Sexism In Dance: Where Are All The Female Choreographers?

'The higher up the ladder you go the less women you see.'
|

Visit most town halls across England on a Saturday morning and you’re likely to find dozens of little girls dutifully standing with their feet in first position. If you’re lucky, you may find one or two boys hidden among them.

A report from the Department for Media, Culture and Sport found that 43.3% of girls between the ages of five and 10 participate in dance-based activities, compared to just 12.2% of boys.

But when you look at the lineup of adults who dominate the most powerful positions in dance, particularly the world of classical ballet, the picture couldn’t be more different.

It’s been 17 years since the Royal Ballet commissioned a work by a female choreographer on the main stage of the Royal Opera House. 

What’s more, just four of the 16 associate artists at Sadler’s Wells are women.

“Early dance is populated with females, yet the higher up the ladder you go the less women you see,” Sharon Watson, artistic director at Phoenix Dance Theatre in Leeds tells The Huffington Post UK.

So what’s stopping women from rising to the top in a field they otherwise dominate?

Open Image Modal
Ken Scicluna via Getty Images

Choreographer Annabelle Lopez Ochoa believes the training young dancers receive may be putting women at a disadvantage to men if they choose to pursue a career in choreography later down the line.

Because there are so few male dancers, they are often encouraged to be individual, whereas young female dancers are trained in the art of appearing as a unit.

“Most of the female choreographers come from contemporary dance. In that world we are more engaged in discussing with directors and choreographers due to the improvisational tools that choreographers use to create their pieces,” she tells HuffPost UK.

“In classical ballet, young ballerinas are not asked to express their thoughts, and opinions about what they dance, they are taught the steps and counts. Hence their speaking and leading skills are left underdeveloped.

“A young classical ballerina who could have a start at a choreographic career at a major company lacks the tools and practice to become a choreographer. And then, for a contemporary dancer, to break through into a classical company, it takes time for directors to notice them, and so there are not so many of female choreographers working in ballet right now.”

Open Image Modal
ENB
Annabelle Lopez Ochoa

Despite the odds, Lopez Ochoa has created works for some of the world’s most renowned dance companies, including Scapino Ballet Rotterdam, Finnish National Ballet and The Washington Ballet. 

She started choreographing aged 11 and decided to focus solely on creating her own pieces when she turned 30. Remarkably, she received her first international commission just two years later. But she acknowledges that if she had been a male dancer, the process may have been even quicker.

“At 42, I can say that I am an established choreographer. It might have taken me longer than my male colleagues but I believe that art needs not just craftsmanship but maturity,” she says.

Watson also has first-hand experience of how difficult it can be for women to rise to the top in dance.

When she joined Phoenix as a dancer back in 1989 she was one of the only female principal performers at the previously all-male, all-black company.

“It was hard work,” she says. We almost had to earn our place even though we were schooled in a similar way to the men.”

Open Image Modal
Phoenix Dance Theatre
Sharon Watson

Even as a dancer, Watson had clear ideas about the direction she thought the company should go in in order to secure funding. But as a woman, it was a constant battle to ensure her voice was heard.

“The women became incredibly powerful people in that group. We had to be, because we were fighting against incredibly powerful men,” she says.

Her transition from dancer and choreographer to artistic director wasn’t smooth. Despite running her own company (ABCD) in the interim and gaining a wealth of experience, Watson was not chosen as artistic director for Phoenix the first time she applied for the position. 

“It was given to a male over a female. It was given to an outsider as opposed to an insider,” she says.

“I had to take myself off and get myself a Masters to prove that there’s an area of my work that is creative and I can think about it.”

When she reapplied for the position in 2009, masters in hand, she was finally given the top spot. But she believes she wouldn't have had to take time out to complete this qualification in the first place if she had been a man.

“It’s not only a question of gender by a question of race as well,” she adds.

“I think I’m probably one of only two black women in the country that’s running a company of this scale. You just think, wow, that’s not right.”

Thankfully, some of Britain’s biggest companies and theatres are finally starting to wake up the fact that this lack of diversity is unacceptable.

In 2012 English National Ballet appointed Tamara Rojo as artistic director. Under her leadership, the company premiered 'She Said' earlier this month - a triple bill dedicated to female choreography.  

Open Image Modal
ENB

Sadler’s Wells is also actively working to showcase more work from female choreographers and directors.

“For a while now we have been aware of how, despite good intentions and some progress in recent years, we still have a long way to go in terms of more effectively supporting women choreographers,” Sadler’s Wells artistic director and chief executive Alistair Spalding tells HuffPost UK.

“We present a varied range of work created by women on our stages every season and one of our artist development programmes, Sadler’s Wells Summer University, is currently supporting 13 women out of a total of 21 artists.

“But we know we need to do even more – which is why we are currently taking part in Advance, a six-month programme led by Tonic Theatre. With their help, we are exploring how we can better support women in sustaining a career in choreography.”

The Arts Council is also making a stand, by saying their funding will be influenced by whether or not companies are working to improve diversity.

"In 2014, we committed our funded organisations to a fundamental shift in their approach to diversity, making them accountable for promoting and developing diversity across their leadership, workforce, programming and audiences," a spokesperson said.

"We measure their progress annually and while some progress has been made, there is still more to be done to ensure that all art and cultural organisations reflect the diversity of their communities."

The Royal Ballet is also making moves in the right direction.

Commissions are about the right fit for the Company, whether male or female,” the company’s director Kevin O’Hare tells us.

“But we do acknowledge that there is some way to go with addressing gender imbalance.” 

While The Royal Ballet may not have commissioned a piece by a female choreographer on the Royal Opera House main stage since Siobhan Davis presented ‘The Strangers Taste’ in 1999, O’Hare points out that it has been engaging with female choreographers since then, albeit on smaller stages.

"A number of female choreographers have presented work at the Linbury Studio Theatre in the Royal Opera House including Mayuri Boonham, Martha Clarke, Aletta Collins, Shonana Jeyasingh and Kristen McNally,” he says.

“When I took up my role as Director of The Royal Ballet in 2012, one of the first things I did was to ask choreographer Crystal Pite to make a new work for the Company, it has taken since then to align our schedules, Pite’s new work for The Royal Ballet will premiere in March 2017." 

In 2015 O’Hare also appointed Charlotte Edmonds as the inaugural participant on The Royal Ballet’s Young Choreographer Programme - an initiative dedicated to enabling emerging talent to gain key skills in becoming a successful choreographer.

The director adds that there are “also many discussions” taking place across the Royal Opera House including “engagement with different groups and diversity related issues”.  

Like Sadler's Wells, The Royal Opera House is currently working with Tonic Theatre to look at gender issues in artistic programming and investigate some of the reasons behind the imbalance.

It all sounds well and good, but Watson says discussions are one thing  - now it’s time for action.

“I’ve heard a lot of conversation, I’ve been part of a lot of discussions, but I don’t know whether there’s yet been a blanket approach to changing the landscape,” she says.

Despite this, Watson says young female dancers should never be afraid to pursue their dreams.

“Very often there’s a jar in the door and if you just crack it you’ll be surprised what’s on the other side,” she says.

For any women thinking of pursuing a career in choreography, Lopez Ochoa gives this advice: “Grow a thick skin because you will be judged.

"Not everything you create will be good or appreciated. Just create because you love it not because others will love it." 

Ballet Dancers Changing the Landscape
Misty Copeland(01 of13)
Open Image Modal
Misty Copeland became the third African American female soloist at the American Ballet Theater back in 2007. Since then, she's spoken openly about racism in the dance world. "[Ballet is] such a traditional and historic art form that people are afraid to change it," she said in an interview with New York Magazine. "But I think it has to if it’s going to last in the world we live in today. It's hard to change someone’s ideas when they might not even really consciously know that they’re being racist, or have racist ideas, just because ballet has been this way for hundreds of years."
Her new Under Armor ad has been making waves online, effectively conveying a contemporary interpretation of what it means to be a ballerina.
Yuan Yuan Tan(02 of13)
Open Image Modal
Yuan Yuan Tan is a principal dancer with the San Francisco Ballet. In the late 1990s she became the youngest principal in the company’s history and the first Chinese dancer to be promoted to that level.
Shannon Harkins(03 of13)
Open Image Modal
Shannon Harkins was 13 years old when The Washington Post called her "the face of African American ballet dancers' struggles." At that time, she was the only African American girl at Level 7 at the Washington School of Ballet -- the highest pre-professional level.
Desmond Richardson(04 of13)
Open Image Modal
Desmond Richardson is the co-founder and co-artistic director of Complexions Contemporary Ballet, a company that seeks to reinvent dance by creating an open environment that embraces multicultural forms of movement. Richardson also performed as a principal dancer at the Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater for seven years.
Natalia Osipova(05 of13)
Open Image Modal
While Natalia Osipova may look like the stereotypical image of a ballerina, her viewpoints express anything but. "I am not interested in sporting diamond tiaras on stage, or having my point shoes cooked and eaten by my fans," she explained to The Spectator this year. "Ballet has evolved and the ballerina figure with it. The world around us offers new challenges, new stimuli and new opportunities, and I believe that it is the responsibility of every artist to be constantly ready to respond to these. There is simply no reason, nor time, to perpetuate century-old clichés, such as the remote, semi-divine figure of the 19th-century ballet star."
Osipova's attitude eschews the celebrity of a glamorous field, and we can't help but love her progressive tone.
Chehon Wespi-Tschopp(06 of13)
Open Image Modal
Chehon Wespi-Tschopp became America's Favorite Dancer back on "So You Think You Can Dance" Season 9. Being the first male contestant to identify first and foremost as a ballet dancer, he brought the art form into the realm of mainstream television.
José Manuel Carreño(07 of13)
Open Image Modal
Born in Cuba, former ABT star José Manuel Carreño is the Artistic Director at the Ballet San Jose. After dancing as the Prince in "Swan Lake" as his final performance, he ventured from New York City to Northern California to lead the financially-troubled company.
Wendy Whelan(08 of13)
Open Image Modal
Wendy Whelan has become something of a figurehead for veteran dancers, advocating for financial support and career services for ballet icons nearing retirement. “We are not supported federally at all once we leave the ballet. There is no support whatsoever, financially or insurance wise for dancers in the United States."
After 30 years at the New York City Ballet, the principal dancer will bid her adieu this October, with plans to continue dancing with the likes of Edward Watson and the folks at Manhattan's City Center.
Cassa Pancho(09 of13)
Open Image Modal
Cassa Pancho is the founder of Ballet Black, a company devoted to inspiring opportunities for "dancers and students of black and Asian descent."
"All through ballet school I was really aware of the lack of black people around me," she explained to The Guardian. "So for my dissertation I thought I would interview black women working in ballet and see what they had to say –- but I couldn't find a single black woman working in ballet, and that really stunned me. When I graduated, I decided, very naively, to do something about it myself."
You can read more about Cira Robinson, Damien Johnson and Sayaka Ichikawa -- all senior artists at Ballet Black -- here. (Photo of the company by Bill Cooper.)
Carlos Acosta(10 of13)
Open Image Modal
Cuban-born Carlos Acosta, a principal guest artist at The Royal Ballet, has spoken openly about the lack of representation in ballet.
“The percentage of classical black ballet dancers around the world is sadly minimal, which is quite embarrassing,” Acosta has said. “In most companies, when a talented black dancer is chosen as a member, they don’t know how to cast them properly. Still, there is this mentality, especially with directors, that a black ballerina in the middle of a flock of white swans would somehow alter the harmony.”
Sylvie Guillem(11 of13)
Open Image Modal
Sylvie Guillem made a name for herself after leaving the Paris Opera Ballet to become an international freelance ballerina. Now in her late 40s, the woman bold enough to appear on the cover of French Vogue nude and without makeup (long before the makeup-free selfie craze) is happily bursting through barriers between the modern dance world and ballet with works like "6000 Miles Away."
Shiori Kase(12 of13)
Open Image Modal
Tokyo-born Shiori Kase is a soloist with the English National Ballet who recently wowed critics in the London staging of the "psycho-thriller" ballet, "Coppélia."
Michaela DePrince(13 of13)
Open Image Modal
Sierra Leone-born Michaela DePrince spent her early years in an orphanage after her father was killed during the civil war in her country. After being adopted by an American family and entering the world of ballet, she was told at the age of eight that America wasn't "ready for a black girl ballerina." Despite her challenging childhood, she's gone on to win a position in ABT's preprofessional division and the Dutch National Junior Company.

Before You Go