British Sailor Lewis Bennett Pleads Guilty To Killing Wife At Sea

Lewis Bennett and Isabella Hellmann had been married for just three months.
Lewis Bennett
Lewis Bennett
Broward Sheriff’s Office/PA

A British sailor who reported his new wife missing from their sinking catamaran has pleaded guilty to her manslaughter.

Lewis Bennett and Isabella Hellmann had been married for three months when she went missing off the coast of Cuba in 2017.

On Monday, he admitted a charge of involuntary manslaughter at a change of plea hearing in Miami, Florida after US prosecutors reduced a charge of murder.

The couple started their expedition in St Maarten in April 2017, before sailing the catamaran Surf Into Summer to Puerto Rico and Cuba. They then left for their home in Delray Beach, Florida.

According to court documents, experienced sailor Bennett was awoken on 15 May 2017 when he heard a loud noise while resting in their cabin.

He said he climbed to the exterior of the boat and observed that the sails and rigging were loose, the helm of the vessel was unmanned, and his wife – who had limited emergency sailing procedure knowledge – was not there.

Lewis Bennett and Isabella Hellmann had a child together
Lewis Bennett and Isabella Hellmann had a child together

Bennett said he could not recall whether he called out for his wife and he did not deploy flares to illuminate the area in order to look for Hellmann or to signal his position in the open water.

The court heard Bennett – a dual British-Australian national – did not search for his wife with either the catamaran or the attached dinghy, nor did he immediately activate any emergency equipment or raise the alarm.

He later abandoned the 37ft vessel and boarded the life raft. Expert testimony found the vessel had been deliberately sunk by allowing water into the hull.

It was not until Bennett boarded the life raft that he called for help and reported his wife missing, approximately 45 minutes after he woke up in the cabin.

Hellmann’s body has never been found.

Prosecutors initially alleged he murdered her and deliberately scuttled the vessel to end his “marital strife”, thus inheriting her apartment where they lived in Delray Beach and the contents of her bank account.

Investigators also discovered that Bennett was smuggling rare coins during his rescue, which they alleged could have been a further motive to kill her.

The couple's catamaran
The couple's catamaran

Bennett had reported the coins, worth nearly ÂŁ30,000, as being stolen from a former employer in St Maarten a year earlier.

He admitted transporting the coins and is currently serving a seven-month jail sentence.

Bennett faces a maximum eight-year prison term when he is sentenced next year.

Attorney Fajardo Orshan said: “Although nothing can ever erase the pain and suffering caused by Lewis Bennett’s criminal acts, the US Attorney’s Office and our law enforcement partners hope that the defendant’s admission of guilt is a step toward justice for the victim, Ms Isabella Hellmann, and her family.

“The federal government remains committed to the safety and security of our US citizens, whether they are at home in South Florida or travelling on the high seas.”


What's Hot