Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Stevenson

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Stevenson
 

Policing Occupy London is About Intimidation

Posted: 17/10/11 01:00 BST

Standing on the steps of St. Paul's Cathedral, a young man addressed the 'Occupy London Stock Exchange' protest on Saturday. "There is a police line to my left", he said as the crowd repeated his words in unison to create an 'echo microphone' that allowed everyone to hear, "and we must be careful not to let it move forward." His warning proved prescient.

When the demonstration first assembled outside St. Paul's, it was largely unhampered by policing. I had arrived two hours earlier, and had witnessed the closing of Paternoster Square, the intended site of the occupation. But while the square, a private development and home to Goldman Sachs, was blockaded by police officers and horses, the assembly at St. Paul's was left alone. After it became obvious that Paternoster Square was unreachable, this became the new site of the occupation.

By 1pm, police had begun to line the edge of the crowd. Most were engrossed in the 'general assembly', a mostly democratic system of organisation by vote and hand-signals (wave one hand for 'yes', cross both hands for 'no'). It was already clear that the police intended to form a kettle, and form a kettle they did.

The protest was predictably peaceful. When the crowd first attempted to enter Paternoster Square, a small chant of "get those animals off those horses" briefly emerged (referring to mounted officers), but this was shouted down. "The police are not the problem", one man said, and the chant changed to a more sympathetic "your job's next". Throughout the day, music, dancing and football defined the mood. Why then was the protest kettled at all?

The standard answer is that kettling ensures that demonstrations remain static, and thus reduces the risk of injuries. Indeed, the police erected a screen which rolled the message "this area is contained to avoid breach of the peace" in deep red letters. Such is the irony of the idea that it's necessary to surround peaceful demonstrators discussing, dancing and singing, with officers equipped with riot helmets in order to maintain peace, it's surprising the screen didn't short-circuit.

But in any case the standard answer clearly doesn't apply to Occupy London; for the majority of the day, demonstrators were free to leave the kettle (at one small cavity). Instead it served to keep the hundreds of people who wished to join the occupation from doing so. Wikileaks founder Julian Assange was prevented from entering the demonstration for over an hour.

Furthermore, the Met issued statements throughout the day 'urging peaceful protesters to leave' St. Paul's. They even resorted to claiming that the area had to be cleared, as the Cathedral needed to prepare for its Sunday service - a ploy that somewhat unravelled when the vicar himself gave the occupation his blessing.

In this light, the reason for the kettle becomes obvious. Excuses of maintaining public order aside, the kettle was there to disperse the occupation - a legitimate protest - entirely. But Occupy London are a tenacious group. Interviewing several tent-owners, I asked how long they were planning to stay; I always received the same answers - "as long as it takes... as long as possible".

The day wore on, and police tactics became more aggressive. By 4pm they had restricted the territory of the occupation considerably, and by 6pm the entire 'general assembly' was confined to the steps of the Cathedral. From there they forced a contingent of riot police behind the assembly, ostensibly to 'defend the Cathedral from damage'. Needless to say, there was never any sign that this was likely.

Compacting the kettle was also achieved in an important manner. I witnessed several times a sergeant circle behind the police line and roar "charge". Though the movement itself would be better described as a determined walk forwards, the distinctly military feel to this command has the desired effect. And that desired effect defines the goal of policing Occupy London: intimidation.

In his speech, Julian Assange described the Occupy movement as "a culmination of dreams". On October 15th, it was surrounded by a culmination of intimidation.

 

Follow Tom Stevenson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TomStevenson_

Standing on the steps of St. Paul's Cathedral, a young man addressed the 'Occupy London Stock Exchange' protest on Saturday. "There is a police line to my left", he said as the crowd repeated his word...
Standing on the steps of St. Paul's Cathedral, a young man addressed the 'Occupy London Stock Exchange' protest on Saturday. "There is a police line to my left", he said as the crowd repeated his word...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mediumal57
Moderate Extremist
09:52 PM on 10/18/2011
There are several ways to look at this aren't there.

One thing to get clear in our minds though is the basic naive error in this fairly modern liberal attitude that the good peoples of the UK have as their birthright a fundamental right to protest.They haven't and never have had. What those in authority have always sought over the centuries is civil obedience to their will - either through encouraging general co-operation, mainly through economic bribery or exercising physical coercion when bribary won't work, Or as is usually the case an (depending on how you look at it) a pleasant or unpleasant mixture of both.

The person in that croud calling on his fellows not to verbally and/or physically confront the police was wise indeed, especially in the current political climate. The police as always are the last people you confront if you wish to change Society. They ultimately will take their orders from whomever is in Power after all. All the laws and policies enacted in history are basically intructions to the police; the army or whatever security forces are deemed necessary to keep order in a country.

I suspect that copper calling on his men to charge was deliberately trying to provoke a reaction. Unfortunately the State, whether they be a duly and legally elected Government or a despotic King cannot always ensure that those that act by their authority and in their name behave wisely themselves.
photo
TheEmptyMonty
President of Antarctica
07:56 PM on 10/18/2011
It would seem to me that the London police are being responsibly vigilant due to the riots earlier this year. I completely support the Occupy Wall Street movement, but I understand the city's apprehension even at a peaceful demonstration. After all, it was a legitimate protest that devolved into an orgy of fire and chaos last time around. I hope everyone keeps a cool head.
12:47 PM on 10/18/2011
I was working with an aboriginal elder at Occupy LSX - he took on the police in his own, peaceful way spreading his messages against greed. Check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ik-UvqhRXZs
photo
European1919
I am the PigmⒶn
06:26 AM on 10/18/2011
It has long been known (at least since Thatcher (ab)used the police to enforce her fascist anti-union policies) that the british police force are not always the friendly Bobby with the weird hat who gives young tearaways a friendly but resounding clip round the earhole.
Recently in the student protests they already showed that tough tactics intended to intimidate and hurt protesters are part and parcel of their arsenal. Apparently they have not learnt from the backlash, including legal proceedings and enquiries, that followed those protests.
This time they again protect the guilty and ruthlessly enforce against the people - who to all intents and purposes not only have public opinion on their side, but also are demanding and defending their rights.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Yorksgal
'Conservative Christian' is a complete oxymoron.
04:45 AM on 10/18/2011
Just who is being upset by the protesters? Who is behind the various police forces that are wanting the police to do their best to intimidate these peaceful groups that are coming together to let the various governments know that the governments are out of control and the ordinary people have had enough.

Be careful governments of the world - from little acorns, mighty oaks do grow.
07:42 PM on 10/17/2011
Im not quite sure what these protesters were looking to achieve? A better idea would be to actually lobby your MP or maybe even take part in these things we have called elections. Its really funny what happens when you take part in democracy and try and change things from the inside, you actually have an effect. Unlike using up all the bin space outside st Pauls and getting very cold.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lukebrambles
08:43 PM on 10/17/2011
Yes, because our MP's have proven themselves trustworthy and shown they truly care about us. Oh no, I forgot. The majority of those that participated in the 'expenses scandal' got a mere slap on the wrist, They have increased the amount of regulation strangling businesses and done nothing about the banks. What a difference electing a tory government instead of a labour government has made.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
VoiceGig
The Speech Experts
07:56 AM on 10/17/2011
Julian Assange spoke about police kettling and then the deconstruction of the law - download his full but short speech on Voicegig at: http://www.voicegig.com/view-speech/1717/deconstruction-/-construction-of-law---occupylsx---st-pauls-cathedral-julian-assange/
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Captai
Get out while you still can!!
05:10 AM on 10/17/2011
Policing is about intimidation. The police mantra is: Dominate. Intimidate. Control.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
momoluvsu
We live in a parallel universe
03:18 AM on 10/17/2011
Excellent article.
01:33 AM on 10/17/2011
thanks for this report. i can find no mention of the intimidating police tactics used during this peaceful protest, in the uk press, not even from those that purport to be left of centre. as ever, we need to rely on foreign observers to get any semblance of objectivity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony Booth
12:52 PM on 10/23/2011
as with the police, the uk media works for the PTB to protect them from the people they continue to abuse.
thank goodness for alternative news sources, they show up the lies of omission of our own lot.