Mum Criticises Clarks For Placing 'Inferior' Back To School Shoes In Their Girls' Section

'What messages are you giving to my daughter?'

A mum has criticised Clarks claiming their back to school shoes are “aggressively marketed” at boys, in a way that may be off-putting to girls.

Jemma Moonie-Dalton, from London, said she was “dismayed” by the choice of school shoes for her seven-year-old daughter.

“In the boys’ section the shoes are sturdy, comfortable and weather-proof with soles clearly designed with running and climbing in mind,” she wrote on Facebook to Clarks on 8 August.

“In contrast, the girls’ shoes have inferior soles, are not fully covered and are not well-padded at the ankle. They are not comfortable and are not suited to outdoor activities in British weather.”

Moonie-Dalton continued: “What messages are you giving to my daughter? That she doesn’t deserve shoes that put her on equal ‘footing’ with her male peers?

“That she should be satisfied with looking stylish whilst the boys are free to play and achieve in comfort?

“That she shouldn’t try and compete with boys when they play chase – girls’ shoes aren’t made for speed, so perhaps girls aren’t either?

“These messages may not be explicit, but they are there, and are insidious.”

The mum said she was “deeply angered” by Clarks’ “persistent discrimination”.

Writing openly to the retailer, she continued: “As market leaders you have an opportunity to lead the way by designing and marketing shoes for 21st century children.

“I look forward to your detailed consideration of my letter, and until I hear a satisfactory response I will be sharing my concerns with a wide audience.”

The Facebook post had more than 33,000 likes and 13,000 shares, and it received nearly 6,000 comments in less than two days.

Speaking to HuffPost UK, a spokesperson for Clarks said: “Clarks has a gender-neutral ethos that anyone can choose any style they would like.

“Over the past few seasons, following customer feedback and market research, we have focused on creating more unisex shoes and we are looking at a number of elements of our business to promote this gender neutral ethos, both on our website and within our stores.

“As a large global company, it is not always possible to implement all the changes we want to make as quickly as we would like.

“However, we are looking to move as fast as we can to ensure this ethos is reflected throughout our brand.

“Today we have more unisex styles in our range than ever before.

“This means we now have a wider range of closed-in styles, school boots and Gore-Tex styles and these changes will continue in our Spring/Summer 2018 range, which has been designed with an entirely unisex approach.

“In addition, in September we will roll out a new format in some of our stores, where the whole kids department will be unisex with shoes displayed by ‘story’, rather than gender.”

Before You Go

Back To School Stationery 2017
Wave Pencil Case(01 of21)
Open Image Modal
The essential item to hold all stationery in one place. Paperchase has so many different patterns, but this brightly-coloured piece stood out for us.
Price: £7.
Buy: Paperchase, click here.
(credit:Paperchase)
Pack Of 12 Pencils(02 of21)
Open Image Modal
A pack of 12 pencils with eraser nibs - essential for your child's pencil case.
Price: £1.
Buy: Tesco, click here.
(credit:Tesco)
Pack Of 24 Coloured Pencils(03 of21)
Open Image Modal
No pencil case is complete without a set of coloured pencils. This set has 24 shades and is a bargain at under a fiver.
Price: £3.99.
Buy: WHSmiths, click here.
(credit:WHSmiths)
Mini Stationery Set(04 of21)
Open Image Modal
We love this back to school mini set from M&S including many of the essentials: A stapler, sellotape, scissors, sharpener, plastic clips and a pencil.
Price: £5.
Buy: M&S, click here.
(credit:MS)
Tropical Large Pencil Case(05 of21)
Open Image Modal
If your child has coloured pencils as well as pens to fit in their pencil case, maybe go for a larger one? We absolutely love the print on this tropical-themed zip-up case.
Price: £12.95.
Buy: Ohh Deer, click here.
(credit:Ohh Deer)
Scented Highlighters(06 of21)
Open Image Modal
A fun addition to your child's stationery hoard - and they'll be useful if your son or daughter is in secondary school and has a lot of reading to do. Oh, and they're scented!
Price: £3.50.
Buy: Smiggle, click here.
(credit:Smiggle)
Handwriting Pens(07 of21)
Open Image Modal
These pens have an ergonomic grip and quick-drying ink, so are great for kids in the later years of primary school.
Price: £2.99.
Buy: Cult Pens, click here.
(credit:CultPens)
Gel Pens(08 of21)
Open Image Modal
Gel pens have the power to make homework more interesting. These fine-pointed pens start from £1.
Price: From £1.
Buy: MUJI, click here.
(credit:MUJI)
Doodle Notebook(09 of21)
Open Image Modal
Depending on whether your child is in primary or secondary school, they might find having a spare notebook handy. A great place to store homework notes, deadlines and important dates at school.
Price: £3.95.
Buy: Ohh Deer, click here.
(credit:Ohh Deer)
Compact Maths Set(10 of21)
Open Image Modal
If your child is heading to (or already at) secondary school, it's extremely likely they'll need a maths set. This handy compact case has a ruler, protractor and compass, along with a sharpener, too.
Price: £1.49.
Buy: Ryman, click here.
(credit:Ryman)
Eraser Set(11 of21)
Open Image Modal
It's so much more fun when rubbers are colourful and different shapes. These six rubbers fit in a pineapple-shaped box.
Price: £1.75.
Buy: Wilko, click here.
(credit:Wilko)
Pukka Pad(12 of21)
Open Image Modal
If your son or daughter is studying different topics in secondary school, they might find it useful to have a project notepad that will separate out sections for different subjects.
Price: £5.33.
Buy: Staples, click here.
(credit:Staples)
Personalised Pencils(13 of21)
Open Image Modal
Does your child have a birthday before they head back to school or do you want to get them a treat? These personalised pencils aren't cheap, but they are fancy. 12 in a pack.
Price: £11.99.
Buy: Dotty About Paper, click here.
(credit:Dotty About Paper)
Double Sharpener(14 of21)
Open Image Modal
It's small, practical and cheap.
Price: 35p.
Buy: Morrisons, click here.
(credit:Morrisons)
BiC Biros(15 of21)
Open Image Modal
Just like pencils are a staple in the pencil case, so is a pack of standard biro pens.
Price: £1.50.
Buy: Asda, click here.
(credit:Asda)
Pritt Stick(16 of21)
Open Image Modal
Always handy - whether they're sticking worksheets into their books or doing crafty projects, you can't go wrong.
Price: £2.
Buy: Asda, click here.
(credit:Asda)
A4 Folder(17 of21)
Open Image Modal
This folder comes in a range of colours. It's great for storing worksheets, ideas for a project or revision notes.
Price: £1.25.
Buy: Wilko, click here.
(credit:Wilkinsons)
Sticky Notes(18 of21)
Open Image Modal
These sticky notes can be helpful to mark important pages in books, write down little reminders or make a homework page look even more interesting.
Price: £3.50.
Buy: Paperchase, click here.
(credit:Paperchase)
Scientific Calculator(19 of21)
Open Image Modal
A must-have for secondary school students for GCSE maths (and no, we don't know what all the buttons mean anymore, either).
Price: £11.99.
Buy: Casio, click here.
(credit:Casio)
Design Your Own Diary(20 of21)
Open Image Modal
Some secondary schools provide diaries/planners for the pupils, and some don't, but they're helpful for putting in homework deadlines and lessons. TOAD diaries allow you to completely customise how you want your planner to look, including the start month, the words on the front and how the week looks.
Price: £12.36.
Buy: TOAD Diaries, click here.
(credit:TOAD)
All In One School Box(21 of21)
Open Image Modal
Would you rather get everything in one big package? Postboxed has created a back to school gift box including a notepad, pencil, colouring pencils, a pencil case AND sticky notes. Oh and it's free delivery.
Price: £25.95.
Buy: Postboxed, click here.
(credit:Postboxed)