Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mary_McGill

GET UPDATES FROM Mary_McGill
 

Baby Wars: Should You Apologise for not Wanting Children?

Posted: 02/11/2012 23:00

During a recent panel discussion on an Irish television show, I spoke about not wanting children. The views of my fellow talking heads were mixed - one had just revealed she was expecting her first child - but almost all of them shared similar views and those who didn't were still supportive of mine. The open mindedness didn't last however. An irate caller lambasted me for getting married recently, demanding to know what on earth the point was when my partner and I weren't planning on becoming parents.

I responded by saying that I fell in love with my best friend and I wanted to make a solemn commitment to him in front of our friends and family. A wedding was a great way of doing that. I also said that in the 21st century, marriage is not the only environment in which to raise a family nor is it always the perfect one. What the caller thought of my reply I have no idea but her views are not unique. Not by a long shot.

Electing not to be a mother is often seen as an affront to the natural order, as if, simply having ovaries, you must use them. While I completely understand the urge to become a Mum, it is not something I have ever experienced. I know things change and people change but so far my feelings on the matter have remained the same as has my refusal to apologise for them.

For years I presumed that my take on parenthood would see me end up alone. Despite the emphasis on women as the gender who long for children, in my experience many, if not just as many, men experience a similar longing. When my relationship with my now husband got to the point where 'the future' came into the picture, I was sure the subject of children would be our undoing. There are certain things you can compromise on but having a family is not one of them. If one partner wants kids and the other doesn't, you'll soon discover that even love has its limitations.

Thankfully, my husband and I realised that not wanting kids was yet another thing we have in common, not because we dislike children in any way, we can definitely see the attraction, but because they are not for everyone. I can't imagine bringing a child into the world simply because that is what you're 'supposed' to do. Parenthood is the greatest and most daunting of jobs. It shouldn't be something you go into blindly. What it produces is far too precious for that.

Statistics show us that more and more women are choosing not to have children, for reasons that are as varied as the seasons. With that, one would hope the negative attitude towards those who opt out of parenthood, the idea that they are unnatural and selfish, will dissipate. Not wanting kids doesn't make you any less of a woman or a bad person. Talking about not wanting kids doesn't make you offensive, just honest. Not wanting kids doesn't automatically mean you dislike them. Having kids reluctantly, as a kind of 'just in case' policy is probably not the best idea.

Wanting a family or not should never be something we judge others on or take offense to. Everyone is entitled to make their own way in this world, to dream their own dreams. All that any of us can hope for is that we have the strength of character to stay true to who we are. In doing so, we pave the way for others to do the same, making our world a more compassionate and open place. Surely that's much better for all of us, children included?

 

Follow Mary_McGill on Twitter: www.twitter.com/missmarymcgill

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
During a recent panel discussion on an Irish television show, I spoke about not wanting children. The views of my fellow talking heads were mixed - one had just revealed she was expecting her first ch...
During a recent panel discussion on an Irish television show, I spoke about not wanting children. The views of my fellow talking heads were mixed - one had just revealed she was expecting her first ch...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 101
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:11 PM on 01/01/2013
I am in shock that other people can be offended at an individual or couple's choice to not have children. I mean, seriously - read that again: someone else can be offended because another human chooses not to pro-create. What does it actually have to do with them anyway? It baffles my mind and makes forming a response a tough task because it's just so utterly ridiculous.

I completely agree that not wanting children is not the same thing as not liking children. Being a parent and raising another human being into a hopefully well-rounded adult is about much more than 'liking' children. Someone might like to holiday in Spain, but that doesn't mean to say they want to commit to living there for the rest of their lives. I can barely believe I've had to use that analogy. Whew...

I genuinely hope people who find not wanting children to be in any way wrong or offensive are in the minority.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Ferris
01:08 PM on 11/06/2012
Who the hell cares? It is nobody's business whether someone else decides to have children or not.

Sidenote: we need to be having fewer children as is, I don't know if anyone's looked lately but there are just way too many of us. Perhaps couples should start leaning more toward adoption, i.e. giving a home to a child who needs it, rather than just making more people.
11:09 AM on 11/06/2012
No, you shouldn't, it's your choice - but maybe you should for some of your H*ffington colleagues articles over the years.
10:25 AM on 11/06/2012
I totally understand where you're coming from Mary. I feel exactly the same, and was also lucky enough to find a husband who agrees with me. After 20 years of women confidently telling me I'd change my mind, in my 40s it's becoming clear that other people don't actually know better what I think and feel! The extent of social pressure on childless women (not men, note) is bizarre, as if we are threatening something fundamental in society, as if they don't know what identity to assign us if we are not mothers. My brother actually told me my life was pointless and that I was a 'dried up old spinster'! On a planet that is vastly overpopulated, women like us should be valued, not pilloried.
10:44 PM on 11/05/2012
We have a right to choose whether we want kids or not, end of story, I dont dislike kids, but their not for me, what I do resent, is obsessed baby bores, assuming that there is something wrong with people who dont want them.
09:56 PM on 11/05/2012
How do you get so much copy out of a guff of air? Who cares whether or not you want children? It's your business and nobody else's. I can't stand all this hand wringing and soul searching. You're an adult. You have the right to make your own decisions and live with the consequences - whatever they may be - good or bad, and no, I'm not making judgements so don't read anything into that. It is totally your choice, your life and your decisions to make, but I will say one thing. Only women without children have the time and energy to worry about thoughts like this. Parents are too busy/ preoccupied/ tired to be bothered with any of it. One thing is for sure, the world won't grind to a halt because you don't want children. There's more than enough women who do so there's no need to pontificate or beat yourself up over it. Get on with your life and please find something more interesting than your own life and thoughts to write about.
09:09 AM on 11/06/2012
The fact is that a lot of women who don't want children DO come under a lot of pressure and flak from others - their own parents, families, friends, all kinds of people. I didn't want children when I was younger and I had no end of people queueing up to tell me I was wrong, as if it were any of their business what I did with my reproductive system.
As it happened, I did change my mind, and I had my son. And then everyone started asking if he was going to be the only one....And I said yes, and he was, and he is.
09:25 AM on 11/06/2012
Parents are too busy etc to be bothered with any of it? Really because in my experience it is parents who spend their very precious time telling those of us who don't have/can't have kids how we ought to have children even if it means going through years of medical treatment.

We are treated as people with an opinion less worth while by the media, just look at how many stories point out how many kids someone has despite it having nothing to do with the story. You have just compounded it with a low opinion of anyone with no kids who dares speak about other people's attitudes on this subject.

You yourself have chosen a name that reflects your status as a parent and yet denigrate this article as guff and tell the writer to get on with her life. Experiences that reflect those of a certain section of society are not guff just because you do not experience it yourself.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:26 PM on 11/05/2012
Good for you!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hucancum
07:03 PM on 11/05/2012
What is there to apologise for? In fact people with no children should pay less tax .
07:35 PM on 11/05/2012
My thoughts exactly...
10:28 AM on 11/06/2012
I think people who don't have children should have a big fat pension in recognition of all the money they save the state.
06:42 PM on 11/05/2012
If more people thought long and hard before procreating the world would be a far better place!
06:28 PM on 11/05/2012
Who would want kids in a time when all they can look forward to is a life less prosperous than we planned for them thanks to the Banks and Buiulding Societies who went all out on greed and we bailed out with our tax money and thanks to some pretty inept Government action now it will only get worse before it gets better
At least with Labour the deficit was coming down before the Libs and Cons cheated their way into power
04:04 PM on 11/05/2012
M FOSTER, YOU GO ON ABOUT THE WHITE RACE THEN YOU FINISH WITH A BIBLICAL QUOTE, KKK?
Well im a shaven headed,Ben Sherman wearing Chelsea fan who dont want kids, but you would be quitr pleased about that as my wife is an English born Bengali
09:19 PM on 11/07/2012
That does not impress me much but you having a Bengali wife is fine by me. As a matter of fact my family is mixed race, half from West Indian roots some generations ago. My father was Black as is my brother, my sister and myself are white. That does not prevent me from believing that the indigenous people of certain countries, having occupied those lands for 10's of thousands of years, should not have their race, culture, traditions, language, religion, etc, and rightful ownership protected and recognised. Be it Aborigine, Maori, American Indian, Chinese or whatever, You might not bother about the elimination of your race but others do. The Jews certainly do, they will not tolerate a Jew settling in Israel if married to a non-Jew. (See part 2 in reply to THINK BIGGER).
This comment has been removed.
03:26 PM on 11/05/2012
The way I see it, if you dont want kids thats great for everyone else.

Why have kids if you dont want them? No child would want to grow up with parents who resent them.
The world is over populated as it is, why add more?
The care system is over run as it is, so why add more unwanted children?

People who choose not to have kids, are better than those who just pop them out for the sake of it.
02:50 PM on 11/05/2012
Your loss Mrs Mcgill.My wife and i have had 3 children.Two grown up,one currently 9...i respect your decision..but for me there are atleast 3 people in the world who love me unconditionally,and three who are loved by me the same.I wouldnt have swapped the most sparkling of careers for one day with my children.I loved them when when they were babies when they were growing up and now im a grandad and looking towards the evening of my life.ill love them when im old a knackered and i pray they will love me and look out for me too.Mrs Mcgill theres a saying...on your death bed..no one says i wish i had spent more time in the office..To me lifes about loving and being loved..everything else is wrapping paper.To me a life without children is like going on holiday and staying on the plane after its landed.Oh..one last thing..the love you give your children is repaid a thousand times.
03:28 PM on 11/05/2012
Any one on their death bed will wish they had done something differently.
She may well be glad she didnt slave after a bunch of children who hardly ever called or visited for the last 15-20 years of her life.
05:43 PM on 11/05/2012
by and large if you raise people that dont come and visit you for the last 15 -20 years of your life you have no one to blame but yourself.when my parents wee old they sold their home,we sold our home,we pooled the money snd bought a bigger home and we all moved in together..they didnt go short of anything.
07:41 PM on 11/05/2012
What a dated attitude! One doesn't give to receive as that is not very loving now is it? Oh, and one last thing I know of people that have loved and done everything for their children only to be cast on the slagheap when they are older and of course that is not too mention the children that steal from their parents, the children that grow up to be in and out of prison and the one's that end up dead due to alcohol or drug abuse... not all children that are loved turn out loving themselves.....
08:59 PM on 11/05/2012
im old fashioned .i wont apologise for that..i like to hang on to values that genuinley have value rather than chase the next half baked idea dreamed up by some lonely half baked journalist.and yes your right one doesnt give to receive,but if one does have children one should strive to bring them up as loving decent kind generous people.its the circle of life.in this life there are two types of love.the love you die for,the love you feel with every ounce of your soul.real love.then theres the love thats all kisses and pressies and parties and empty and nothing behind it but an empty smile because you hearts desire is looking back at you in the mirror and you think you have fooled everyone but the only person your kidding is yourself.
This comment has been removed.