What do misbehaving students, a bus crash in Coventry, the Tottenham riots and our current government have in common?
The concept of empathy is one I have long been interested in. Differences between students can often be attributed to varying levels of empathy - persistent low level misbehaviour speaks volumes about that particular child's lack of empathy for students around him or her. Generally speaking, the more empathetic a student is, the better their relationship with their peers and the adults around them; it comes as no surprise that these students often achieve more highly than less empathetic students.
Simon Baron-Cohen's brilliant and precise Zero Degrees of Empathy: A New Theory of Human Cruelty had me thinking about the links between empathy and student behaviour. His assertion that certain people exhibit "a pervasive pattern of disregard for and violation of the rights of others that begins in childhood or adolescence, and continues into adulthood" may seem only to apply on the surface to those with diagnosed pathological conditions and yet, as teachers, particularly in urban, deprived areas, do we not see these behaviours exhibited by our poorest behaved students on daily basis? These students turn into the adults of the future, sometimes taking their low empathy levels with them. Some of them become inconsiderate drivers, noisy neighbours, litter-droppers, looters and muggers.
Whose responsibility is it to teach people to consider others, to be more empathetic?
The curriculum (when we have one coherent one) ignores this life skill - it is overlooked by those who design the curriculum, perhaps out of a mistaken belief that it is not a teacher's responsibility to develop levels in empathy in children. We don't explicitly teach empathy; it is a by-product of studying History, Literature, PSHE and RE but it is not something that is taught as a life skill that can mean the difference between success and failure. It doesn't fit onto a league table. It would look odd nestled in the data outlining A*-C grades including English and Maths. And yet, in our society - one that is struggling against a 'me-first' culture highlighted most horrifically by the Tottenham riots - we can't afford to ignore the impact of ignoring this most human of skills.
Recently, in Coventry (a town blighted by the German bombing and then by some poor architectural choices), a bus carrying passengers crashed into a pawn shop, scattering the gold in the window display. I would like to think that if I was on a bus and this had happened, my fellow passengers' first instincts would be to check on each other, to make sure that everyone was safe, out of danger and uninjured. But no: many of the passengers and onlookers began looting the gold, scrabbling in the debris for what they could gather up. They left the scene with their pickings.
When reading this story, I couldn't help but associate it with other instances of disintegrating empathy. Only someone with very low levels of empathy could set fire to buildings that may be occupied during the Tottenham riots; only someone with very low levels of empathy could assault a Malaysian student and pretend to be helping him. Lack of compassion has been very much in the news - a recent study by the journal Psychological Science suggested this week that the less compassionate you are, the less moral you become.
Where, then, does a decreased ability to display empathetic behaviour come from? Have we always been this way? In a lesson with Year 11 students, we were discussing Hamlet. In analysing the line: "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark", my students made the link between the quality and style of leadership and the knock-on effects on state and society. Claudius, the 'king', is rotten and therefore, the country is too. We don't have to travel too far to see the parallels in our own society. Empathy is not a feature associated with the Coalition government, or those appointed by it.
Sir Michael Wilshaw's statement almost sums up my argument: "If anyone says to you that 'staff morale is at an all-time low', you know you are doing something right". When you've finished being astounded by the sheer bullishness of the line, it is hard to find an iota of empathy in that sentence. The sacking of Downhills Primary governing body by Michael Gove can be seen as yet another nail in the coffin of empathy. The act in itself is the result of complex wranglings influenced by the need to demonstrate total control over a system that is powered, ultimately, by human beings with human feelings. Whatever our opinions on school underachievement, the end result leaves onlookers asking uncomfortable questions about the methodology of improvement on such a public scale.
Combine Sir Michael Wilshaw with Michael Gove, add in cuts to services such as domestic violence support charities, whisk in a whole host of measures that adversely affect women and ethnic minorities, and sprinkle liberally with a reduction in public sector pay in the poorest areas and you're left with a potent mix that may account for the unease in communities. It's a recipe that lacks one vital ingredient: empathy.
The inevitable consequence of a right-wing government that is more interested in the stick than the carrot and nothing in between can only lead to a society that reflects their own lack of empathy. Society is a mirror of leadership. I don't imagine the Coalition government sees itself in the Tottenham riots, or the bus passengers that looted the pawn shop - but maybe it should. Maybe it should.
Follow Bansi Kara on Twitter: www.twitter.com/benniekara
Coventry bus crash: Shopworkers' anger at Trinity Street looters ...
Coventry bus crash: Looters 'have brought shame on our city ...
BBC News - Looting after bus crashes into Coventry pawnbrokers
Looting after bus crashes into Coventry pawnbrokers, page 1
'Opportunistic thieves' loot jewellery store after Coventry bus crash ...
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/shreen-ayob/why-politicians-and-youth_b_1339846.html
Watch the TED talk experiment (referenced in the blog) if you haven't already seen it, you'll love it.
---------------------------------------
Please, you are a teacher. Coventry was not ''blighted'' by bombing. It was devastated, much of it destroyed. ''Blight'' used in relation to town planning has a much different, less serious usage. As in ''planning blight''. You appear to be make light of the bombing. ''Blight'' is caused by neglect - not bombs falling from the sky, exploding, destroying buildings and killing and maiming human beings.
They all involve humans convinced that the rendition of realty being artificially generated inside their head is an accurate facsimile of the actual reality occurring outside their head? If not, I give up.
"The concept of empathy "
cannot occur to a consciousness, unless that particular mechanism can conjure up an experience similar to that of the victim.
"Whose responsibility is it to teach people to consider others"
Whose responsibility is it to teach people to ask themselves questions? That could cause them to gain an understanding of their existence, far beyond that superficial grasp they currently have.
"ignoring this most human of skills."
Imagine being a passenger in a ‘plane. The pilot of which does not appreciate those ways that might confuse a correct calculation of position. No need to double check the sums from a different viewpoint. Because an understand of how understanding is achieved, is neither understood nor challenged.
"Where, then, does a decreased ability to display empathetic behaviour come from?"
It droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven. Upon those beneath: it is twice avoided; by those that lead and those that are led.
"'staff morale is at an all-time low' "
Increase punishment until it improves.
"more interested in the stick than the carrot"
Some may be into both.
"Society is a mirror of leadership."
Beware those who have no reflection.
History abundantly illustrates that values that a society and it's leaders emphasize can, in the aggregate, call forward empathy or sociopathic misuse or persecution of others. Empathy is a democratizing awareness that threatens the agendas of those who aim to consolidate unmerited privilege at the expense of others.
The Center for Building a Culture of Empathy
The Culture of Empathy website is the largest internet portal for resources and information about the values of empathy and compassion. It contains articles, conferences, definitions, experts, history, interviews, Â videos, science and much more about empathy and compassion.
http://CultureOfEmpathy.com
I posted a link to your article in our
Empathy and Compassion Magazine
The latest news about empathy and compassion from around the world
http://bit.ly/dSXjfF