THE BLOG
18/12/2013 05:14 GMT | Updated 16/02/2014 05:59 GMT

Confusion Within the NHS Regarding the Use of Autism Diagnostic Tools

Anna Kennedy Online, UK - recently produced the survey Autism Diagnosis Survey in the UK, on 14 December. Autism Daily Newscast reported on the findings.

Anna Kennedy Online found that when conducting research into how children on the Autistic spectrum were being diagnosed and what diagnostic tools were being used to do so, there was no consistency within the National Health Service (NHS). It was found that both the diagnostic tools, ICD-10 and DSM-V were being used by health professionals.

Both Austin Hughes who is the training and advice officer and Anna Kennedy spent many weeks researching and writing to different departments within the NHS regarding the use of the Autism Diagnosis Tool. This is the question that Anna asked:

"Are the NHS stating we are using the ICD-10 as a diagnostic tool? If so does that mean that everyone giving a diagnosis within the NHS are required to use it?"

Anna told us that every department that they contacted, even at the very top, either gave a different answer or a reply of 'I do not know'.

Talking exclusively to Autism Daily Newscast Anna shared with us a few of the answers given to her regarding the diagnostic tool and process that she received via email.

Anna received a response from the Office of the National Clinical director for Learning Disabilities, Dominic Slowie, who explained that:

"ICD-10 does determine how clinicians diagnose or treat problems. It is the internationally agreed classification used for statistical analyses of healthcare activity. Usually it is applied by coders to clinical records."

The following was received from the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE):

"Thank you for contacting the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence (NICE) regarding ICD-10. We do not make any specific recommendations on using the ICD-10 as a diagnostic tool however; it is referred to in numerous guidance we have produced such as Autism diagnosis in children and young people or Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. It would be a local Trust decision whether to use the ICD 10 as a diagnostic tool. I am sorry I cannot offer you any further information."

From these findings Anna Kennedy Online believes that 'the action of diagnosing 'Autism' is lacking any direction'. Professionals are trying to define and classify Autism, which is not possible, due to its very nature of it being a spectrum condition.

They add:

"We now have too many cases of people not receiving a diagnosis or having to wait for years of medical in-fighting around them to gain one."

From the survey's findings and subsequent research Anna Kennedy Online state that professionals are confused as to what diagnostic tool to use. They believe that the whole diagnostic system is not clear. They state that the NHS recognise and should use the ICD-10 diagnostic tool but that professionals within the NHS 'state they diagnose to what the DSM-V states and often misunderstanding what is within it.'

Anna Kennedy Online goes on to say that they now have evidence of families whose children have Asperger's Syndrome being told that they would have been given a diagnosis before but now under the DSM-V diagnostic criteria Asperger's' no longer exists.

Anna Kennedy's final words are:

"Bottom line is that Austin, my husband Sean and I have discovered that every Local Authority is allowed to do what they want and pick and choose which tool they use as in Health Professionals very worrying! Different rules for which area you live in."

The Autism Diagnosis Survey in the UK survey results can be found here

This is an article which I originally wrote and posted on Autism Daily Newscast, 17 December.