Mum Whose Child Died After Being Turned Away By GP For Being Late, Calls For Change On 'Good Morning Britain'

'You should be seen if it’s an emergency.'
|

The mother of a five-year-old who died of an asthma attack after being turned away from a GP appointment because she arrived late, is calling for a change in the way emergency appointments are handled. 

Shanice Clark, who was with her daughter Ellie-May when they arrived 10 minutes late to the appointment back in January 2015, said she wished she stood her ground at the time. “I think there needs to be procedures put in place that emergency appointments don’t get turned away ever, especially children,” Clark said on ‘Good Morning Britain’ on 9 March.

“Whether you’re five minutes late or half an hour late, you should be seen if it’s an emergency and that needs to happen.” 

Open Image Modal
GMB
Ellie-May’s grandma Brandi Clark (L) and mum Shanice Clark (R).

During Ellie-May’s inquest in February 2018, Clark told of how she requested a home visit when her daughter, who had a history with asthma, began wheezing. She was given an emergency appointment 25 minutes later. She arrived five minutes late for the 5pm appointment and was speaking to the receptionist at 5.10pm. She was told she had to return in the morning.

According to the BBC, the coroner said a chance to “provide potentially life-saving treatment was missed”.

Speaking of the day she was late to the appointment, Clark said: “I was angry more than anything. I was a few minutes late but I thought she still should have been seen. At that point, we were in the surgery, she was walking and she was talking and her breathing had improved, so at that point I wasn’t too worried.

“So I just took her home, I thought if she gets any worse I’ll take her to the hospital. As soon as she did get any worse, that’s what I did, I rang 999 straight away.”

The mum said she wished she had reacted differently, and put her foot down, demanding to see a doctor before she left. Ellie-May’s grandma Brandi Clark was also on the ITV morning show, “I was annoyed. She’s a little girl, she had a history,” she said. “You think, that’s what doctors are supposed to do.” 

Aneurin Bevan University Health Board provided a statement to GMB which was read out on air: “Our thoughts remain with the family of Ellie-May. We fully investigated this matter and subsequently made a referral to the General Medical Council who investigated in accordance with their procedures.”

‘Good Morning Britain’ is on ITV on weekdays from 6am - 8.30am.

Before You Go

What To Do If Someone Is Having An Asthma Attack
What To Do If Someone Is Having An Asthma Attack(01 of11)
Open Image Modal
(credit:Alamy)
Step One(02 of11)
Open Image Modal
Ask if they have their reliever inhaler (usually blue) and where it is. You may need to get it out of their bag for them. (credit:Alamy)
Step Two(03 of11)
Open Image Modal
Encourage them to take one to two puffs of their reliever inhaler. (credit:Alamy)
Step Three(04 of11)
Open Image Modal
Make sure they are sitting up. (credit:Alamy)
Step Four(05 of11)
Open Image Modal
Encourage them to take slow and steady breaths. (credit:Alamy)
Step Five(06 of11)
Open Image Modal
Keep them calm and reassure them. (credit:Alamy)
Step Six(07 of11)
Open Image Modal
If they are still not feeling better after two minutes they can take two puffs of their reliever again and continue to do so every two minutes (up to a maximum of 10 puffs). (credit:Alamy)
Step Seven(08 of11)
Open Image Modal
If they feel better, they should be OK to carry on with their day - but make sure they see a doctor as soon as possible (ideally the same day). (credit:Alamy)
Step Eight(09 of11)
Open Image Modal
If at any time you are worried about them, call an ambulance. (credit:Alamy)
Step Nine(10 of11)
Open Image Modal
If after 10 minutes they don't feel better and their inhaler doesn't seem to be helping them, then call an ambulance. (credit:Alamy)
Step 10(11 of11)
Open Image Modal
If the ambulance hasn't arrived after 10 minutes then the sufferer should repeat Step 6, until help arrives. (credit:Alamy)