Christmas Food 2015: Good Housekeeping Reveals 'Tried And Tested' Supermarket Guide

Best Christmas Supermarket Foods Revealed By Good Housekeeping
|

Good Housekeeping has released its annual 'tried and tested' guide of where to get the best ingredients for your Christmas dinner.

This year, the authority on supermarket foods can reveal that Aldi is the best British supermarket to go for champagne. Meanwhile your roast turkey should come from Tesco.

Pipping the likes of Fortnum & Masons and Waitrose to the post, Morrisons took the crown for the best smoked salmon.

Open Image Modal

The Good Housekeeping taste test team ate and drank their way through 185 different festive foods from more than 30 stockists.

They managed to pick out the best of the best across 13 categories, including: champagne, prosecco, smoked salmon, turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, Christmas pudding, brandy butter, Christmas cake, mince pies, stollen, mulled wine and stilton.

The retailer with the highest number of winners this year is Morrisons with four winning products out of 13 categories.

Marks & Spencer, Tesco and Waitrose also figured frequently in the top five, along with high street challenger Aldi.

Good Housekeeping's consumer director Caroline Bloor, said: "Our top scorers show that price is no indicator of tastiness. By blind testing a wide range of foods, Good Housekeeping can say with confidence which products taste best and pass that knowledge on to shoppers."

Here are the results of the 'Tried & Tested' Christmas food guide:

Best champagne

  • Winner: Aldi Veuve Monsigny Champagne Brut by Philizot (£12.99 for 75cl)
  • Runner up: Faubert Brut Champagne, from Ocado (£19.99 for 75cl)
  • Best of the rest: Waitrose Blanc de Noirs Brut NV (£21.99 for 75cl)

Best smoked salmon

  • Winner(s): Morrisons M Signature Oak Smoked Salmon with Black Pepper (£5 for 120g) and Morrisons Christmas Tree Smoked Salmon (£3 for 100g)
  • Runner up: Aldi Specially Selected Rowse Honey & Mora Seaweed Smoked Salmon (£2.49 for 100g)
  • Best of the rest: Waitrose Peat & Heather Scottish Smoked Salmon (£6.49 for 140g)

Best prosecco

  • Winner: Waitrose San Leo Brut Prosecco (£10.49 for 75cl)
  • Runner up: Marks & Spencer Prosecco (£9.99 for 75cl)
  • Best of the rest: Aldi Valdobbiadene Prosecco Spumante DOCG (£7.49 for 75cl)

Best mince pies

  • Winner: Marks & Spencer Christmas Star Mince Pies (£2.50 for four)
  • Runner up:Greggs Mince Pies (45p each)
  • Best of the rest: Aldi Specially Selected Mince Pies (£2.99 for six)

Best Christmas pudding

  • Winner: Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference 18 Month Matured Laced with Cognac Christmas Pudding (£8 for 907g)
  • Runner up: Aldi Specially Selected Golden Topped Christmas Pudding (£9.99 for 907g)
  • Best of the rest: The Co-Operative Truly Irresistible Christmas Pudding (£3 for 454g)

Best Stilton cheese

  • Winner: Morrisons M Signature Mature Blue Stilton (£3 for 300g)
  • Runner up: Lidl Valley Spire Mature Blue Stilton (£1.45 for 220g)
  • Best of the rest: Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference Tuxford and Tebbutt Extra Mature (£4 for 454g)

Best Christmas cake

  • Winner(s): Meg Rivers ‘All Over’ Iced Cake (£40 for 1.9kg) and Sainsbury’s Golden Bow Celebration Cake (£18 for 1.7kg)
  • Runner up: Aldi Specially Selected Exquisite Christmas Cake (£9.99 for 1.5kg)
  • Best of the rest: Marks & Spencer Hand Decorate Falling Star Christmas Cake (£20 for 1.46kg)

Best stollen

  • Winner: Bettys Christmas Stollen (£9.95 for 380g)
  • Runner up: Bettys Stollen Bites (£10.95 for 330g)
  • Best of the rest: Lidl Favorina Mini Butter Stollen (£1.99 for 250g)

Best brandy butter

  • Winner: Tesco Courvoisier Brandy Butter (£2.49 for 150g) and The Co-Operative Courvoisier Brandy Butter (£1.85 for 200g)
  • Runner up: Morrisons M Signature Indulgent Brandy Butter (£2.50 for 200g)
  • Best of the rest: Waitrose Christmas Brandy Butter (£1.99 for 200g)

Best turkey

  • Winner: Tesco Bronze Turkey (£20 for 3.6-5kg)
  • Runner up: Marks & Spencer Butter Basted Turkey (£11 per kg, 1.4-2kg)
  • Best of the rest: Morrisons Extra Large M Signature Bronze Turkey (£39 for 5.8kg)

Best stuffing

  • Winner: Tesco Finest Venison And Pork Mulled Wine Stuffing Portions Wrapped In Bacon (£3 for 300g)
  • Runner up: Aldi Specially Selected Cranberry And Apple Stuffing Portions (£2.29 for 300g)
  • Best of the rest: The Co-Operative Truly Irresistible Sage and Shallot Stuffing Slab with Jewelled Fruit and Chestnuts (£5 for 610g)

Best mulled wine

  • Winner: Aldi Gluhwein (£4.99 for 1 litre)
  • Runner up: Marks & Spencer Red Mulled Wine (£6 for 75cl)
  • Best of the rest: Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Mulled Wine (£6 for 75cl)

Best cranberry sauce

  • Winner: Morrisons M Fresh Cranberry Sauce (£1.48 for 300g)
  • Runner up: Tesco Cranberry Sauce (75p for 200g)
  • Best of the rest: Rosebud Preserves Cranberry and Orange Relish with Port (£3.30 for 227g)

Read the full Good Housekeeping Christmas Foods Tried & Tested results in the December issue of Good Housekeeping, on sale 30 October.

27 Christmas Cocktails
Brandy Alexander(01 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Brandy Alexander recipe from HonestlyYUM (credit:Todd Wagner/HonestlyYUM)
Jingle Juice (02 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Jingle Juice recipe by Baked Bree (credit:Baked Bree)
Champagne Cocktail(03 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Champagne Cocktail recipe from Food52 (credit:James Ransom/Food52)
Winter Bourbon Smash(04 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Winter Bourbon Smash recipe from Minimalist Baker (credit:Minimalist Baker)
Autumn Crush(05 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Autumn Crush recipe from Verses From My Kitchen (credit:Verses From My Kitchen)
Holiday Milk Punch(06 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Holiday Milk Punch recipe by Erika Kotite from Food52 (credit:Food52)
Mulled Wine(07 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Mulled Wine recipe from Gimme Some Oven (credit:Gimme Some Oven)
Crimson Bulleit Punch(08 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Crimson Bulleit Punch recipe from Food52 (credit:James Ransom/Food52)
Holiday Mule (Ginger Beer, Gin Or Vodka)(09 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Holiday Mule (Ginger Beer, Gin Or Vodka) recipe from Home Sweet Jones (credit:Home Sweet Jones)
Pear Sonata(10 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Pear Sonata recipe from HonestlyYUM (credit:Todd Wagner/HonestlyYUM)
Maple Old-Fashioned(11 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Maple Old-Fashioned recipe from Food52 (credit:Food52)
St. Germain Pomegranate Spritzers (12 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the St. Germain Pomegranate Spritzers recipe from Minimalist Baker (credit:Minimalist Baker)
Spiced Gløgg With Port Wine And Cointreau(13 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Spiced Gløgg with Port Wine And Cointreau recipe from Food52 (credit:Sarah Shatz/Food52)
Fresh Cranberry Ginger Vanilla Margaritas With Sugared Cranberries(14 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Fresh Cranberry Ginger Vanilla Margaritas With Sugared Cranberries recipe from How Sweet It Is (credit:How Sweet It Is)
Mulled White Wine With Pear Brandy(15 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Mulled White Wine With Pear Brandy recipe from Food52 (credit:Merrill Stubbs/Food52)
Cranberry Cinnamon Cocktail(16 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Cranberry Cinnamon Cocktail recipe from Horrible Housewife (credit:Horrible Housewife)
Holiday Sparkler(17 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Holiday Sparkler recipe from Food52 (credit:James Ransom/Food52)
The Real McCoy Cocktail(18 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the The Real McCoy Cocktail recipe from Verses From My Kitchen (credit:Verses From My Kitchen)
Raspberry Limoncello Prosecco(19 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Raspberry Limoncello Prosecco recipe from Damn Delicious (credit:Damn Delicious)
Cranberry Margaritas(20 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Cranberry Margaritas recipe from Gimme Some Oven (credit:Gimme Some Oven)
Bubbly French 75 Cocktail(21 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Bubbly French 75 Cocktail recipe from FoodieCrush (credit:FoodieCrush)
Cranberry Gimlet (22 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Cranberry Gimlet recipe from Food Fanatic (credit:Food Fanatic)
Spiced Blood Orange And Champagne Punch(23 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Spiced Blood Orange And Champagne Punch recipe from Spoon Fork Bacon (credit:Spoon Fork Bacon)
Hot Buttered Hazelnut Whisky(24 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Hot Buttered Hazelnut Whisky recipe from Adventures In Cooking (credit:Adventures In Cooking)
Mulled Pomegranate Punch (25 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get a Mulled Pomegranate Punch recipe by Holistic Squid (credit:Holistic Squid)
Honey-Pomegranate Mulled Wine(26 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Honey-Pomegranate Mulled Wine recipe by Dinner Was Delicious from Food52 (credit:Food52)
Winter Sangria(27 of27)
Open Image Modal
Get the Winter Sangria recipe from Bakeaholic Mama (credit:Bakeaholic Mama)