Yes food stamps are up..because people are hurting.. so look at the policies that were there 10 years ago..and the rewards for sending jobs overseas... you blame our president.. he is only a small variable.. blame the firms that offshores our jobs.. blame the stockholders that insist on profits unimaginable, blame the owners of businesses that is sitting the election out waiting to get Romney is to deregulate even more practices.. this blaming only the president is near sighted.
10:19 AM on 11/06/2012
Capitalism few want more & only works for the few & the few want more & more each day !
10:23 AM on 11/06/2012
[Complete typo disaster in previous comment!] What I meant to say was: Capitalism only works for the few & the few want more & more each day !
05:56 PM on 11/06/2012
One would think with all the money spent on programs to help the poor since President Johnson's War on Poverty, we would have solved this problem. The more money we spend, the worse the problem becomes.
08:11 PM on 11/05/2012
Hey Gareth, I will agree poverty is an issue. However, Let us take into account the myriad of reasons poverty exists. I.E., Some people or families fall into poverty for reasons involving layoffs or lack of qualified experience/advanced education to make it to the next rung in the ladder of success. Couple that with rising prices on everything essential to day to day living and the result can be detrimental to getting ahead financially and being self sufficient. But this is a common existence for many families around the world. TRUE poverty can be summed up by an across the board lack of family structure/guidance, having children that cannot be supported,lack of education opportunities, minimal community support. Life deals a crappy hand, some overcome but for those who don't what is to become of them? A lot of what happens to us is based on self worth and what we want to happen for us, even after tragedy or a set back. This is not an across the board truth but just saying that poverty/not poverty is a matter of opportunity, decisions, and personal effort. I hope people in a bad situation know they can make good decisions and make a better way for them and their loved one's.
11:50 AM on 11/06/2012
Beautifully put but surely true poverty is struggling on a daily basis to find enough food to eat..