Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bansi Kara

GET UPDATES FROM Bansi Kara

London Riots and Looting

Posted: 09/08/11 01:00 BST

"We are what we always were [...] but now the little crazy children are jangling the keys of the kingdom..."

Driving the circuitous route from my home to Islington for lunch and a visit to a bookshop, I notice something odd. I have felt the edginess in the air since Saturday night and the first riot in Tottenham, so dangerously close to where I am. It is only on Green Lanes on the way home, towards Turnpike Lane that I realise what it is. The shutters are down on local businesses. From the moment I notice this, it's like when you notice the first ant. All of sudden, there's another and another. The shops, pharmacists, hairdressers, grocery shops and appliance retailers, all closing at a quarter to five on a Monday. This feels surreal and doesn't ease my considerable fears.

I top up my electricity. My local newsagent, a jolly man, is still open. I ask him what's going on - not only are the local shops closed, but a lot are surrounded by men who look as if they are there to stay. Is this the local community beginning to defend their livelihoods because they know they are in for another night of looting? He replies that he has information that the looting has started on Salisbury Road, not five minutes from where we are. He's closing up and he has family with him, all men, all on phones.

The quotation from 'The Crucible' by Arthur Miller seems eerily resonant now. Whereas Saturday night in Tottenham, there seemed to be a reason for the violence (albeit complex and difficult to digest), the looting we have seen and heard about is predominantly led by young people who have realised simply that if they want to break into a shop in large numbers, in different places, they can and there will be no immediate consequence. In 'The Crucible', the girls who lead the witch hunt, crying out against their neighbours, do so because they can - some tiny power has been handed to them and they have no idea - no regard for - the consequences.

I have seen this before. Anyone who has worked in a school that is struggling to manage the behaviour of large numbers of students knows all too well how easy it is to lose control and have corridors that belong, in essence, to the students. Fortunately for me, I have worked in schools that have been on an upwards turn and haven't experienced this issue on a grand scale. But there are moments, when a fight breaks out between two students - and then there are five, then twelve, then twenty. The only way it stops and the crowd is dispersed is when the adults are adults and arrive to be the responsible force in that corridor. The immediate aftermath is vital - how that fight is dealt with and the message that goes out about what will and will not be tolerated becomes the turning point. A school has to have a policy, but it also has to have consistency and an unequivocal approach to enforcing it - tying in parents, students and staff.

But it is not the most important thing. Good schools and by extension good societies, are built on the every day understanding that adults are in charge.

A very wise man, a headteacher who I won't name here because he'd be embarrassed, often says that the way we show that we are in control is by being present. One teacher standing by themselves in a corridor will not make a difference. Six or seven will. My students do not behave just because I have rules, that is only part of how I maintain order, they behave because they recognise that I will be annoyed, disappointed, angry even, if they disrupt the learning of others. I am the first line of defence, as the adult in the room. The sanctions are what I fall back on. The other thing is that the majority of my interactions with my students are positive - I have spent time building trust, showing that I respect them. This makes the negative interactions easier to diffuse.

Just having laws to deal with disobedience isn't enough. Clearly it isn't. I am watching the news; the youths who have just torched a car in Hackney aren't even wearing masks which would suggest to me that they don't care about the law. None of this is even personal because there are no people - no one has come out to stop the children from looting, no parent has taken their child to a police station to return the goods that they have stolen - and if they have, they are one person in a nation that has forgotten how to be responsible adults. I understand fear, I have had the dilemma of whether to step into an argument between two people on a bus, or whether to ask someone to pick up litter.

But what happens now? The police can enforce laws, but they do not create society - we do - and we are not out there in our own 'corridors'.

When the Prime Minister finally returns to see the images I am seeing now in Hackney, Enfield, Walthamstow and in Brixton and Lewisham, maybe then we will begin to have a wider debate about what we need to do now to build a society that is led by grown ups and not dictated by children. It then needs to be acted on by all of us.

For now, I will wait to see what happens - what else can I do?

This blog can also be read on thenewstateswoman.wordpress.com

 

Follow Bansi Kara on Twitter: www.twitter.com/benniekara

 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:51 AM on 08/10/2011
The UK is a society of strict social and economical classes. Always has been and likely will always be one! Only country still with a strong monarchy and entitled social class. Why are people surprised that that the middle class and lower class youths are pissed off?

Elites are few in number and weak of spine. So the majority wants a greater piece of the pie. Seems normal.
06:25 PM on 08/09/2011
Yes, but it must be led by "grownups" who are not rapacious pirates stealing all the nation's resources for their own use. "Children" respond not just to discipline but to fairness.
photo
HelloFunnyWorld
In Times Of Sorry Leadership.... Cry or Manage Up?
10:30 PM on 08/09/2011
Disk ~
Great insight, great point!

Kids do respond far better to Fairness.

But our World is very 'selective' when it comes to Fairness..... Being Fair with some one and/or.... Treating every one Fairly!
05:45 PM on 08/09/2011
The nationwide riots should not simply be reduced to anti-social criminal behavior. The widespread riots are a manifestation of contentious politics. The riots are symptomatic of deeper austerity problems which the criminal element has been able to ferment.
08:13 PM on 08/09/2011
I don't think the looters and arsonist give a damn about politics.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newshoundmama
My bite's worse than my bark
09:49 PM on 08/09/2011
I believe they give a damn about having little opportunity. And if you're so concerned about the looting of businesses, it would do you well to have an interest in politics that protects all citizens of all classes from being disadvantaged by their own nation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Patricia013
American made - what have you done with my badges?
05:28 PM on 08/09/2011
Still no explanation as to the underlying causes. People....children....call them what you will simply do not gang up and riot for no reason. I'm still waiting to hear the underlying causes of their actions!
06:29 PM on 08/09/2011
Haven't you been reading? Social programs were cut, big banks were bailed out with the money, unemployment in council estates is as much as 70%, and there was a shooting of a black man by white police. There were nonviolent protests and then certain elements escalated them, seeing a chance for looting and perverse expressions of power. Which are attractive if they're all you can hope for, I imagine. People are desperate. There is no way there is "enough to go around" and there was recently the display of a wealth of the royal wedding. It's not a good recipe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Patricia013
American made - what have you done with my badges?
07:09 PM on 08/09/2011
...thank you and YES, I googled and read all that from other sites BUT where does it say that anywhere on huff post??? That was my point!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gateking
05:17 PM on 08/09/2011
Always a good way to advance a genuine discussion is to start with the suggestion to replace the children now in charge. Very helpful. Oh, and mature.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lukebrambles
04:41 PM on 08/09/2011
Can't be condoned, but equally, it can't be condemned.
These are young people out there, not 'kids' but young people, the next generation. They have been reviled and vilified by the press more and more often, with less and less basis. They have been sidelined by politicians, priced out of universities, and left out of the job market.
Why hire a young, semi-skilled person when there are more qualified people out there who've lost their jobs in the recession? This lack of jobs means they become dependant on welfare benifits, and often stay with their parents well beyond there twenties. What else could this situation breed but anger and despair?

So, we have long building anger, despair and resentment. Add to that tension caused by heavy anti-youth policing, and you had a powder keg just waiting for a spark. To those who say that the protests have been hijacked, and they're no longer about just the death of one man, you are entirely right. It is about so much more.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ScarlettMocha
The Truth is Relative, relatively speaking
05:20 PM on 08/09/2011
Thoughtful
06:31 PM on 08/09/2011
Exactly. You cannot expect people to display personal responsibility and initiative in the near-complete absence of opportunity. What you get is despair, frustration, desperation and anger.
02:11 PM on 08/09/2011
Bansi Kara I fully agrre with you. Unfortunately I believe most people are afraid to act even though they really want to. If more adults were present and especially the parents of these kids and young people it would definitely have an effect, granted they do not support the behaviour of their children. Strangers are probably afraid of getting involved in some kind of confrontation. The intentions could be good, but still how do you react if someone in the streets gives you a punch. Do you hit back, defending yourself? Before you know of it, you might end behind bars yourself. I think the adults in these areas ought to meet and make a unified declaration and then go to the streets in larger numbers. Just be present. Not interact.
And yes, where are the parents?
Libber Rose
lastpost
see biography
11:25 AM on 08/09/2011
"now the little crazy children are jangling the keys of the kingdom"
But long before that, they were pointing out that the emperor had no clothes.

"This feels surreal"
You should try asking politicians questions, and when they contradict themselves point out that anomaly. Then watch as their eyes glaze over. Now that’s what I call surreal.

"some tiny power has been handed to them and they have no idea - no regard for -"
rational answers?

"The immediate aftermath is vital"
open public debate? Where those who do not think things through are compelled to do so, in the full view of all.

"it is not the most important thing"
the most important thing, is identifying the most important thing.

"the way we show that we are in control is by"
questioning and re-questioning everything. That way we detect what is awry, all the more readily.

"they behave because they recognise"
how it all works?

"I respect them"
Doesn’t respect breed respect?

"no parent has taken their child to a police station to return the goods that they have stolen - and if they have, they"
were probably arrested for child abuse.

"But what happens now?"
Well, Dave could try a lock-down. That way everything appears calm, while the pressure builds up to the final explosion. Or he could try something altogether alien to his experience of reality.

"what else can I do"
Ask Dave to explain why he calls a republic a democracy, for a start.
10:52 AM on 08/09/2011
For now, I will wait to see what happens - what else can I do?
-----------------------------------------------------
You could think about causes in terms of the values of grown-up society in which greed is commonplace, wealth is worshipped. This may serve you better than creeping towards a premodern position of desiring that adult authority determine the behaviour of children. Britain is not a traditional family: it is a modern society. We are not authoritarian or paternalistic: we are democratic.
01:12 PM on 08/09/2011
It's pre-modern to expect adult authority determine the behaviour of children?

Babies are born no different then they used to be so its pre, post and very now. Though I would ask why parents and community are absent.
04:58 PM on 08/09/2011
As you say, children now are no different for mother times. And I do not mean that families should change - how families behave is their business. But in the public sphere we cannot solve this problem by reverting to premodern authoritarianism.

And again you are right to ask why parents are absent. In many cases, they have never been present.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
09:33 AM on 08/09/2011
The violence of the serfs is always a problem with the rule by the 1000 richest families, and the austerity programs they impose on their people.

No justice, no peace.
photo
HelloFunnyWorld
In Times Of Sorry Leadership.... Cry or Manage Up?
04:08 PM on 08/09/2011
Good observation but we dont think the author is really interested in looking at and addressing such a perspective. Too many "consequences" (to use her own words) in there!!
Consequences and lasting effects that have been ignored, laughed at, dismissed, disregarded and made invisible, for so long now.

For most people it is far easy-er to go with the flow, appease the Upper Ranks and diss the Lower ones, than to hold a mirror up and shine a light on the Ruling Classes. These days - who wants to be called names? A trouble maker? Contentious? Or worse still..... uncivilized??

Watching from across the Pond we are sorry to see this happen. And hope sane-er heads prevail. The Past is catching up with us and our World is truly at the cross roads, a turning point.
However - We are ALL entitled to Live in a Decent World, with Decent Living Conditions. And this requires, for one, for starters, Decent People at the Top, to manage this Planet & all it's Resources in a Decent Way for ALL of us to use & share.
:)

Re: "The violence of the serfs is always a problem with the rule by the 1000 richest families, and the austerity programs they impose on their people."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ScarlettMocha
The Truth is Relative, relatively speaking
05:26 PM on 08/09/2011
Loved it! F&F and badged.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ithaqua
09:30 AM on 08/09/2011
Nor dictated by children. Lol gonna do away with parliament then?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DaveJohnWard
07:21 AM on 08/09/2011
'Ordinary', 'decent' people have a respect for the law, and a concern for the impact of breaking it; loss of a job, the opinions of friends and colleagues and so on. It's clear that those taking part in the riots have none of those feelings. They don't care if they are arrested, indeed it's probably a rite of passage for many. With that being the case it's clear that a different approach is required. Years of 'softly, softly', 'touchy feely' handling has led us on a path with this inevitable conclusion.
It's time for the silent majority to stand up and be counted, we need to reclaim our streets and communities, and not stand quietly by when we see wrong being done. New York's rejuvenation started with the 'no broken windows' programme, we need to expand that to zero tolerance for law breaking.
The rioting in broad daylight that was seen yesterday clearly showed that they rioters have no fear, we need to make them afraid again. The police cannot do this on their own, it has to come from within the community.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newshoundmama
My bite's worse than my bark
02:06 AM on 08/09/2011
Those young people are in the 'corridors'. . . and maybe they are the lesser of two evils. The ones out of control are the so-called leaders of society ( I don't mean the police, really. They're more henchmen). But the real anarchy, the real corruption and lawlessness that we're seeing on a global scale are in the corridors of the powerful. I see what's happening in London right now as symptomatic of the greater ills that are being visited upon ordinary people throughout the world. . . it can't be condoned, but I won't condemn it, either. You can't stomp on the dignity of a town, a country, a people or a populace and think you won't get a reaction. This reaction hasn't been nearly what it could or should be. . .Global leaders have spoken clearly. . . they're daring us to a global revolution.

You say you want a revolution . . .

. . .and you might just get one.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ithaqua
06:07 AM on 08/09/2011
F + f
08:12 AM on 08/09/2011
Revolution is not burning and looting your local businesses. We are fortunate to have witnessed a few revolutions in the Middle East and that was not the form they took. These are young people using the killing of a man by the police as an excuse to run around like sociopaths and hooligans. It's all good fun to them but the cost of the damage to peoples lives is very real. We don't need to tolerate this crap or sugar coat it.

This is not a noble rebellion against the powers that be, it is the heartless destruction of their own neighborhood. I am not surprised the police are standing by as it goes on because this is where the poor people life. They will let them burn down their town but if these young boys decide go downtown I am sure justice will be swift and merciless.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newshoundmama
My bite's worse than my bark
03:12 PM on 08/09/2011
Sometimes burning and looting is just burning and looting, I won't disagree there. But other times, it's the start of something that snowballs into a real uprising . . .and none of us should be surprised if that is touched off by what's happening now. For further reference, please see Earlier in 2011, Egypt, Tunisia, et all AKA Arab Spring. . .