Diet Shakes And Soups Should Be Prescribed To Obese Patients, Say Oxford Researchers

Patients lost more weight with low-calorie meal replacement plans than traditional healthy eating.

Meal replacement soups and shakes should be prescribed by doctors to help obese patients achieve significant, sustained weight loss, new research suggests.

The researchers, from the University of Oxford, suggest total diet replacement programmes could ease pressure on GPs treating obesity-related illness.

In the study of UK patients with a BMI over 30, those who ate just 810 calories per day on a meal replacement plan lost an average of almost 24lb (11kg) in one year.

But it should be noted that the study was partially funded by the Cambridge Weight Plan UK, who provided the low-calorie food products.

AkayArda via Getty Images

The trial, published in the British Medical Journal, involved 278 obese adults in Oxfordshire, who were split into two groups. The first were enrolled on a healthy eating GP weight management programme, receiving advice and support from a practice nurse. The second were offered a low-energy total diet replacement plan for 24 weeks.

Participants on the programme, provided by Cambridge Weight Plan UK, reduced their intake to 810 calories a day using specially designed soups, shakes and bars, and also took supplements. They were given these products for eight weeks, before gradually re-introducing normal food, and also received diet counselling. After 12 weeks on the programme, they were encouraged to continue replacing one meal a day with a replacement product.

The study found participants on the diet replacement plan lost an average of 23.6lb (10.7kg) after 12 months, 16lb (7.2kg) more than those on a GP practice programme.

They also had a greater reduced risk of developing heart disease, stroke and diabetes. Almost half (45 per cent) of obese people on the low-energy diet achieved weight loss of more than 10 per cent, compared with just 15 per cent of patients receiving help from their GP.

Lead investigator Professor Susan Jebb, from the University of Oxford, said: “In the past we have worried that a short period of rapid weight loss may lead to rapid weight regain. But this study shows that nine months after the intensive weight loss phase, people have lost more than three times as much weight as people following a conventional weight loss programme.”

Dr Nerys Astbury, a senior researcher in diet and obesity at the University of Oxford, said: “This model of care, where patients are referred to a provider in the community for support, offers the potential for rapid roll-out at scale across the NHS and could help reduce the pressure on GPs in treating obesity-related disease.”

The study was funded by the Cambridge Weight Plan and the National Institute for Health Research.