Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Laura Williams

Why Is Eat Less, Move More Still Considered To Be So Un-Sexy?

Posted: 12/08/11 12:45

A features editor called me the other day: "Laura, can you just give me a tasty sound bite about why calorie counting doesn't work?"

I paused momentarily with this horrible quandary: to turn down a mention in a major glossy in a tough economic climate vs. doing a U-turn on my ten year,'eat less, move more' belief. "But it does work", I ended up saying, "And diets work. Returning to your previous, excessive eating pattern and piling it all back on in a feast or famine frenzy is what doesn't work." Not to worry, there'll be other mentions, I'm sure.

I've lost count of the number of times over the last decade I've been told that 'eat less, move more' isn't quite sexy enough as a concept. On occasion, I've even toyed with the idea of doing a career U-turn and jumping on a '12-hrs-a-week-of-crazy-living-room-leg-swinging-exercise + no-carbs-after- ten-past-eight' bandwagon so I can gain many more column inches/mentions. For some reason people don't want to read that eat less, move more works - and work well it does. This baffles me because the stuff that makes headlines and grabs people's attention is infinitely harder. To my mind, getting takeaway/snack-savvy, being accountable to yourself for your daily food intake and upping your calorie burn during the course of your daily routine, is infinitely more do-able, sustainable (and rewarding, actually) than embracing a diet and exercise regime that allows for no human impulse. If you're contemplating one of the current popular plans or 'methods', you can forget a mini Starbucks splurge after a tough meeting; there'll be no nicking a finger of your daughter's KitKat while you wearily rustle up dinner, and as for that oversized class of Rioja - forget it. You can have a green tea instead though.

This is not to deny that action needs to be considered for our big weight problem. A massive change in our lifestyle over the last 50 years or so has made a big impact on our calorie expenditure (the human body was, and still is, built for exercise) and an abundance of tasty, cheap and readily available food makes it a tough old mountain to contemplate climbing. But we're losing sight of the hows and whys as we try and make this stuff wacky and sell-able. When we should be concentrating on making the truth palatable and do-able, we're getting too waylaid with endless discussion of good carbs vs bad carbs; we debate whether vibrating platforms can take the place of a cheap set of dumbbells (only if you're Onassis with stacks of time on your hands); we gloss over the fact that food acts as a huge emotional crutch for many people, and we're omitting to say, "Hellooo, that muffin contains around a third of your daily calorie burn". As SHAPE magazine, the US health and fitness mag that offers sound diet and fitness advice, put it in one fabulous feature: "You ate it, now negate it". I have a dream whereby I'm running up and down the country waving a dumbbell and a thong in the air shouting, ""Downsize the burger and ditch the Spanx pants! I'm going to show you how to REALLY look good naked." I suspect this may remain a dream.

I am walking talking proof of practising what I preach. I'm a size 8 and I don't drink power smoothies for breakfast, nor have I inherited the DNA of a gazelle - my before and after pics are impressive. 70% of what I eat is good (i.e. evidence-based) calorie-counted nutrition. But I have been known to eat dolly mixture for breakfast - because I'm human; because I pound the streets of Tower Hamlets to keep cardiovascular disease and a bulging waistline at bay, and because I was brought up to believe that a little of what you like will do you no har

 

Follow Laura Williams on Twitter: www.twitter.com/laurafitness

A features editor called me the other day: "Laura, can you just give me a tasty sound bite about why calorie counting doesn't work?" I paused momentarily with this horrible quandary: to turn down a m...
A features editor called me the other day: "Laura, can you just give me a tasty sound bite about why calorie counting doesn't work?" I paused momentarily with this horrible quandary: to turn down a m...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
21:43 on 14/08/2011
Why should something need to be sexy before it is something you should do?
01:24 on 13/08/2011
The fact is that eating less and moving more works for reducing overall weight people who have zero insulin resistance or who are very young, and often for males. However, eating less and moving more is a form of starvation that ruins your metabolism, so by doing so over time you destroy your metabolism. This is why yoyo dieters find it progressively harder to lose weight. The only real cure is to eat in such a way as to not inhibit the ability of fat to be released from storage in the body. If there is insulin in your blood, fat cells are locked shut. It's as simple as that. As soon as your blood has no insulin in it, the fat cells begin to open up and release stored fat. The only way to get the insulin out of your blood is to not eat any sugars, whether they are simple or complex carbs. You don't need to diet. You don't need to exercise. You just need to get the insulin out of your blood. If you keep your blood insulin free most of the time, then you will lose fat deposits.
photo
liberalsrheros
GOP's voter suppression, an insult to veterans.
20:27 on 13/08/2011
i believe you have a point about insulin and fat. i also believe that you toss aside eating less and exercising more too easily. combine eating less and exercising to keep metabolism up while staying away from carbs that spike insulin and you have a path to burning fat losing weight and satisfying appetite without starvation.
23:57 on 13/08/2011
Thanks for your comment. Eating less is a form of starvation and is known to slow the metabolism. Using exercise as a way to boost calorie deficit (a weight loss tool that consistently fails to achieve lasting results) is just another way of starving the body of the calories it needs to function. In my opinion, which is based on much hard earned experience and much interaction with others who are or have been significantly overweight, exercise is a method of achieving physical fitness rather than a method of weight loss, and the two are usually conflated when they should not be. I believe that morbidly obese people should rest up while they are losing weight, and that it's not until the metabolism is achieving normality, usually when there are less than 30 pounds left to lose, that exercise becomes a good idea.
16:27 on 16/08/2011
wow...

"If there is insulin in your blood, fat cells are locked shut. It's as simple as that. As soon as your blood has no insulin in it, the fat cells begin to open up and release stored fat."

so when does that happen (no insulin being in your blood)? have you ever heard of fasting insulin levels?

"The only way to get the insulin out of your blood is to not eat any sugars, whether they are simple or complex carbs. "

what utter nonsense, you do know protein also spikes insulin levels, right?

"If you keep your blood insulin free most of the time, then you will lose fat deposits. "

no, you will lose fat by being in a caloric deficit
00:59 on 17/08/2011
Protein must be eaten in sufficient amounts for it to be converted to glucose. Most people who keep their blood insulin levels low move into a state of higher satiety and are unlikely to eat so much protein in a sitting as to cause an insulin spike. "Fasting insulin levels" are just that. If you fast you should have low insulin. I do suggest you read Taubes for some instruction on this. In the presence of insulin in the blood, a fat cell cannot release stored fat. Period. End of story.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
w84it
18:46 on 12/08/2011
I eat a balanced diet of proteins, fats, and carbs. Yes, carbs...mostly good, with a taste of bad every now and then! I'm nearly 40 and weigh nearly the same as I did in college. I'm lean, fit and very active.

Do I pay attention to what and how much I eat? You bet I do.
Does it work for me? Absolutely.
Is my diet sustainable? Well...20 years and going isn't half bad!
18:23 on 12/08/2011
All so very true, and much more refreshing than hearing about the latest fad! I wish you had column inches in the glossies to make everyone see that real dietary change not a short term fix works the best and is a lot easier and more fun to stick to!

Brilliant article :)