Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter G Tatchell

GET UPDATES FROM Peter G Tatchell
 

Ceasefire Will Only Hold if There Is Justice for Palestine

Posted: 22/11/2012 09:30

I have Palestinian colleagues in Gaza. They are democrats and human rights defenders who are critics of the Hamas regime and opponents of terror attacks on Israel. Some have been detained and tortured by the Islamists.

Together with much of the Gaza population, for seven days they cowered in fear of Israeli bombardment. Why were they - and so many other innocents - terrorised by the Jewish state on account of the crimes of Islamist extremists?

My heart goes out to all Israeli and Palestinian civilians who were caught in the cross-fire. The Gaza conflict has affected too many innocents on both sides.

Israel launched more than 1,500 airstrikes on Gaza, while Islamists fired over 1,000 rockets into Israel. At least 160 Palestinians were killed, including dozens of civilians, and five Israelis died too. A rather one-sided death toll. Nevertheless, I mourn all these deaths.

The traumatised victims include not only civilians who've lost loved ones or been injured but also everyone (millions of Palestinians and Israelis) who lived in daily fear of attack. The psychological and emotional strain was immense. No one should have to endure this unrelenting trauma - a trauma to which successive generations have been subjected for decades.

This is why it is so important to find a lasting peaceful solution that can ensure security for both Jews and Arabs.

While the Egyptian-brokered ceasefire is welcome, it will only last if the legitimate grievances of the Palestinian people are remedied. Similar ceasefires have failed in the past precisely because of a lack of progress towards a negotiated settlement that is fair to the Palestinians.

The Israeli seizure and occupation of Palestinian land, and the denial of a Palestinian state, are the root cause of the on-going conflict and the last week's flare up in Gaza. There will be no enduring peace without first securing justice for the people of Palestine.

A genuine injustice is what gives the Palestinian fanatics influence. While the injustice exists, they will continue to exploit it. Remedy the injustice and they will be sidelined.

This is a viewpoint shared by many Israelis and by many in the Jewish Diaspora. They reject the hardline stance of the current Israeli government. They, too, recognise that justice is a precondition for peace.

Most Palestinians would accept peace with Israel if they secured a just settlement.

The Palestinian people have a right to their own homeland - just like Jews. It is time to take serious steps to secure peace, justice, equality and security for all - Palestinians and Israelis - by means of two co-existing states based on the 1967 borders.

To this end, I have joined with more than 1.5 million other people (so far) to sign the Avaaz petition here.

It urges world leaders to press for an end to the Israeli occupation of Palestinian land, and for the recognition of an independent Palestinian state, as the most effective way to break the log jam in the stalled peace process.

While rocket attacks on Jewish civilians are absolutely wrong, Israel's escalation in Gaza risked sparking a major regional conflict, possibly involving Iran and its proxy, Hezbollah. This is not in the interest of the people of Israel, Palestine or the wider region.

Palestinians are justified to non-violently resist Israel's seizure of land, demolition of houses, destruction of crops and the killing of civilians. The divisive, sectarian wall and the building of illegal Jewish settlements on the West Bank undermines the prospects for peace and plays into the hands of Islamist extremists.

Israel's oppression of the Palestinians does not justify Islamists firing rockets into Jewish civilian areas. Nor do rocket attacks justify Israel's bombardment of Gaza and the consequent civilian deaths.

Israeli actions are tantamount to the terrorisation and collective punishment of the Gaza population, which is illegal under international law. The same is true of attacks on Israeli civilians by Hamas, Islamic Jihad and other Islamist terror groups.

The deliberate or reckless killing civilians is a war crime - whoever does it, for whatever reason. The human rights of both Israelis and Palestinians must be protected.

The cycle of attack and counter-attack, revenge and pay-back, is immoral and futile. Neither side gains. Insecurity is compounded and the seeds of further conflict are sown.

The Hamas regime in Gaza is guilty of serious human rights abuses against its own Palestinian citizens, including unfair trials, torture and executions.

See, as one example, the Human Rights Watch report: Abusive System: Failures of Criminal Justice in Gaza, October 2012.

Hamas has also sanctioned rocket attacks on Israeli civilians.

It is truly shocking the way some western pro-Palestinian, anti-war and left-wing groups variously defend or excuse Hamas. As well as being anti-Semitic, Hamas is an authoritarian, reactionary movement.

While people are right to be critical of Israel's stance towards the Palestinians, it is also important to defend Jewish people against Islamists and other anti-Semites.

Human rights are universal and indivisible. They apply to everyone, even perceived enemies. The lust for vengeance is self-defeating.

An-eye-for-an-eye leaves everyone blind.

Peter Tatchell is Director, Peter Tatchell Foundation: www.PeterTatchellFoundation.org

 
FOLLOW UK
I have Palestinian colleagues in Gaza. They are democrats and human rights defenders who are critics of the Hamas regime and opponents of terror attacks on Israel. Some have been detained and tortured...
I have Palestinian colleagues in Gaza. They are democrats and human rights defenders who are critics of the Hamas regime and opponents of terror attacks on Israel. Some have been detained and tortured...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 149
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
12:06 AM on 11/27/2012
There will never be peace because both sides are so bloody PIG HEADED.
The only way the Jews and the Muslims will stop killing each other is if the Jehovah Witnesses open a pig farm in Gazza
10:42 PM on 11/25/2012
So if you use the same logic that the Jews deserve Israel as their ""homeland" because they were driven away centuries ago then shouldn't we, the US, give this country back to the native Americans, basically the same thing was done to them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
03:28 AM on 11/25/2012
There will never be peace over this. Israel may believe that it is chosen by God. And it's supporters may like to think that they can change from Terrorists into victims but it doesn't work. There will be an almighty war in the middle east within the next 50 years which will benefit no one.
lastpost
see biography
05:32 PM on 11/23/2012
“There will be no enduring peace without”
perusing all the various song sheets being sung from. How many from either side are so influenced by received information, they’re incapable of challenging that conditioning? How many from either side don’t give credence to the conditioning, yet still have no intention of ever co-existing in peace? How many from either side would have to find some other outlet for their aggression, if peace became permanent? Etcetera, etcetera. Its not a matter of logic, but rather a function of the mentalities of those involved. Accommodating all understandings is impossible. The best chance may be to challenge all understandings. Demonstrate their shortcomings, and instil the realisation that all notions are flawed to a greater or lesser degree.

“The Palestinian people have a right to their own homeland - just like Jews”.
If possible, proving that its merely a lend-lease arrangement might give encouragement to grudging acceptance.

“the most effective way to break the log jam”
could entail clarifying the intentions of various parties. Covertly, complete control of the region may be the master plan/s. To address such a situation, a UN Dutch auction might be tried. Here is the plan. For each time period that passes without agreement, loss of land to a new UN administered buffer state will ensue.

“An-eye-for-an-eye leaves everyone blind.”
Unless it’s the god-given gift of a corneal transplant, that surpasses all considerations of ethnicity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
godsamyth
10:30 AM on 11/24/2012
Jews are a religion and no religions are entitled to homelands . For those jews from the US that is their homeland etc
10:52 PM on 11/24/2012
It seem only Jews are not allowed a state of their own. Fifty-six Muslim states is not a problem. No democracies among them. All theocracies persecuting religious minorities. Are you saying Islam is not a religion? It could be called a political system. You know something like communism or fascism.
11:49 AM on 11/23/2012
Or listen to what Pat Condell says about it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=QuVx_7ER09Y#!
11:46 AM on 11/23/2012
In 1948, instead of attacking Israel, the Palestinians could have welcomed the new state, and developed Palestine at the same time. In 2005 Israel uprooted its citizens and communities and synagogues in the Gaza Strip and LEFT. Israel no longer occupies Gaza! And what have we gotten since? A drastic rise in attacks. If the Palestinian leaders would finally come to their senses and recognize Israel, we finally WOULD be able to build a lasting peace and prosperity for ALL in this region! If the Palestinian government would spend its money on infrastructure and security for its people, instead of weapons to destroy us, we would not be in this situation. None of us!

"What was the real cost for not recognizing Israel in 1948 and why didn’t the Arab states spend their assets on education, health care and the infrastructures instead of wars? But, the hardest question that no Arab national wants to hear is whether Israel is the real enemy of the Arab world and the Arab people." This is a quote from an article in the "Arab News" written by ABDULATEEF AL-MULHIM. To read the entire article, go here: http://www.arabnews.com/arab-spring-and-israeli-enemy

If only his words were listened to, this region of the earth could be a paradise for us all.

A.R. who lives on the border of the Gaza Strip
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
godsamyth
10:32 AM on 11/24/2012
you are in the Palestinians homeland and you are part of the problem
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
03:29 AM on 11/25/2012
Defend the indefensible all you want and it will still be indefensible.
11:35 AM on 11/23/2012
The so called Palestinians are Semites just as the Israelis are (for the most part). You, like all the other apologists for the outrageous behavior of Arabs in general and Hamas in general ignore the fact that the two factors which caused the "refugee" problem were: The declaration of the Grand Mufti in Jerusalem in 1947/8 which incited all Muslims to rise up and murder all Jews and the fact that 80%+ of The Palestinian protectorate was designated as Arab Muslim Jordan. This is a country which like Tunisia took in these self exiling refugees and cared for them until their behavior forced their expulsion . Egypt has also suffered from these unlovely people.
In my many visits to that troubled land there were always Arabs employed in Israel despite their nasty habit of blowing up buses full of children. This has had to be reduced to only proven trustworthy people - a difficult and almost mutually exclusive situation.
I experienced at first hand the use of children as self propelled bombs and the wicked punishments handed out to the people who would not obey Hamas and their like.
You also do not mention that Hamas started it's Gazaian reign of terror by murdering the political opposition.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
virtusfides
12:35 PM on 11/23/2012
You have a troubled mind. Historically as well in reality.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norman Mitchison
10:16 AM on 11/23/2012
Arab states state their horror and aversion to terrorism so why do they support Hamas,a terrorist organisation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saint wright
Dyslexic old chippy
11:17 AM on 11/23/2012
as an oppressed people they might reguard them as freedom fighters?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
virtusfides
12:42 PM on 11/23/2012
Arab states support terrorist states (Dubai/USA) as well terrorist groups (Syria/Libya) But in all the oppose the most aggressive violent country that ignores over 120 UN resolution,(just paper to wipe yr bum with Israeli politician) refuse atomic control on their nuclear installation in Negev, something they demand for Iran while Israel has illegal nuclear weapons, Iran has not,has blocked in Gaza with only supplies allowed by Israel where even chocolate is not allowed for bomb making reasons???? where the homes and land of the West Bank Palestinians are taken and the people driven out, then you can ask what is horror and the reason to defend your self. Defending themselves is called by the West as being a terrorists, as we have seen by Occupy Wallstreet which demonstrators were arrested under terrorist laws.
10:16 AM on 11/23/2012
"..........it is so important to find a lasting peaceful solution that can ensure security for both Jews and Arabs." Genius. Why has nobody thought of this before?
This comment has been removed.
09:21 AM on 11/23/2012
What is Blair doing to reslove this issue apart from pocketing largs quantities of coin.
10:24 AM on 11/23/2012
How about grieving for a recently dead father? Would YOU put anything else before that, I know I couldn't and didn't.
09:21 AM on 11/23/2012
Why does nobody listen to the truth !!!...... ISRAEL have a 100% effective anti rocket defence system called phalanx supplied by the USA. They also have their own version called iron shield. the ONLY reason a small number of hamas rockets are getting through to israel, is because the israeli Government are purposfully switching off the defence systems at various times of the day !.. This is a familiar propaganda tactic used to build support with the Israeli people for the planned invasion of Gaza.

This whole situation is a David and Goliath type scenario, with David living on land that Goliath wants to take !.
09:32 AM on 11/23/2012
So it is the fault of Israel that rockets are been fired at them for not switching on their defence shield? This is an interesting take on the conflict.From now on when a school bully now punches someone in the face it will be the fault of the bullied child for not defending himself properly.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
virtusfides
12:49 PM on 11/23/2012
May be ridiculed but it is a established fact!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YESYOUARE
11:58 AM on 11/23/2012
The Truth might be out there but it certainly isn't in your post. Bless
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saint wright
Dyslexic old chippy
09:14 AM on 11/23/2012
On top of all this Haredi men are becoming more aggressive to ordinary Israelis attacking little school girls by throwing excrement at them for wearing a school uniform that exposes the lower leg and abusing Arabs that inflames an already volatile situation, and even forcing women to sit at the back of buses away from the bearded ones. The penny is beginning to drop that if this is allowed to continue Israel faces become the mirror image of the backward intolerant jihadist states that are its enemies in the Muslim world.

There is real resentment among other Jews who pay their welfare bills and suffer their abuse and have to serve in the IDF. If they cut the allowances to the Haredi and throw them off stolen Arab land in the West Bank and try to make them serve in the Military, the next conflict in Israel could well be a civil war?
With Israel fast running out of friends for its massacres in Gaza, torture and illegal imprisonment of Arabs without trial and continuing to steal Arab land in the West Bank and Jerusalem for homes exclusively for Jews, Herzl’s dream could be coming to a very bloody end. Shalom.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
virtusfides
12:51 PM on 11/23/2012
Can we please make an distinction between Israel the home land for Jewish believers and the Jewish believe worldwide. Israel is a country forced by the actions of Zionist in Britain and US. Jewish is a believe just as Christians and Muslims.
07:27 AM on 11/23/2012
Israel exists only because of the UK and the US. It defends itself only because the US and, I'm assuming, the UK provide them latest technology weapons.

We are so hypocritical it is unfunny. We attack other countries for trying to get "weapons of mass destruction" when we are the ones who invented, and continue to invent them. But, we don't allow other countries to have them unless, irrespective of political philosophies, they provide us with something we want in return.
09:11 AM on 11/23/2012
jrainspe,
There is a very good reason why Israel needs to be armed to the teeth as you call it and that is that they are fighting for their very existence.How many times have they been involved in wars with Arab countries, wars that they didn't start? If they were not well armed they would no longer exist. Furthermore how can there be peace when other Arab states mainly Iran, ( who are probably supplying Hamas with arms) have openly stated that they want to wipe Israel off the face of the earth.Would you not want to be well armed in the face of this.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
godsamyth
09:59 AM on 11/23/2012
The only jews with the right to exist there are Palestinian jews the rest do not belong there, the world is changing and time is not on Israels side ,every dog has its day
12:59 AM on 11/23/2012
This is a very good post and your eye for eye comment is right although it is understandable that owing to constant bombardment and the slaughter of civilians with the final straw being the slaughter of the Palestinian Scientist then Ahmed Jabari Palestines military commander who was blasted to smitherines whilst driving. These asaults must be viewed as causing destabilization to Palestinian security beyond endurance. Also it has been reported that former prime minister Ehud Olmert had killed over 1,400 Palestinians and injured and caused to be displaced many more.